Did Aaron Hernandez really cheat on Shayanna Jenkins? 'American Sports Story' portrayal is close to the bone

FX's 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' explores the rise and fall of NFL star Aaron Hernandez
Things gets tense between Aaron Hernandez and Shayanna Jenkins in 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' Episode 7 (@fxnetworks)
Things gets tense between Aaron Hernandez and Shayanna Jenkins in 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' Episode 7 (@fxnetworks)

Contains spoilers for 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez'

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: From the outset of FX's American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez, the show seeks to portray Aaron as someone who unintentionally falls into self-destructive behavior. Created by Stu Zicherman, the sports drama delves deeper into the turbulent personal life of NFL superstar Aaron Hernandez. While the show expertly depicts the hidden aspects of Aaron's life, it is strongly indicated that Aaron's anguish at being unable to be with Chris Taylor (Jake Cannavale) leads to his erratic decisions.

However, no matter what problems Aaron was facing, his fiancée Shayanna Jenkins (Jaylen Barron) has always been there for him without expectations or conditions. But, the new parents eventually engaged in a heated argument, causing the fight to escalate. 

Why did cops end up at Aaron Hernandez's doors in 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' Episode 7?

A still from 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' (@hulu)
A still from 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' (@hulu)

In the seventh episode of 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez,' Aaron's star are not shining brightly as he relapses into drug usage despite his best efforts, prompting him to contact Chris for a meeting where they end up spending personal time. However, Shayanna, who had been quiet about Aaron's activities, finally confronts him when she discovers he passed out in the restroom when he was meant to be caring for their baby. In a heated dispute, Shayanna accuses him of adultery with another woman, which enrages Aaron and causes him to hit a vase, scaring Shayanna.

However, things quickly escalate when cops arrive at Aaron's doorstep and ask Shayanna whether she feels comfortable. While Shayanna indicates that she is secure and there is nothing to worry about, it is not surprising, but the cops did end up at Hernandez's doors twice. Now, if you think that the sequence is just the figment of the maker's imagination, in that case, you are wrong, Aaron was involved in two aggressive domestic incidents in one week, as per The Wall Street Journal. Despite these disturbances, Aaron was never arrested, and Shayanna stayed in the house after assuring the police she felt safe.

Did Aaron Hernandez cheat on Shayanna Jenkins in real life?

Josh Andrés Rivera and Jaylen Barron in a still from 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' (YouTube/@fxnetworks)
Josh Andrés Rivera and Jaylen Barron in a still from 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' (YouTube/@fxnetworks)

Shayana highlighted Aaron's alleged adultery during Odin Lloyd's murder trial, revealing that she discovered suspicious phone messages and briefly left their house, according to ABC News. However, the couple decided to work through their challenges and stay together.

Furthermore, in the days preceding Aaron's death, rumors circulated regarding his interactions with men. A source close to Aaron said that Shayanna was his genuine love as per People. According to the insider, Aaron was attracted to guys, but his love for Shayanna was real, and he considered her his soulmate.

Where is Shayanna Jenkins these days?

Shayanna Jenkins continues to support Aaron Hernandez even years after his death (YouTube/@abcnews)
Shayanna Jenkins continues to support Aaron Hernandez even years after his death (YouTube/@abcnews)

Following Aaron's untimely death, Shayanna continued to care for their daughter Avielle. Shayanna also gave birth to a daughter with her fiancé, Dino Guilmette, according to Radar. Shayanna and Guilmette had their daughter on June 15, one year after Aaron's demise.

As time passes, Shayanna continues to defend Aaron, portraying him as a loving individual. Guilmette had played for the New England Patriots alongside Hernandez.

How to stream 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez'?

Josh Rivera in a still from 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' (@fx)
Josh Rivera in a still from 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' (@fx)

You have several options for viewing 'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' on FX. FX is available on YouTube TV for $72.99 a month, with a free trial. Hulu includes FX in all of its packages, which start at $7.99 per month. Hulu also offers a free trial to new and qualifying repeat users.

FX, on the other hand, is available for purchase or rental on Amazon Prime Video. FXNOW is free, but you'll need a cable or satellite TV subscription to utilize it

'American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez' trailer



 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘Chicago Fire’ star Taylor Kinney shares the date for the franchise’s next crossover, which will bring all three NBC dramas together
2026-11-12T08:52:55.000Z
James Reynolds reveals his Parkinson’s diagnosis and explains why ‘Days of Our Lives’ is bringing it into Abe Carver’s storyline
2026-11-12T08:23:38.000Z
Charlie Vickers and his ‘The Rings of Power’ co-stars hint at Sauron’s next move and the Season 3 moments that left even the cast struggling for words
2026-11-12T07:50:09.000Z
Nearly three decades after their 1997 horror film, Jennifer Love Hewitt and Ryan Phillippe are sharing the screen again, this time in the ‘9-1-1’ franchise
2026-11-12T06:55:17.000Z
The Hulu spinoff follows nine MomTok creators in California, with Jen Affleck as the lone original star
2026-11-12T05:10:11.000Z
FX’s comedy series ‘Adults’ follows five friends sharing a home in Queens as they navigate adulthood
2026-11-12T04:36:21.000Z
‘Chicago Fire’ Season 15 Episode 6 introduces Violet’s estranged mother, whose unexpected return comes with devastating news
2026-11-12T04:24:26.000Z
A leadership change at DC Studios left the status of the Kyle Chandler and Aaron Pierre series in question
2026-11-12T04:05:49.000Z
'Chicago Med' Season 12 Episode 6, titled 'Lessons in Chemistry,' sees Freddy return to sign Margaret's estate papers alongside Charles
2026-11-12T03:18:28.000Z
Netflix’s ‘The Body’ explores teenage identity, friendship and repression, with its creators drawing inspiration from their own school years.
2026-11-12T03:00:28.000Z