17-year-old ‘American Idol’ contestant’s powerful song for his grieving teacher moves judges to tears

Slater Nalley’s soulful audition on 'American Idol' had everyone in the room feeling emotional
PUBLISHED APR 20, 2025
Luke Bryan, contestant Slater Nalley with his teacher, Carrie Underwood, on 'American Idol' 2025. (Cover Image Source: YouTube| American Idol)
Luke Bryan, contestant Slater Nalley with his teacher, Carrie Underwood, on 'American Idol' 2025. (Cover Image Source: YouTube| American Idol)

Slater Nalley, a 17-year-old singer and songwriter from Nashville, wowed the 'American Idol' judges with his original composition 'Traces of You'. However, they were stunned when they heard the inspiration behind the heart-tugging track. Before Nalley had a chance to impress the judges, his English teacher, Mrs. Davis, explained that the song was written as a memorial to her late son. "I am not performing today. I'm so grateful to be here. I have a special student of mine, Slater Nalley, and he wrote a song for my son, who was killed eight years ago," she revealed. The grieving mother further disclosed that Nalley had turned her short poem into a song, "Slater had heard the story about my son and I had written a poem, and the second year that I taught him, I asked, 'Would you mind looking at the poem?" 



 

"So he did, and two weeks later, he wrote the song, and that's what he's going to sing today," she continued. During the confessional, the teenager acknowledged that he wrote the original song because he wanted to soothe his teacher's suffering after learning that she was grieving. "This song is called 'Traces of You,' I wrote it for Carter Davis," he said, "I didn't know Carter before this happened, and when Mrs. Davis told us, I just felt this presence come into my life essentially, and I knew that I needed to do something. I went home and started working away on little notebook pages, and eventually, it turned into a song."

Carrie Underwood at the 38th Annual Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame Induction Ceremony at Barclays Center on November 03, 2023, in NYC.(Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Jeff Kravitz)
Carrie Underwood at the 38th Annual Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame Induction Ceremony at Barclays Center on November 03, 2023, in NYC.(Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Jeff Kravitz)

Carrie Underwood was left feeling overwhelmed by the end of the teen's soulful performance. "Even though this was about your son, every single person who hears that can fill in that memory with somebody that's in themselves. I couldn't have imagined you doing that any better," she said, wiping her tears. Lionel Richie stated that he was moved by the lyrics, and Bryan Luke encouraged him to maintain his uniqueness. The judge's decision was unanimous without casting any vote; Nalley earned his ticket to fame. "To have this gift, it's like a little piece of Carter gets to live on in song," Mrs. Davis expressed in tears after witnessing the result. 



 

The teen sensation breezed past Hollywood Week with another one of his original tracks titled 'Foolish Pride'. "It is about self-reflection, and realizing sometimes when you're the problem in a relationship, of a friendship, or anything. I wrote it when I was going through a hard time in a relationship. I think the judges are going to see another side of my storytelling," he said before his turn. "I'm scared!" was all Underwood could say after witnessing another one of his soulful performances.



 

"I wanted the judges to see a different side of me. Still a songwriter, but with a different range of my voice. And I think that they got that." Earlier during the introduction, Nalley shared that his English teacher gifted him a necklace with a pendant that featured Saint Christopher and also had her late son Carter's ashes. "Because they know I got nervous a little bit before my last audition," he explained. Nalley's stunning renditions have rocked the competition, including his most recent performance of 'Over the Rainbow.'

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'Secret Lives of Mormon Wives' Season 5 halted filming following a domestic violence investigation involving Taylor Frankie Paul and Dakota Mortensen
2 hours ago
A brutal round of Battles sends several contestants home while one last-minute Steal shakes up the teams just before the high-stakes Knockouts begin
2 hours ago
Adam Levine stuns fellow coaches with a wedding confession, as a high-stakes Battle delivers emotion, praise, and a decisive win
5 hours ago
The second half of the Top 20 took the stage during Ohana Week, and the March 30 episode will reveal the Top 12
6 hours ago
Taylor Frankie Paul's past altercation with her ex, Dakota Mortensen, causes the latest season of 'The Bachelorette' to be canceled.
22 hours ago
Gabby Windey's $1.1 million net worth includes earning from reality shows, podcast, clothing line and more.
22 hours ago
Jill Chin, who has appeared across multiple shows of the franchise, shared her take on who should have been the next Bachelorette
1 day ago
The controversy around Taylor Frankie Paul leaves the future of ‘The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives’ hanging in uncertainty.
1 day ago
ABC pulled the plug on Season 22 of 'The Bachelorette' leaving the fate of the contestants uncertain
2 days ago
Taylor Frankie Paul, known for being part of 'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,' was set to be the first Bachelorette outside of Bachelor Nation
4 days ago