Did Scarlet get eliminated due to the 'bad edit'? 'American Idol' fans declare she was 'robbed'

After hearing about Scarlet's elimination many fans felt that the audience may have voted her out because of the bad edit she received on the show
Scarlet Ayliz on 'American Idol' Season 20 (ABC)
Scarlet Ayliz on 'American Idol' Season 20 (ABC)

The power is in the audiences' hands to decide the fate of 'American Idol' Season 20's contestants, and it looks like it takes a lot more than just impeccable vocals to please them. That's the only explanation the show's fans could come up with after host Ryan Seacrest announced Scarlet Aylizi's elimination following her top 24 performance.

Dan Marshall, Danielle Finn, and Scarlet, were the last three standing from group 1, competing for the last spot on the top 20 list. So, when Ryan announced that the audience had voted for Dan to move to the show's next round which meant that Danielle and Scarlet's journey came to an end, fans were surprised. While Danielle took the bad news with grace and thanked everybody for the opportunity, Scarlet looked puzzled and annoyed. Just like Scarlet, fans too were puzzled with the result and wondered if the 'bad edit' that she received during the Hollywood Week's duet round had something to do with her elimination.

RELATED ARTICLES

Did Kenedi Anderson SNUB 'American Idol' over record deal? Singer wants 'no strings attached'

'American Idol' Top 20: Sage's singing slammed as 'wailing like she swallowed glass'

Scarlet after she learned about her elimination from 'American Idol' (ABC)

Was Scarlet eliminated due to a 'bad edit' on 'American Idol'?

During the Hollywood Week's duet round, Scarlet was teamed up with Douglas Mills. She was frustrated with her fellow singer's struggle to memorize their song's lines. This led to Scarlet storming out angrily during their rehearsals. Though she joined back later and apologized to her teammate for her behavior, and the duo managed to put up a decent performance, it looks like fans haven't gotten over it.

After hearing about Scarlet's elimination many fans felt that the audience may have voted her out because of her attitude and the bad edit she received on the show. Since she always wowed the judges with her performances, fans couldn't think of any other reason for Scarlet's untimely elimination from the ABC show. A fan tweeted, "Scarlet was robbed. She was set up to fail after she was given a bad edit during the duet round. Complete bs. #AmericanIdol." "The only reason scarlet didn’t make it is because of how they edited her duet round, it has nothing to do with talent… i understood her frustration but I guess it was off-putting to others idk #AmericanIdol," wrote a fan. "The ONLY reason scarlet might not make it is because of what happened in the duet round.. cause other than that she is a really good performer #AmericanIdol," continued the fan in another tweet.



 



 



 

Scarlet on 'American Idol' season 20 (Photo by Instagram@scarletayliz)

Another fan shared, "WTH!! Scarlet didn't make it... But Dan did.... #AmericanIdol." "Scarlet is PISSED! #americanidol," observed a fan. "Honestly I don't think he deserved the last spot over Scarlet or Danielle but to each it's own. They're the judges so," commented a fan on the show's YouTube page.



 



 

'American Idol' Season 20 airs every Sunday and Monday at 8/7c on ABC.

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'The Pitt' Season 3 is currently in production and will return sometime in January 2027
2 hours ago
Several familiar TV stars were missing from the 2026 Emmys In Memoriam despite major tributes during the ceremony.
2 hours ago
‘Charlie’s Angels’ actress Farrah Fawcett passed away in 2009 after her battle with cancer
2 hours ago
Sally Field won in the ‘Outstanding Lead Actress in a Limited or Anthology Series or TV Movie’ category for her work in ‘Remarkably Bright Creatures’
3 hours ago
There’s a very Taylor Swift-coded reason she was not present at the Emmys this time
3 hours ago
Matthew Rhys, Jean Smart, Rhea Seehorn and more were among the biggest winners across the 78th Emmy Awards
4 hours ago
The Emmys had a few surprise wins up their sleeve. Here are 7 biggest moments of the 2026 Emmys.
5 hours ago
‘Buffy the Vampire Slayer’ fan favorites came together on stage to present the award for Lead Actor in a Limited or Anthology Series or Movie
5 hours ago
‘The Late Show’ was nominated alongside 'The Daily Show,' 'Jimmy Kimmel Live!,' 'Last Week Tonight with John Oliver,' and 'Saturday Night Live'
5 hours ago
Vince Gilligan just broke a streak that followed him for years
6 hours ago