'Judges were unfair': 'AGT: Fantasy League' fans slam Mel B and Simon Cowell for being overly critical of Darci Lynne's act

'AGT: Fantasy League' fans felt that Darci Lynne's performance was a 'natural evolution for her act' but the judges were too hard on her
PUBLISHED JAN 23, 2024
'AGT: Fantasy League' viewers slam Simon Cowell and Mel B for being hard on Darci Lynne (YouTube/@agt)
'AGT: Fantasy League' viewers slam Simon Cowell and Mel B for being hard on Darci Lynne (YouTube/@agt)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Darci Lynne received a warm reception from the audience at the 'America's Got Talent: Fantasy League' Season 1 studio when she performed.

This time, Lynne took her ventriloquist skills to a whole new level. During her act, she flaunted her vocal skills in front of the judges. Along with this, she even played an electric guitar.

After her performance, the 'America's Got Talent' winner received mixed feedback from the judges. 

Heidi Klum gave a standing ovation to Darci after her performance and said, "Darci I think you are absolutely fantastic and I'm glad you didn't abandon Petunia all the way because this is how we fell in love with you. I'm so happy that you are back here on our stage."

Mel B added, "Your beauty is you and Petunia's voice, your voice, and Petunia's voice. You know who I mean. That's what captures America's heart. I almost love the simplicity of what you were doing back then, and I just feel like the music and everything overshadowed what you're still good at."

Simon Cowell said, "You know what, Darci, I'm gonna agree with Mel. There are very few people in the world who could do what you do. The singing and the ventriloquism together is what I call your USP (Unique Selling Point) and I think we were distracted away from what you do brilliantly."

Cowell continued, "The good news is it's not down to us. It's down to the audience."

Soon after, the fans of the show began calling out the judges for being so hard on Darci Lynne.

A Reddit user said, "I thought it was a natural evolution for her act. The judges were unfair."

Another user chimed in, "Yeah, I was honestly afraid she'd change it TOO much, so i was glad she didn't go too far. they kind of overdid it in the criticism because she still included her other talents, as well."

Another user shared, "Agree. It wasn’t deviating from her specialty (like Simon said), but rather incorporating new things into something wholly unique."

A user quipped, "I am NOT a Howie fan but he got it so right when he was explaining how she wanted to grow. She did great."

One user commented, "I had been thinking for years I wonder what she'd do as she got older because she'd have to at least somewhat change some things around."

'AGT: Fantasy League' contestant Darci Lynne's act consisted of different elements like singing and ventriloquism (YouTube/@agt)
'AGT: Fantasy League' contestant Darci Lynne's act consisted of different elements like singing and ventriloquism (YouTube/@agt)

Was 'AGT: Fantasy League' star Darci Lynne hesitant to perform in front of people?

Lynne had a natural inclination for singing since she was young, but she was reluctant to sing in front of people. Her parents encouraged her to overcome her shyness by participating in the 2014 International Cinderella Scholarship Program, which led to her being crowned International Mini Miss.

While participating in the competition, Lynne got to meet Laryssa Bonacquisti, who held the International Teen title and was a ventriloquist. This encounter inspired Lynne to also pursue ventriloquism.

In March 2016, Darci performed on the television show 'Little Big Shots'. During her appearance, she sang the song 'I Want to Be a Cowboy's Sweetheart' alongside her puppet named Katie.

'AGT: Fantasy League' star Darci Lynne was hesitant to perform in front of people (YouTube/@agt)
'AGT: Fantasy League' star Darci Lynne was hesitant to perform in front of people (YouTube/@agt)

Darci Lynne made history by becoming the youngest contestant to win 'AGT'

In 2017, Lynne, who is a skilled ventriloquist and singer, competed on 'America's Got Talent' and impressed Mel B enough to receive a Golden Buzzer. Lynne went on to win the season, becoming the youngest winner in the history of the show at just 12 years old.

The 'AGT' winner gained over 67 million views on AGT's YouTube channel and received the highest number of votes ever for a final performance on the show. She won over the American audience with her likable personality and exceptional talent.

In 2019, Lynn also showcased her talent on 'America’s Got Talent: The Champions.'

Darci Lynne made history by becoming the youngest contestant to win 'AGT' (YouTube/@agt)
Darci Lynne made history by becoming the youngest contestant to win 'AGT' (YouTube/@agt)

How old is Darci Lynne right now?

Darci Lynne was born on October 12, 2004, which means, she is 19 years old right now.

Lynne is going to turn 20 later this year.

Darci has literally grown in front of our eyes as she was only 12 when she came on 'AGT' and now, she is about to enter her twenties. 

'AGT: Fantasy League' star Darci Lynne is 19 years old (YouTube/@agt)
'AGT: Fantasy League' star Darci Lynne is 19 years old (YouTube/@agt)

'America's Got Talent: Fantasy League' airs every Monday at 8 pm ET on NBC.

RELATED TOPICS AMERICA'S GOT TALENT (2006) SIMON COWELL

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Netflix is rebooting 'Star Search' with a live, interactive format and a trio of A-listers joining the judges' table for the iconic talent show's return
4 hours ago
'The Masked Singer' deviated from its two-seasons-per-year format in 2025 when it skipped the fall season
21 hours ago
Peacock launched 'The Traitors' official podcast with Boston Rob and Bob the Drag Queen to unpack every betrayal, banishment, and twist
1 day ago
Old accusations resurface in the ‘Sister Wives 1-on-1’ trailer, proving the Browns’ emotional breakup is far from truly settled.
1 day ago
A subtle moment on 'Uncloaked' has sparked fresh theories about the identity of the 'Secret Traitor' hiding beneath the 'Red Cloak'
2 days ago
‘RuPaul’s Drag Race’ Season 18 launches with a high-stakes design challenge, a show-stealing guest judge, and fierce first impressions from 14 queens.
4 days ago
Netflix lifts the veil on Palm Beach’s most exclusive circles as ‘Members Only’ reveals the rules, rivalries, and secrets of elite society.
7 days ago
'The Road' on CBS featured 12 new voices judged by country music stars Keith Urban and Blake Shelton
Dec 22, 2025
Celeb guests include Singer Zac Brown and YouTuber MrBeast, with Jeff Probst returning as the host
Dec 18, 2025
Season 49 of the survival reality show concluded with Savannah Louie winning the competition
Dec 18, 2025