'American Idol' judge Luke Bryan makes a bold prediction for the season 23 winner: 'My gut has told me...'

With just one episode to go, Luke Bryan has a 'gut feeling' about one finalist—could he have called it before the win?
PUBLISHED MAY 15, 2025
(L-R) Photo of contestants John Foster, Breanna Nix, and Jamal Roberts from 'Instagram @americalidol; Screenshot of Luke Bryan from 'American Idol';  (Cover image source: Instagram | @Americanidol (R) YouTube 'American Idol')
(L-R) Photo of contestants John Foster, Breanna Nix, and Jamal Roberts from 'Instagram @americalidol; Screenshot of Luke Bryan from 'American Idol'; (Cover image source: Instagram | @Americanidol (R) YouTube 'American Idol')

During a recent episode of  'American Idol,' the top 5 contestants, Slater Nalley, Jamal Roberts, John Foster, Thunderstorm Artis, and Breanna Nix, battled each other with powerful performances. However, as per the show's format, two contestants had to bow out of the race for the coveted Idol trophy, leaving only 3 finalists to compete in the finals. The shocking elimination has Nalley and Artis packing for home, but at this point, any elimination would have hit hard, not only to the judges but to the viewers as well, especially when it's all in the hands of the voters.



 

The judges might not choose the winner, but it is no surprise that they will have their favorites. Just like the fans, they’re deeply invested—after all, they've not only watched but also groomed and been a part of these contestants' journey from the start. In a recent chat with People, the judges opened up about the three finalists, Roberts, Nix, and Foster. Luke Bryan didn’t hesitate to name a contestant whom he thinks could win the show. "My gut has told me Jamal has been a lead all year." Admitting that the final call is with American, he added, "When you look at every time Breanna gets through, we're like, 'She keeps showing up and making it happen,'" the "Play It Again" singer said. "And then John Foster just seems to be gaining momentum."



 

Speaking of the unpredictable nature of the show, Bryan said, "He continued, 'Even if it's something that Jamal's kind of had the reins of, it could change with a little bit of not focusing... so they've got to be focused to the end. The music business is never like that. You've got to focus every day." Lionel Richie pointed out that it's not only about singing anymore: "It's an even playing field, but it comes down to popularity. How many fans do they have that like them as people?" He continued, "Right now, singing cover songs is great, but when they have their hit records, you start building their career. Right now, they're falling in love with the artist."



 

Weighing in on the tight competition, the season 4 winner and judge Carrie Underwood said, "We've had a condensed season." Recalling her experience as a contestant, she added, "It was a lot longer when I was on the show. So they're running to catch up the whole time." The 'How Great Thou Art' singer continued, "I would imagine they feel more frenzied than I felt about the whole situation. It's a different blackout. You're going to be doing a lot, going back to their towns, and everyone's going to be on them."



 

She then summed it up perfectly: "This is kind of a taste of what the rest of their career is going to be like. We always call this a star boot camp because you learn a lot fast". It’s only a matter of time before we find out who will take home the crown. But fans can look forward to seeing their favorites perform once again—fan favorites who’ve been eliminated will return for a special performance, and as a tradition, even the judges will hit the stage during the show’s grand finale.

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL THE IDOL

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Emma Roberts will star in a Peacock series loosely based on the 2009 rom-com starring Anne Hathaway and Kate Hudson.
3 hours ago
Before 'Industry' Season 4 finale, which premieres one hour earlier than usual, HBO announces a major update on the future of the hit TV show.
4 hours ago
Netflix dropped major updates on 'The Boroughs', the Duffer Brothers‘ supernatural mystery series, created by Jeffrey Addiss and Will Matthews.
5 hours ago
'Game of Thrones' star will be the main antagonist in the 'God of War' (2018) game and in the upcoming series on Prime Video.
6 hours ago
The Crave-HBO Max series 'Heated Rivalry' now gives its viewers a chance to stay at the cottage as the feverish wait for Season 2 continues.
7 hours ago
With Season 2 underway, ‘Paradise’ deepens its post-apocalyptic narrative while viewers wait to learn whether Hulu will renew the series for Season 3.
8 hours ago
Taylor Sheridan’s next ‘Tulsa King’ chapter is moving forward, with new details emerging ahead of filming for the highly anticipated series.
8 hours ago
AMC chief Dan McDermott shared a promising update on the future of ‘Dark Winds,’ as the acclaimed thriller continues to gain momentum.
9 hours ago
CBS’ new series ‘CIA’ follows mismatched agents tackling covert threats, with a surprise cameo from ‘FBI’ star Jeremy Sisto.
10 hours ago
The ‘Scrubs’ revival brings back beloved doctors, leaves out key originals, and introduces fresh faces to a changed Sacred Heart.
10 hours ago