This ‘DWTS’ star has come painfully close to winning many times — but has only won once

Noone knows the pain of losing the mirrorball trophy better than one ‘DWTS’ pro who has 'accepted' her losing streak.
Dancers perform at the 'Dancing With the Stars' stage at The Grand Ole Opry on February 20, 2025 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by Leah Puttkammer)
Dancers perform at the 'Dancing With the Stars' stage at The Grand Ole Opry on February 20, 2025 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by Leah Puttkammer)

Noone knows the pain of losing the mirrorball trophy better than ‘DWTS’ pro Witney Carson. It’s one thing to lose in the middle of the competition, but going home empty-handed after reaching the finale stings. Carson has experienced this several times! In Season 31, she and her partner, Wayne Brady, finished third. 2 seasons late, Carson came in third again with Frankie Muniz. In Season 27 and 28, she grabbed second place with Milo Manheim and Kel Mitchell respectively. The dancer did win the coveted trophy once, but it was 10 years ago with the show’s current co-host, Alfonso Ribeiro.



 

In an interview with CinemaBlend, Carson opened up about her unfortunate losing streak on ‘DWTS.’ “You know what, I've just accepted it. I've accepted that I'm maybe just second place forever,” she said with a laugh. She added, “Everybody is like, ‘I wanna win, I wanna win,’ and obviously I wanna win.” However, that’s not her first priority. “I feel like now in my career it's more about just creating very unique and amazing routines,” Carson added. On the show, her only focus is to do her job every week and have a 'good time' doing it.


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Witney Carson McAllister (@witneycarson)


 

It’s been a decade since Carson has won the ‘DWTS’ title, but her focus has remained the same. Carson’s secret to paving her way to the finale is: “Pushing the boundaries of my celebrity and not necessarily worrying about the outcome.” Although she admitted that victory is never completely out of her mind, but it is the least of her worries. “I want to win and that would be amazing. But for me, it's just better to think about what I'm doing and just staying in the moment,” she explained.



 

Carson also competed in the show’s recently concluded 33rd season. She and her partner, the two-time Super Bowl champion, Danny Amendola, made it to the finale. No surprise. The duo performed a Viennese waltz to ‘Gravity’ by John Mayer and won over the judges. Before advancing to the finale, Amendola spoke about his journey in the show. “Each week, it feels like we're assigned the impossible,” he said in an episode, as reported by The Providence Journal. “And by the end of the week the impossible feels obtainable,” he added.



 

He also acknowledged that some people see him as the underdog of the competition and made his peace with it. He said, “I think it's fair that I'm seen as the underdog — I have no dance experience. I love that title because I get to prove people wrong.” Before their Waltz performance, Carson revealed that their routine had a storyline similar to their previous contemporary routine, which became a 'breakthrough' for the contestant. “So he's gonna have to dig even deeper and really perform the best of his ability,” Carson said at the time.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The latest ‘Special Forces’ episode featured three unexpected exits and two challenges
1 day ago
The show's host, Julie Chen Moonves, shared the big announcement after the Season 28 winner was revealed
1 day ago
Drew, Taylor, and Rick went head-to-head in the finale of the fan-favorite CBS reality show
1 day ago
'Survivor 51' Episode 2 brings a shocking injury, shifting alliances and a Tribal Council vote that changes the game.
2 days ago
With all 13 teams having an Express Pass, the competition show raised the bar.
2 days ago
The upcoming season of the social experiment will feature a new group of Boston singles looking for love
2 days ago
Part 3 of the Final HOH will determine which two of the three finalists enter the Final 2.
2 days ago
After a few teams used their Express Pass, one team was eliminated after arriving last at the final Pit Stop of Leg 1.
2 days ago
In the latest episode of 'The Challenge: Cutthroat,' TJ Lavin announced a special twist: Trial by Combat
2 days ago
'Below Deck' returns to Thailand with seven new yachties, crew romances and workplace tensions aboard Azul V.
3 days ago