'Return to Amish' fans call Jethro Nolt 'selfish' as he reveals shocking reason for leaving Sabrina Burkholder

Jeremiah Raber and his wife Carmela accompanied Sabrina Burkholder to the doctor's office because Jethro Nolt was missing from the picture
'Return to Amish' star Sabrina Burkholder accuses Jethro Nolt of deliberately hurting her (@sabrina_returntoamish/Instagram/TLC)
'Return to Amish' star Sabrina Burkholder accuses Jethro Nolt of deliberately hurting her (@sabrina_returntoamish/Instagram/TLC)

SARASOTA, FLORIDA: Things have taken a dramatic twist in 'Return to Amish' Season 7 as Sabrina Burkholder recently had a pregnancy scare. In the last episode, Jeremiah Raber and his wife Carmela accompanied her to the doctor's office because Jethro Nolt is missing from the picture.

However, in the March 28 episode of 'Return to Amish', Jethro is back! Sabrina called Jethro after having an anxiety attack at the doctor's office because she found blood in her underwear. This pregnancy scare compelled Jethro to return and reveal the reason he is always leaving her. Keep reading to find out the reason.

RELATED ARTICLES

'Return to Amish' star Fanny Schmucker feels betrayed as Rosanna Miller gives her cold shoulder

Who was Jeremiah Raber's father Larry? Truth behind 'Return to Amish' star's biological dad who was murdered


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Sabrina Burkholder (@sabrina_returntoamish)


 

'Her refusal pissed me off'

While Sabrina was heavily pregnant with their child, Jethro left her for 4 weeks. This has raised a lot of red flags. Jeremiah had said time and again that he is very angry at Jethro for doing this again to Sabrina. Well, it seems Jethro is done with running away as he has returned, but for how long is anybody's guess? Viewers are dying to know why he up and left Sabrina like this and even Sabrina questions Jethro on his return. She accused him of doing this deliberately to "hurt" her.

So Jethro confessed that when she refused to marry him again, he was "pissed" and said, "I just need to get away and get some time to myself and think." Sabrina believes Jethro would rather run away than face pain and that's why she can no longer trust him. For now, the couple seems to be mending things.

'Return to Amish' 2023: Who has the kids, Sabrina Burkholder or Jethro Nolt? (TLC)
'Return to Amish' Season 7 star Jethro Nolt's marriage proposal got rejected by Sabrina Burkholder (TLC)

Fans dub Jethro Nolt a 'piece of s**t'

'Return to Amish' viewers have some very strong opinions on Jethro's return and his tendency to leave Sabrina. They are not his fans right now and have expressed their anger on Twitter as one said, "Why is Jethro even here? He is useless." Another one shared a gif saying, " What a piece of s**t." One more tweeted, "Jethro is way too selfish."



 



 



 

Fans of the show have also expressed that Sabrina needs to stop letting Jethro back in and should not have any more babies with him. One fan said, "Sabrina and Jethro need to stop having babies together!" Another said, "Jethro is not important - he doesn’t need to be there." One more added, "Jethro gives abusive vibes."



 



 



 

'Return to Amish' Season 7 airs new episodes every Tuesday at 10 pm ET on TLC.

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'Landman' Season 3 invited cheerleaders and students to participate in its production
2026-11-16T10:02:15.000Z
‘Virgin River’ scores an eighth and ninth season on Netflix
2026-11-16T08:34:37.000Z
‘The Chosen’ Season 6 has an unusual release plan as the final two episodes get a theatrical release
2026-11-16T07:27:40.000Z
Dennis Haysbert makes his 'The Gilded Age' debut as Dr. Harris, whose unexpected connection with Ada could lead to a new romance.
2026-11-16T06:50:02.000Z
With the upcoming holiday season, CBS has changed the schedule for its fan-favorite shows
2026-11-16T05:51:02.000Z
‘Tracker’ Season 4 Episode 6 leaves Mel’s mother’s death unexplained as Colter Shaw agrees to investigate the mystery
2026-11-16T05:46:28.000Z
The 'Victorious' spinoff is coming back, with 12 more episodes already filmed and their titles revealed.
2026-11-16T05:04:42.000Z
‘Marshals’ Season 2 Episode 6 reveals what happened to Troy, but his killer remains unidentified
2026-11-16T04:51:14.000Z
With 'Slow Horses' Season 7 set to arrive in 2027, Olivia Cooke shares an emotional update about the spy thriller's future
2026-11-16T04:00:07.000Z
Robyn Coffin has launched a GoFundMe campaign to help cover expenses during her cancer treatment
2026-11-16T03:42:38.000Z