'Love Island': Cashay Proudfoot and Aimee Flores head for another love triangle

'How come I feel like they are always putting Cashay and Aimee with the same guys for drama. Ughhh #loveislandusa,' wrote a 'Love Island' fan
'Love Island' stars Cashay Proudfoot and Aimee Flores (CBS)
'Love Island' stars Cashay Proudfoot and Aimee Flores (CBS)

It's not just love that gets tested on 'Love Island', even friendships often get tested on CBS's hit reality dating show. When Season 3 contestant Cashay Proudfoot was feeling very low due to the love triangle she found herself tangled in with Melvin Cinco Holland Jr and Trina Njoroge, she found comfort and solace in Aimee Flores' friendship.

Aimee patiently heard out Cashay's woes and cheered her friend into not giving up on finding love. So when Isaiah Harmison entered the villa she actively encouraged her friend to pursue him. Unfortunately, while Cashay's love life is finally beginning to pick up, Aimee's was beginning to fall apart when she learned that her partner Jeremy Hershberg was going around telling people that they were just friends. So, when Isiah picked Cashay during the recoupling and the new couple began kissing each other, it broke Aimee's heart.

RELATED ARTICLES

'Love Island': Is Aimee Flores a VIRGIN? Shannon's bombshell has fans playing sex sleuth

'Love Island' fans threaten to quit watching show if Cashay is sent home during recoupling

'Love Island' stars Isaiah Harmison and Cashay Proudfoot (CBS)

Aimee felt that Cashay should have been there for her, and was also a bit upset that her best friend was kissing the guy she liked right in front of her. Thankfully, before another love triangle situation arose between Isaiah, Aimee and Cashay, things quickly diffused. Aimee sat down and spoke to Cashay and explained that she wouldn't interfere between them if Cashay was really interested in Isaiah. Just as things were returning to normalcy, new islander Wesley Ogsbury was thrown into the mix.

Wes entered the villa with his eyes firmly set on Aimee, but since he met Cashay he was smitten by her too. He took both the ladies out on a date. At this point, both Aimee and Cashay are interested in Wes, leading to yet another love triangle. When fans saw this, they were unhappy to see the best friends getting into a fight over a guy. A fan tweeted, "#loveislandusa cashay please leave Wes for Aimee. Stick to Isaiah. I'm tired of this love triangle nonsense every time." Another fan wrote, "Not Aimee and Cashay being in a love triangle again #LoveIslandUSA." 



 



 

'Love Island' stars Aimee Flores and Wes Ogsbury on a date (Love Island/ Twitter)

Many fans also began wondering if the show's producers were orchestrating the love triangles with Cashay. A fan shared, "The whole Cash vs Trina thing was probably a plot. Now they’re attempting the Aimee vs Cash scenario. #LoveislandUSA." "But why do they have my girl Cashay in this messy triangle w Aimee pursuing the same men again though ?! #LoveIslandUSA," wondered a fan. Another fan seconded, "How come I feel like they are always putting Cashay and Aimee with the same guys for drama. Ughhh #loveislandusa." "Why They Keep Trying To Put Cash & Aimee Against Each Other #LoveIslandUSA," echoed a fan.



 



 



 



 

'Love Island' Season 3 airs Tuesdays through Fridays at 9pm ET/PT on CBS. In addition, Love Island will air on Sunday nights from 9-11 PM ET/PT for the remainder of the season. You can also stream the episodes on Paramount+.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

A dangerous former client targets top divorce attorney Allura Grant with a series of escalating attacks before holding her hostage at gunpoint
2026-11-05T08:27:49.000Z
Joe Miñoso left 'Chicago Fire' in the procedural's momentous 300th episode
2026-11-05T07:53:12.000Z
‘Chicago Fire’ honors a fan favorite character in its 300th episode
2026-11-05T05:51:40.000Z
‘Chicago Med’ focuses on Dr Wu’s pursuit of the Chief Resident position in its latest episode
2026-11-05T04:50:53.000Z
Tomlin risks Cruz’s job to convince Severide in the latest episode of ‘Chicago Fire’
2026-11-05T03:47:56.000Z
The untitled Hulu series follows Leavitt and her family as she handles new fame and career ambitions
2026-11-05T03:29:58.000Z
The ‘All’s Fair’ cast return for a second season of divorce cases and personal drama. Here’s when new episodes arrive, where to watch and what to know about before the finale.
2026-11-04T16:46:27.000Z
'Batman: Knightfall Part 2' unveils a first-look clip as Azrael takes up the cowl after Bruce Wayne is left paralyzed by Bane.
2026-11-04T16:27:06.000Z
Owen Wilson returns to the green in ‘Stick’ Season 2. Here’s your guide to Apple TV’s weekly episode rollout, streaming details and finale date.
2026-11-04T15:48:30.000Z
'Trinity,' starring Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Richard Madden, follows a naval officer who suspects the US Secretary of Defense is at center of a conspiracy.
2026-11-04T15:21:56.000Z