'Murder at Blackthorne Manor' Review: Lifetime film is a brilliant homage to classic murder mysteries

The film revolves around Hayley who enjoys her job creating murder mystery parties at the famous Blackthorne Manor
Christie Leverette and Bobby Slaski in 'Murder at Blackthorne Manor' (Lifetime)
Christie Leverette and Bobby Slaski in 'Murder at Blackthorne Manor' (Lifetime)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Murder mysteries have a charm of their own. As cinema has evolved, there have been many changes in how crime fiction has been perceived by audiences and filmmakers, and many sub-generes have been created around the it, including virtual and real-time crime dramas. 'Murder at Blackthorne Manor' just released on Lifetime, and the film pays homage to the many films that have been created around the genre. The script is simple and has some jumpscares to offer, but sadly doesn't do much for one's imagination.

The film's cast did a good job of convincing audiences of its potential, but the film still doesn't shine after an hour of play. The cast includes Christie Leverette, James . Pierce III, Veronica Martell and Bobby Slaski in the lead roles.

READ MORE

What day and time will 'Secret Society of Lies' release on Lifetime? Everything you need to know

'Vacation Home Nightmare': Here's everything to know about Lifetime thriller

Be careful who you trust

'Murder at Blackthorne Manor' comes across like a simple murder mystery where you're sure who the murderer is. And in the end, you're right, too. The film follows Hayley who enjoys creating murder mystery parties at renowned Blackthorne Manor. But when the manor's owner is found dead, Hayley and her colleague must sort through a house full of suspects to identify the murderer. Hayley is claustrophobic and suffers from nyctophobia. The plot explores itself and the characters, showing every element of the character that can be used later in the story. On one of the mystery weekends, the owner of the house, Charles Benedict (James A Pierce III), is murdered. Hayley doesn't know what to do and is the first to discover the body. The best part of the plot is that Hayley and her team don't tell the guests of the mystery game throughout the movie. So when the guests think that the plot has been greatly enhanced, they're actually dealing with a real murder.

Christie Leverette in 'Murder at Blackthorne Manor' (Amazon Prime Video)
Christie Leverette in 'Murder at Blackthorne Manor' (Lifetime)

Doesn't hit the spot

The production strives for a plot that will produce the best crime story, but fails drastically. Even the cinematography fails, and the entire film is a dark shade of blue. Crime music plays in the background throughout the film, but without a great plot, even that is a failure. You do see the characters running and trying to find answers, but they do not do it very well. And it's pretty incredible how the guests do not know what's going on and still think it's all part of the game. Although the plot and production had their intentions in the right place, the plot let the whole film down along the way.

All in all, you should watch 'Murder at Blackthorne Manor' and develop your own theories and ideas about it. The film is available exclusively on the Lifetime channel.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The final San Diego Comic-Con 2026 costume reveal has shifted ‘Avengers: Doomsday’ fan theories away from Elizabeth Olsen's Wanda Maximoff
1 hour ago
Hayley Atwell says Peggy Carter returns in a 'very different light' in 'Avengers: Doomsday' after seven years
4 hours ago
Marvel took over Comic-Con Saturday, announcing the casting of Ryan Gosling as Ghost Rider
5 hours ago
‘Black Panther’ director Ryan Coogler revealed that 'The Long Walk' actor would take on the lead role in the film
7 hours ago
Miami may be the backdrop in ‘72 Hours’, but most of the movie came to life somewhere completely different. Here is the full filming story.
2 days ago
‘Her Private Hell’ is Nicolas Winding Refn's first film in 10 years
2 days ago
Netflix's new Kevin Hart comedy has barely arrived, but fans already want more. Is ‘72 Hours’ 2 on the cards, or is this wild ride over?
2 days ago
Michelle Hadley’s life was upended by a shocking case of false accusations and identity theft, as explored in ‘A Toxic Love Story.’
2 days ago
The first official trailer for Zach Cregger's ‘Resident Evil’ teases a terrifying night in Raccoon City and a desperate fight for survival
3 days ago
Robert Pattinson leads A24's 2006-set drama about the making of 'To Catch a Predator' ahead of its Venice screening.
3 days ago