Heidi Klum's days as judge on 'AGT' may be numbered after Simon Cowell's scathing comments

Simon Cowell has publicly criticized fellow 'America’s Got Talent' judge Heidi Klum for giving positive feedback on every performance
Rumors of Heidi Klum's exit from 'AGT' surface after Simon Cowell criticizes her for giving ‘overly positive’ feedback (YouTube/@agt)
Rumors of Heidi Klum's exit from 'AGT' surface after Simon Cowell criticizes her for giving ‘overly positive’ feedback (YouTube/@agt)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Simon Cowell has publicly criticized 'America’s Got Talent' judge Heidi Klum for giving positive feedback on every performance. Simon remarked, “You can’t just tell everyone they’re good if you don’t feel it,” accusing Klum of lacking honesty in her reviews. Simon's comments suggested he’s displeased with Heidi’s tendency to always praise the acts, even when their performances might not warrant it. This has sparked speculation about whether Heidi might be removed from the show as a result. Some are wondering if Simon's criticism could lead to changes in the judging panel.

For instance, when she awarded the Golden Buzzer to Dee Dee Simon, Heidi expressed her excitement and belief in Dee Dee’s talent, saying, "Dee Dee, you have a magical quality about you. I’m so excited to see you in the Finals. This Golden Buzzer is for you!" In other instances, Heidi has shown her support by emphasizing the effort and unique qualities of the contestants. For example, she noted, "You are absolutely incredible. I can see how much hard work you've put into this, and it truly shows." Her encouragement didn’t end there; she also motivated performers to continue their journey, saying, "Keep going, don't stop now. You have something special, and the world needs to see it." Moreover, she frequently praised the unique talents of the contestants, as she did when she said, "What you did out there was extraordinary. You have a gift, and I’m so glad you’re sharing it with us."

'AGT' judge Simon Cowell didn't invite Heidi Klum to his house for mentoring sessions

Simon Cowell did not extend an invitation to Heidi Klum for his private mentoring sessions, a decision that highlighted their competitive roles on 'America’s Got Talent: Fantasy League'. In a recent grand finale confessional, Heidi Klum and fellow judge Howie Mandel revealed that Simon Cowell had invited only his selected "dream team" for personal mentoring at his home, leaving them out.

Heidi Klum commented on the exclusion, saying, "How come we have never been invited? It’s because we are competitors." Howie Mandel added, "Simon’s mentoring is like playdates because everybody had to go to his house to get mentoring."

Simon Cowell dubs Hyper Kids Africa's quarterfinals act as 'fantastic chaos' (YouTube/AGT)
Simon Cowell (YouTube/@agt)

'America’s Got Talent' judge Heidi Klum takes a jab at Simon Cowell's judgment

In a recent episode of 'America’s Got Talent: Fantasy League', Heidi Klum took a jab at Simon Cowell regarding his involvement in Shadow Ace's semifinal performance. During the show, Shadow Ace asked Simon to sit in front of a screen to cast a shadow while performing his hand-puppet routine. While Simon participated, Heidi felt his contribution was minimal and criticized him for not fully engaging.

Heidi Klum praised Shadow Ace's performance, calling it "so funny" and acknowledging the creativity involved. However, she also noted, "Simon could have opened his mouth as Shadow Ace pretended to brush his teeth," suggesting that Simon’s lack of enthusiasm might have been a missed opportunity to enhance the act. Simon, surprised by the criticism, responded, "I can’t believe I’m being criticized for Shadow Ace’s performance." Despite the tension, Shadow Ace impressed the judges and secured a spot in the finals, thanks to a strong audience vote.

Shadow Ace on 'AGT' Season 18 (NBC)
Heidi Klum took a swipe at Simon Cowell regarding his involvement in Shadow Ace's semifinal performance in 'AGT' Season 18 (@nbc)

'America's Got Talent' Season 19 airs on NBC every Tuesday and Wednesday at 8 PM ET.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

After a $246,300 betrayal, ‘The Traitors: New Blood’ fans want a reunion, and NBC has answered whether the cast will get to compare notes.
2026-11-21T16:48:13.000Z
Katie and Victor got into a heated exchange during the finale, with neither backing down from their claims
2026-11-20T03:07:04.000Z
‘The Traitors: New Blood’ fans have more than a winner to look forward to as NBC shares news about the show’s future
2026-11-19T19:19:13.000Z
The show follows a group of women and their partners as they navigate friendships, relationships, and secrets
2026-11-19T08:38:53.000Z
After completing the Route Info Task, the teams had to kayak to the Pit Stop
2026-11-19T05:04:45.000Z
Aaryn Williams expressed regret about the 2013 controversy as she spoke to her husband, Nick Williams, in Episode 1
2026-11-19T04:06:27.000Z
The remaining castaways took part in an endurance test to secure immunity in Season 51 Episode 9
2026-11-19T03:15:37.000Z
Christine Quinn and Heather Rae El Moussa return as ‘Selling Sunset’ Season 10 introduces new agents and says goodbye to familiar faces.
2026-11-18T16:02:58.000Z
The reality competition has a new streaming home and a new host, who has some thoughts on its revamped format
2026-11-18T11:30:13.000Z
‘Grey's Anatomy’ star Harry Shum Jr. chose a meaningful song from his 'Glee' days for his 'DWTS' semifinals performance that earned a perfect score
2026-11-18T08:01:23.000Z