Will Corey Sobczyk leave 'Temptation Island' with Amanda Spain-Butts? Fans say 'sorry not sorry Erin'

'Like I love seeing a person work on themselves and redeem themselves but man if Corey left with Amanda I'd be like "that's fair she's literally the best person here" #temptationisland," expressed a fan
PUBLISHED APR 14, 2021
'Temptation Island' fans are rooting for Corey Sobczyk and Amanda Spain-Butts relationship over Erin Smith (USA Network)
'Temptation Island' fans are rooting for Corey Sobczyk and Amanda Spain-Butts relationship over Erin Smith (USA Network)

When Corey Sobczyk first set foot on 'Temptation Island' his self-confidence and self-esteem were at rock bottom. The 25-year-old concierge manager felt that he had to compete for his girlfriend Erin Smith's attention, and couldn't help but wonder if he was good enough for his extremely attractive and super athletic girlfriend. The couple came on the island so that Corey could prove to Erin that he was the perfect man for her. 

After spending countless hours crying and moping about his relationship with Erin, Corey finally seems to be in a place to accept that he shouldn't have to compete for attention in a relationship. Luckily for him, Amanda Spain-Butts, a single on the island, recognized the potential in Corey and firmly stood by him and helped him rediscover his confidence and self-esteem. 

RELATED ARTICLES

Erin Smith and Corey Sobczyk's Relationship Timeline: 'Temptation Island' Season 3 couple sparks breakup rumors

'Temptation Island': Is Corey Sobczyk sad because of Erin Smith's new date? Fans say he's 'too good' for her

'Temptation Island' star Corey Sobczyk felt that he had to always compete for attention from his girlfriend Erin Smith (USA Network)

On the latest episode of 'Temptation Island,' the contestants had to pick a partner for the overnight date. Corey made an extremely wise decision by choosing Amanda, and spending the evening with her. While talking to each other Corey expressed how although Erin is an amazing person he never felt like he was enough for her, on the other hand, he pointed out how he felt confident and safe with Amanda. 

He also shared how he wants his partner to feel afraid of losing him which he felt was lacking in his relationship with Erin. Amanda then declared her interest in Corey and told him that she was extremely fond of him and would love to be the person who helps him feel his best. The couple's chemistry and connection left fans rooting for them and hoping that Corey would leave the island with Amanda instead of Erin.

A fan tweeted, "Corey leave with Amanda PLEASE!! #TemptationIsland." Another fan echoed similar thoughts with, "Corey should leave with Amanda #TemptationIsland."



 



 

'Temptation Island' fans believe that Amanda Spain-Butts brought out the best in Corey Sobczyk unlike his girlfriend Erin Smith (USA Network)

"I think Amanda & Corey are a cute & more even keeled couple. #TemptationIsland," commented a fan. "Like I love seeing a person work on themselves and redeem themselves but man if Corey left with Amanda I'd be like "that's fair she's literally the best person here" #temptationisland," expressed a fan.



 



 

Fans also felt that Amanda was better suited for Corey compared to Erin. A fan shared, "I hope Corey leaves with Amanda, sorry not sorry Erin #TemptationIsland." "I think Corey might be leaving with Amanda, Erin might've changed too late #TemptationIsland," seconded a fan.



 



 

Who do you think Corey will leave 'Temptation Island' with? Let us know. 'Temptation Island' Season 3 airs every Tuesday at 10/9c only on USA Network. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

As 2025 comes to a close, it is worthwhile to take your pick from any of the movies listed below for the perfect cosy NYE
6 hours ago
Marvel recently officially released the second 'Avengers: Doomsday' teaser featuring Chris Hemsworth's Thor
12 hours ago
The ‘Predator’ saga takes a daring turn as its latest chapter heads to digital, bringing a dangerous alien world and high-stakes survival home
14 hours ago
Director Emma Tammi's comments suggest fans may have to wait a little longer for the third installment
14 hours ago
The sci-fi flick, serving as the standalone sequel to 'Tron: Legacy,' hit theatres this October
1 day ago
Rumors suggest a fifth trailer in the offing after the previous reports stated four new teasers
1 day ago
The fantasy feature will be available to buy on Prime Video starting at midnight ET on December 30
1 day ago
Directed by Australian filmmaker Michael Shanks, the movie takes co-dependency to its extreme while skilfully combining the nightmarish elements of body horror
1 day ago
'Avengers: Doomsday' has so far released three new teaser trailers and is expected to drop a fourth
1 day ago
Directed by Johannes Roberts, the film follows a group of friends terrorised by a violent chimpanzee
1 day ago