'Love & Death' on HBO Max: Why was Candace 'Candy' Montgomery acquitted of murder charges?

A psychiatrist testified that Candy Montgomery started to hit Betty Gore with an ax and only stopped 'at the point of utter exhaustion' due to childhood trauma
PUBLISHED APR 27, 2023
Elizabeth Olsen in a still from 'Love & Death' (HBO Max)
Elizabeth Olsen in a still from 'Love & Death' (HBO Max)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: The story of Candance "Candy" Montgomery has been recreated many times by several streaming services. While the cast changes in every adaptation, the crime story remains spine-chilling and still brings out many questions about the case. The case is as interesting as it is frightening. There are many layers to the murder that ensued on June 13, 1980. The case isn't just about a decision or a reaction that happened in the heat of the moment, but a psychological reaction that brought back many memories for Candy and her childhood. This was presented in court as a disassociative reaction that was brought back because of a bad childhood memory. 

The story of Candy Montgomery was previously told by Hulu's miniseries 'Candy' and now HBO Max is retelling the tale of love, affair, and murder through their platform. The cast of 'Love & Death' consists of Elizabeth Olsen, Jesse Plemons, Lily Rabe, and Patrick Fugit in the lead. 

RELATED ARTICLES

'Love & Death' on HBO Max: The real-life story behind David E Kelly's latest show starring Elizabeth Olsen

'Love & Death' on HBO MAX: Release date and how to watch

Housewife Candy Montgomery found not guilty of killing neighbor Betty Gore

The part of the story that still baffles people after so many years is the fact that Candy confessed to killing Betty Gore under hypnosis and also came out to confess about having an illicit affair with her husband Allan Gore. But she was found not guilty by a jury on October 29, 1980.

There is a grounded reason for her drastic reaction to killing her best friend, which goes back to her childhood days. If you've learned anything from 'Mindhunter', you must know that a criminal or a murderer doesn't just happen one night while one is having a cup of tea. There are many psychological things that are always happening in the background that triggers one bad memory and lead someone to take drastic action. Although all these hypotheses don't really change the fact that Candy is a killer, they do shed some light on the psychological aspect of a crime. 

Elizabeth Olsen as Candy Montgomery in HBO Max's original limited series 'Love & Death' (YouTube/ HBO Max)
Elizabeth Olsen as Candy Montgomery in HBO Max's original limited series 'Love & Death' (YouTube/ HBO Max)

A childhood trauma trigger 

Candy was under hypnosis where she confessed to killing Betty but there were more revelations that took place. She also shared that Betty was the one who attacked her first and who cut her toe after a fight erupted between the two women when Betty confronted Candy about her affair with Allan.

The psychiatrist testified that Candy started to hit Betty with an ax and only stopped "at the point of utter exhaustion" because Betty told her to "shush" as they tussled over the ax. A rage took over Candy when Betty asked her to be quiet. Something took over her after the word "shush" was uttered by Betty and that brought back a deeply rooted childhood trauma response that led Candy to hit Betty with the ax 41 times. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Several binge-worthy shows are releasing this January—our list of unmissable shows, including the 'GoT' prequel and a delectable crime caper.
1 hour ago
From Ashford’s tourney grounds to whispered legends, 'A Knight of Seven Kingdoms' Episode 1 showed us plenty of 'Game of Thrones' Easter eggs.
2 hours ago
Everything you need to know about ‘nursing home OG’ Judy Ann Prachyl as ‘Landman’ Season 2 comes to an end
3 hours ago
Created by Stan Lee, Jack Kirby, and Don Heck, the eight-episode series is scheduled to premiere on Tuesday, January 27
4 hours ago
'A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms,' adapted from 'Tales of Dunk and Egg,' takes place between the events of 'House of the Dragon' and 'Game of Thrones.'
5 hours ago
Taylor Sheridan is leaving Paramount and joining NBCUniversal, starting an eight-year movie deal in March 2026
7 hours ago
After the season 2 finale, season 3 looms as 'Landman' locks in its return and familiar faces line up for another round of power shifts
8 hours ago
Finn Wolfhard's latest hosting gig on 'SNL' also featured his 'Stranger Things' co-stars Caleb McLaughlin and Gaten Matarazzo
9 hours ago
Futures flip fast in the 'Landman' Season 2 finale as danger, power shifts, and a new company set the stage for what comes next
9 hours ago
The stakes are higher than ever as a secret audio hints at Tommy's possible betrayal of his father, Richard Roper
10 hours ago