An 'American Idol' contestant messed up the lyrics, but fans still had her back for one major reason

Lionel Richie lauded the contestant's performance despite her forgetting the lyrics mid-performance
PUBLISHED MAY 7, 2025
Breanna Nix in a screenshot from 'American Idol' (Cover image source: YouTube |  American Idol)
Breanna Nix in a screenshot from 'American Idol' (Cover image source: YouTube | American Idol)

The stakes are getting higher with each passing episode of 'American Idol' Season 23. As the competition moves into the Top 7, the contestants are leaving no stone unturned to leave a mark. However, amidst fierce competition, one contestant made a major mistake during her performance. Despite this major hiccup, fans couldn't help but rally behind her for her stellar vocals.

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - OCTOBER 02: (L-R) Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood and Ryan Seacrest attend the
(L-R) Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood, and Ryan Seacrest attend the 'American Idol in New York City. (Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by Mike Coppola)

During 'American Idol' season 23 on Monday, May 5, the theme of the night was the Judges' Song Contest, where Carrie Underwood, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan each selected a song for every contestant to perform. The contestants then chose one of the three songs without knowing who picked it, as per American Songwriter. After securing a spot in the Top 8 with her performance of Adele's 'Water Under the Bridge,' Breanna Nix chose to sing Martina McBride's 'Independence Day,' which was Bryan's pick.



 

Nix's other options were 'The Blessing' and 'Dangerous Woman.' Bryan complimented Nix on her performance, saying her voice had the "Martina McBride purity," which she displayed perfectly. Richie called the performance "out of the stratosphere," while Underwood praised Nix for her recovery after missing a couple of notes. Turns out, Nix forgetting about lyrics mid-performance has also gone unnoticed by the fans, who flocked to X to share their opinion.



 

A fan said, "Breanna sounds great but it’s a shame she messed up the lyrics! Ugh! Girllllll. I'm still voting for ya!" while another added, "Breanna's strong vocals make up for those misses lyrics tonight. It surprised me though. Nerves will get you." A fan remarked, "I still voted for her as well! Even the big dawgs in the game mess up lyrics!" Another noted, "Breanna got an EASY pick right in her wheelhouse w/ Martina McBride's "Independence Day" and SHOULDN'T be going anywhere (but I STILL HATE THIS EPISODE b/c it ALWAYS DE-VOLVES into a judges' bravado fest rather than concentrating on the CONTESTANTS)." 



 

Notably, along with her stellar performance at her 'American Idol' audition, her introduction as "just a stay-at-home mom" and the appearance of her adorable son Emerson also stole the spotlight. Underwood gently corrected Nix, telling her not to say "just a stay-at-home mom" and reminding her that she has the "most important job." Since that touching moment, Nix's confidence has grown significantly. In an exclusive interview with Parade, the 25-year-old from Denton, Texas, shared her transformation.



 

"I do feel like I belong now," Nix said. "When I first came into 'American Idol,' I was hoping that I would just get through the audition and not even get to the point of getting a Golden Ticket, but just to make it through that moment. Now that I'm in the Top 14, over every round, I feel like I've learned a little bit more about myself. Believing in yourself is really weird, but it’s a powerful thing. And I'm so happy that I’m finally able to experience it." The birth of her son was the life-changing event that inspired Nix to audition for 'American Idol.' Having always been the "big girl," she realized in the delivery room at 315 pounds that she needed to change her lifestyle to give her son the best life possible. That decision sparked a journey of self-love and growth, showing her she could accomplish her dreams.

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

A quiet conversation reveals a shocking truth about the Others and may hold the key to stopping the Joining as ‘Pluribus’ heads into its finale
14 minutes ago
'The Beauty' teaser introduced an ensemble cast of Ashton Kutcher, Rebecca Hall, and Evan Peters alongside Bella Hadid and Anthony Ramos
1 hour ago
As 'Stranger Things' heads into its final episodes, cast hints and dark teases raise fears that not everyone will survive
1 hour ago
Yasmin and Harper take the spotlight in electric trailer ahead of the show's January 11 release
12 hours ago
Fans have already been talking about a potential love story between Bode and newcomer Chloe
13 hours ago
The finale saw him pip runner-up Channing Wilson and third-place Cassidy Daniels
16 hours ago
‘Heated Rivalry’ stuns fans as Episode 5 earns a rare perfect IMDb score, putting the queer drama in the same conversation as TV’s all-time greats
16 hours ago
The key art features Okarun and Momo, along with Turbo Grammy, against the backdrop of Bamora donning her Kaiju suit
18 hours ago
The 'I Love LA' stars Sennott as Maia, an ambitious influencer manager balancing complex personal and professional relationships
19 hours ago
‘Black Clover’ returns in 2026 with a dark new trailer, signaling Asta’s most dangerous battles are finally about to begin.
22 hours ago