'Homicide: New York': Netflix series revisits 5 notorious, spine-chilling New York murders

The Netflix series delves into the details of five notorious and spine-chilling murders that took place in New York
UPDATED MAR 20, 2024
A still from 'Homicide: New York' (Netflix)
A still from 'Homicide: New York' (Netflix)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Netflix has officially released the docuseries 'Homicide: New York', which delves into the infamous murders that have plagued New York City throughout its history.

Through archival footage and interviews with experts, the series explores the most notorious cases and their impact on New York City.

'Homicide: New York' revisits five infamous murders that have left a lasting mark on the history of the city.

Netflix's docuseries from Dick Wolf follows a format reminiscent of 'Law & Order,' chronicling the crime and its subsequent investigation.

The series sheds light on various criminal cases across five episodes, offering a platform for those directly involved or who witnessed the events to share their narratives. 

Are the stories depicted in 'Homicide: New York' inspired by true events?

All episodes of 'Homicide: New York' are based on real-life stories, drawing from actual crimes and cases that have occurred in New York City. 

In this chilling true-crime docuseries, detectives and prosecutors revisit some of their most challenging homicide cases, offering viewers insight into the complexities and difficulties of these investigations.

'Homicide: New York' Episode 1

In 'Homicide: New York' Episode 1, the storyline centers around the tragic event of the execution-style shooting of Jennifer Stahl, aged 39, and four of her friends.

 As a death investigator in New York City, Barbara Butcher was tasked with investigating the case.

Media coverage of the shooting of Stahl and her friends intensified when it was revealed that Stahl was an up-and-coming actress, dancer, and singer.

 Andre Smith and Sean Salley were separately convicted of fatally shooting three people and wounding two others.

'Homicide: New York' Episode 2

'Homicide: New York' Episode 2 centers around the murder of Michael McMorrow, a case that occurred over four decades ago.

McMorrow, a 44-year-old aspiring musician, was brutally killed by two 15-year-old students from a prestigious private school in New York City.

The teenagers, who were enrolled in an upscale Manhattan prep school, lured McMorrow to Central Park under the pretense of buying drugs from him, before proceeding to kill him.

'Homicide: New York' Episode 3

'Homicide: New York' Episode 3 delves into the disappearance of Eridania Rodriguez, a 46-year-old cleaning lady, within a downtown high-rise.

On July 7, 2009, Rodriguez went missing after her shift at the building. Detectives started to uncover clues and unravel the mystery surrounding Rodriguez's disappearance.

Rodriguez's body was discovered on the 12th floor of the building, bound, hogtied, with her hands behind her back, and her mouth duct-taped.

On July 17, 2009, the perpetrator was convicted and sentenced to 25 years to life in prison.

'Homicide: New York' Episode 4

'Homicide: New York' Episode 4 focuses on the violent stabbing death of millionaire Howard Pilmar in his Midtown office.

In March 1996, Pilmar's body was discovered in his office, lying in a pool of blood. He had been stabbed over 40 times. NYPD detectives struggled to identify anyone with a sufficient level of animosity or hostility that would motivate them to commit murder.

Roslyn Pilmar and Evan Wald were later sentenced to 25 years to life in prison after being convicted at trial for the murder of Roslyn's husband, Howard Pilmar, in 1996.

'Homicide: New York' Episode 5

'Homicide: New York' Episode 5 revolves around East Harlem Rapist, a criminal who instilled fear in the upper Manhattan neighborhood for over seven years.

Viewers are introduced to a serial rapist and killer named Arohn Warford, who wreaked havoc in the East Harlem neighborhood in the 1990s. 

He received a 20-year prison sentence for the rape charge and is currently serving his sentence at Attica Correctional Facility.

What is the plot of 'Homicide: New York'?

Official trailer screengrab from 'Homicide: New York' (Youtube/@Netflix)
Official trailer screengrab from 'Homicide: New York' (Youtube/@Netflix)

'Homicide: New York' emphasizes the most gripping element of every true crime series: personal narratives from those intimately connected to the cases.

The docuseries delves into infamous crimes that gripped New York City, offering perspectives from the detectives and prosecutors who faced these harrowing events firsthand.

Family members also provide detailed explanations and insights into the cases, shedding light on the profound impact of these crimes on their lives.

All episodes of 'Homicide: New York' currently streaming on Netflix.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

In Season 3, Kitty has her heart set on New York University, while Min Ho wishes to pursue a career as an entertainment manager in Seoul
42 minutes ago
The latest episode of the medical drama series finds Dr. Charles overwhelmed after a series of stressful events, leading to his eventual breakdown.
1 hour ago
Lamar Odom's life comes under renewed attention, including his net worth, after the release of his Netflix documentary
1 hour ago
The 'One Chicago' shows on NBC are affected, along with other networks like ABC, CBS, and Fox, to air President Trump's live address to the nation
2 hours ago
Kate Bishop faced Kingpin in a fight that didn't have a conclusive winner, but why is she seen missing from 'Daredevil: Born Again' Season 2?
16 hours ago
Pippa Fitz-Amobi began her adventures on the debut season of 'A Good Girl's Guide to Murder' by investigating mysterious disappearances in her town.
18 hours ago
As ‘High Potential’ nears its finale, secrets around Roman, tangled relationships, and a risky case hint at answers that could change everything.
18 hours ago
In 'Daredevil: Born Again' Season 1, this fan-favorite character teamed up with Daredevil to bring down Wilson Fisk, but has not been seen since.
18 hours ago
James Clarke (Jon Beavers), a suburban father, turns to Colter Shaw's exceptional skills for his help in the latest episode of 'Tracker.'
19 hours ago
Noah Kahan made a major breakthrough following the release of 'Stick Season,' which he later turned into an album.
19 hours ago