Are Laurel Stucky and Nicole Zanatta still together? Cara Maria warns 'The Challenge: All Stars' Season 4 player of cheating

Laurel Stucky and Nicole Zanatta recently slam each other on social media
Cara Maria, Laurel Stucky and Nicole Zanatta to compete in 'The Challenge: All Stars' Season 4 (Instagram/@thechallenge and @misscaramaria)
Cara Maria, Laurel Stucky and Nicole Zanatta to compete in 'The Challenge: All Stars' Season 4 (Instagram/@thechallenge and @misscaramaria)

CAPE TOWN, SOUTH AFRICA: 'The Challenge: All Stars' Season 4 players Nicole Zanatta and Laurel Stucky are currently not together. The duo had been in a relationship for more than a year and reconnected on 'Ex on the Beach: Peak of Love'. The MTV show documented Nicole and Laurel's rocky relationship.

Nicole has since moved on with her new girlfriend and often documented their romance on social media. However, Nicole and Laurel have been speculated to reconcile their relationship while filming 'The Challenge' spin-off. The upcoming season featured romance and tense drama between the ex-couple. In the trailer, Nicole claimed, "Laurel hates my guts because she’s secretly still in love with me."

Nicole and Laurel reportedly hooked up and shared a kiss but Cara Maria Sorbello already sensed the dramatic end of their relationship. She tried to warn Laurel that Nicole could cheat on her and said, "You're going to look back on this and regret the way Nicole's playing you for a fool." However, Laurel was not ready to listen to her co-player and yelled at her.



 

'The Challenge' star Laurel Stucky slams Nicole Zanatta

Nicole Zanatta and Laurel Stucky brought their relationship drama on social media. Nicole recently took to her Instagram and shared a video featuring a slideshow of photos with her girlfriend. The MTV star took an apparent dig at her ex Laurel Stucky in the caption and wrote, "This is what a healthy relationship looks like."

However, the shade caught the attention of Laurel and she wrote in the now-deleted comment, "Hope you're not secretly cheating on her too." Nicole slammed back at Laurel and replied, "We're doing great & no I'm not Thank you, she doesn't have a tendency to get UNHINGED, or a THIEF... then proceeds to play phone tag."

'The Challenge' star Nicole then explained why she referred to Laurel as a 'thief' and wrote, "a person who steals another person's property, especially by stealth and without using force or violence." The MTV star elaborated, "I was never the type to kiss and tell but you like comparing notes with an ex-fiancé and how old are you."

'The Challenge' star Laurel Stucky slams Nicole Zanatta (YouTube/@TheChallenge)
'The Challenge' star Laurel Stucky slams Nicole Zanatta (YouTube/@TheChallenge)

Nicole Zanatta hooked up with Cara Maria Sorbello 

Laurel Stucky parted ways from Nicole Zanatta after she hooked up with Cara Maria Sorbello in 2018. During an episode of 'The Challenge: Vendettas', Nicole explained about the drama, "She knew what I did. It wasn’t a secret. The one hookup that I'm not proud about is with Cara [Maria Sorbello]."

Cara Maria and Laurel were best friends but the friendship soon ended after Nicole was introduced on 'The Challenge: Invasion of the Champions'. Nicole had a crush on Cara but she was not interested in her. Nicole then tried a shot on Laurel which eventually ended the MTV star and Cara's friendship. The viewers witnessed Cara and Nicole's kiss but Nicole insisted that she didn't cheat on Laurel.

Nicole explained, "Me and Laurel broke up before the show. Laurel didn’t know that I was going on it. She found out it the day that I was leaving." She added, "You could say that I went on single and I did exactly me. I'm not ashamed about it. I don’t care."

Nicole Zanatta hooked up with Cara Maria Sorbello (Instagram/@n_zanattamtv)
Nicole Zanatta hooked up with Cara Maria Sorbello (Instagram/@n_zanattamtv)

'The Challenge: All Stars' Season 4 to premiere on Wednesday, April 10 on Paramount+.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11 cast has more to unpack, and here’s what to know about catching the reunion before its Netflix release.
2026-11-05T19:30:37.000Z
‘The Amazing Race’ Season 39 heads to Sri Lanka, where a live Double U-Turn vote creates tension and forces teams to fight to stay in the race
2026-11-05T06:20:44.000Z
After a chaotic merge vote in Episode 7, a 27-year-old professional wrestler became the first ‘Survivor 51’ juror
2026-11-05T05:47:05.000Z
A former ‘RHOBH’ star has filmed with the Season 16 cast, but questions remain about her role. Her latest update offers a glimpse of the reunion and the drama ahead.
2026-11-04T20:49:29.000Z
‘Dancing with the Stars’ will host a brand new theme along with a face-off in next week’s episode
2026-11-04T10:25:19.000Z
‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11 finale sees Wilson and Wilnie clash over expectations before splitting
2026-11-04T09:35:45.000Z
Among the engaged couples featured on the show, only one made it to the altar and said ‘I do.’
2026-11-04T08:23:28.000Z
During his recent appearance on Oliver Hudson’s podcast, David Charvet reflected on his feud with Collin
2026-11-04T07:40:50.000Z
Riley Green also struggled to accept the young singer as a ‘human’ after witnessing her latest performance.
2026-11-04T05:48:33.000Z
Aneha and Cam’s ‘Love Is Blind’ wedding preparations take a turn when her sister raises concerns, leaving the bride with more to consider.
2026-11-03T19:46:46.000Z