Luke Bryan saw his old comment about 'American Idol' singer and had only one thing to admit: 'No one...'

"No one has ever proved me more wrong than you," said an elated Luke Bryan while lauding an 'American Idol' contestant
PUBLISHED MAY 12, 2025
(L) Luke Bryan and (R)  John Foster  in screenshots from 'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube |  American Idol)
(L) Luke Bryan and (R) John Foster in screenshots from 'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)

Known for his honest and gentle feedback, Luke Bryan has become one of the most loved judges of 'American Idol. Even with his star power, Bryan leaves no chance to encourage the participants and push them to do their best. However, there have been times when Bryan outrightly rejected the contestant, only to regret it later. In an interesting turn of events, Bryan had to eat his own words when a rejected contestant blew him away by his performance. Not only that, but Bryan publicly acknowledged his misjudgment, making for one of the most heartwarming 'American Idol' moments.

LOS ANGELES, CA - APRIL 15: Luke Bryan is seen on April 15, 2025 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by PG/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images)
Luke Bryan is seen on April 15, 2025, in Los Angeles, California (Image Source: GC Images | Photo by PG/Bauer-Griffin)

The contestant in discussion is none other than John Foster, who successfully made it into American Idol's Top 5. However, Foster's 'American Idol' journey was anything but smooth. Judge Bryan was skeptical when he first auditioned and hesitated to send him to Hollywood, questioning whether he had strong enough vocals. However, Foster has since won him over, as per MassLive. Foster's performance of George Strait's 'I Cross My Heart' changed Bryan's mind as he openly admitted he was wrong.



 

Bryan said, "I was doing my TikTok scroll daily, and I saw a clip of me saying I didn't know if you could sing well enough back in your audition." The country singer further said, "And man, no one has ever proved me more wrong than you." Bryan had also praised Foster earlier when he performed an original song in hopes of making the Top 14, saying, "You've kind of been a wildcard for me the whole time," he said, "but what you just did there removed all doubts in my mind that you deserve to be here."



 

Notably, 'American Idol' brought back the popular 'Judges' Song Contest' round. In this segment, each judge anonymously selects one song for each of the Top 8 contestants, tailored to their vocal strengths and performance style. The contestants then choose from the three mystery picks and perform their selected song live. Foster chose to perform '“I Cross My Heart,' a choice that came from judge and former winner Carrie Underwood.



 

Notably, in an interesting turn of events, Foster successfully advanced to the Top 5 on 'American Idol' after surviving Sunday night's elimination, as per The Advocate. Foster is joined by fellow contestants Breanna Nix, Jamal Roberts , Thunderstorm Artis, and Slater Nalley. During a recent episode, where part one of the show's two-night 'Disney' special was telecasted, Foster performed 'Almost There' from 'The Princess and the Frog,' a film deeply connected to Louisiana and inspired by New Orleans legend Leah Chase. Lin-Manuel Miranda mentored contestants for the round and encouraged Foster by saying, "Let's embrace your inner rock star because you have your guitar to the side."



 

Before the performance, Foster said, "I have never before performed a Disney song in front of any kind of audience. When I sing this song, I'm going to be thinking a lot about my hometown, my home state. We're almost there. Yeah, let's go." Performing without his guitar, Foster was cheered on by family in the audience, including his mom, who held a sign that read, 'I Believe in You, Son.' Judge Bryan was again impressed and praised Foster, saying, "Charisma, charisma, charisma. That's why you’re still in this thing and that’s why you're 'almost there.'"

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL

GET THE BIGGEST CELEBRITY & ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The prequel stars Spence Moore as young "Ghost" St. Patrick and Charlie Mann as a young Tommy Egan
10 hours ago
A set photo featuring Mike and Hopper sparked multiple theories about their fate the finale
11 hours ago
'Smiling Friends' recently aired its season 3 finale on Adult Swim, earning a largely positive response
12 hours ago
Netflix's new documentary 'Sean Combs: The Reckoning' dives into the troubled world of Sean 'Diddy' Combs 
12 hours ago
'Love & Death' starring Elizabeth Olsen sheds light on the case of Texas housewife Candy Montgomery, who killed her friend, Betty Gore
15 hours ago
'The Boys' Season 5 will be the final outing of Prime Video's hugely popular satirical superhero series
16 hours ago
The two-hour finale will stream on Netflix and screen in over 350 theaters across the US and Canada — a first for the franchise
17 hours ago
Last seen on 'Dancing with the Stars' Season 34, Whitney Leavitt will join Kate Baldwin, Sophie Carmen-Jones, and Tam Mutu, among others
17 hours ago
Primetime Emmy Award winner Phoebe Waller-Bridge is leading the project as creator, writer, and executive producer
19 hours ago
With season 1 garnering positive reviews, the focus shifts to a probable season 2
1 day ago