An NFL legend revealed why he’ll never join 'DWTS' — and it's surprisingly relatable

Alfonso Ribeiro’s ‘DWTS’ pitch went sideways fast when this NFL star passed it to another anchor mid-show
PUBLISHED MAY 19, 2025
 Screenshot of Alfonso Ribeiro from an episode of 'DWTS' Season 33 (Cover Image Source: ABC | Dancing with the Stars)
Screenshot of Alfonso Ribeiro from an episode of 'DWTS' Season 33 (Cover Image Source: ABC | Dancing with the Stars)

Michael Strahan's appearance on ‘Dancing with the Stars’ is unlikely! The former NFL pro and 'Good Morning America' anchor admitted his biggest fear when Alfonso Ribeiro pitched him to participate in future seasons of the ABC dance competition. On Tuesday, May 13, Ribeiro, who’ll be hosting ‘DWTS’, appeared on the chat show to promote season 34. When Strahan asked about celebrity participants who could join the show’s forthcoming season, Ribeiro hinted at the anchor.



 

“I think if there was a guy, if he played for the Giants at one point in his life, 'cause you know he'd bring the whole New York audience, right?” he teased. The suggestion was enough to get Strahan on his feet and bust impromptu dance moves. But after settling back into his seat, he said, “That's as much as you get.” The ‘DWTS’ host kept pitching the idea, even suggesting that he’d get a “tall dancer” for a partner so he wouldn’t feel awkward. But Strahan’s mind didn’t change.



 

He quipped that the best part of the show is that he gets to interview the participants without having to dance. When Ribeiro didn’t budge, Strahan revealed what made him fear the dance competition. He revealed that every professional football player and athlete who’s been on the show has described it as the “hardest” they’d ever done. “If it was harder than football was for me, I cannot fathom it at this point in my life,” Strahan added.



 

That’s when Ribeiro went for the punch! He quipped that maybe those athletes weren’t putting much effort. “I can’t say for certain, but maybe they didn’t step up,” he added while 'GMA' co-hosts burst out laughing. Strahan has been deemed a highly skilled athlete who dedicated 15 years to playing the defensive end for the NFL’s New York Giants. As for ‘DWTS’, it has had many athletes and pro football players as participants over the last 33 seasons.



 

Although athletes are known to have incredible stamina, they were surprisingly stumped by the difficulty of the experience. Olympic gymnast Sunisa Lee competed in the show’s 30th season and shared her experience with PEOPLE in 2021. Lee declared that nothing would ever come close to the efforts she put into preparing for the Olympics, but quickly added that her experience on 'DWTS' was more challenging. “I have to say, probably 'Dancing With the Stars' [was harder],” she told the outlet.



 

NFL star Rashad Jennings also admitted that ballroom dancing was harder than playing football. During his appearance on ‘Wheel of Fortune’ in 2023, he recalled the “gruesome” training they had to do for the show. Although he hadn’t danced “a day” in his life, he ended up winning the season 24 champion trophy. “I knew nothing about dance. But I had a blast,” he added as per Parade. Rashad was accompanied by fellow contestants Marcellus Wiley and Jared Allen, who also vented about their experiences. Strahan then pitched the show to another ‘GMA’ co-host, George Stephanopoulos, who politely declined the offer and prompted a roar of laughter.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'The Pitt' Season 2 Episode 11 sees chaos peak as a malware outage cripples the ER, while there's an attack on Emma, leaving her fate uncertain.
22 minutes ago
Robert Patino and David Wiener serve as the showrunners and the executive producers of Netflix's 'Assassin's Creed' series.
1 hour ago
The documentary series 'Neighbors' showcases the pettiness and reckless attitudes in neighborly disputes in all its glory.
3 hours ago
'The Pitt' Season 2 episode 12 will see the staff scrambling to control the situation as the code leads to more mayhem and disruption.
5 hours ago
A powerful family and a quiet investigator collide as buried secrets resurface in Maya Hawke's new role in a case that refuses to stay hidden.
5 hours ago
A dreamy Nantucket getaway turns tense as old friends reunite, and one unexpected guest changes everything
8 hours ago
Rapp will play Samantha in the upcoming season of the hit show alongside Reese Witherspoon and Jennifer Aniston
9 hours ago
Kathryn Hahn, Ike Barinholtz, and Chase Sui Wonders are set to return to ‘The Studio’ Season 2
10 hours ago
The latest episode focuses on John and Carolyn, a year into their marriage, as their relationship becomes increasingly strained
11 hours ago
A chance encounter turns awkward fast as sparks fly between a quiet songwriter and a hockey star
13 hours ago