Gwen Stefani tells Niall Horan she 'feels sick' for him after his bizarre decision on ‘The Voice’

Niall Horan made a tough call when he picked his top three during 'The Voice' Season 23 playoffs — and fans were not having it
PUBLISHED APR 16, 2025
(L-R) Screenshots of Gwen Stefani and Niall Horan from 'The Voice' Season 23 Playoffs (Cover Image Source: YouTube | The Voice)
(L-R) Screenshots of Gwen Stefani and Niall Horan from 'The Voice' Season 23 Playoffs (Cover Image Source: YouTube | The Voice)

'The Voice' judges have always had to make tough decisions when it comes to selecting the right talent. However during season 23 playoffs, Niall Horan found himself on the hot seat to go first in picking the top 3 out of 6 incredibly talented team members: Nini Iris, Claudia B, Huntley, Julia Roome, Mara Justine, and Alexa Wildish. When the Playoffs began, each artist from Horan's team delivered a jaw-dropping performance, which earned them glowing praise from all four judges. However, there was something special about Wildish. After her performance, Horan said, “You bleed emotion and authenticity.” He added, "It has been so good to watch you amongst all the big belters." John Legend also added, "No one else is like you in this competition." With such heartfelt comments, no one could have thought that Horan would let her go.



 

But things were far from predictable. As all the performances wrapped that night, the tension rose. Huntley was the first to be picked in the top 3. Backstage to the camera, Horan stood by his decisions and said, "Huntley has such an individual tone in his voice, he's a machine on stage, an unbelievable performer." He added, "There is definitely a spot for him in our industry." When the time came to choose the next artist, Horan admitted, "How do I have to do this, look at that team." He continued, "The Second artist moving on is Nini." Speaking of Iris Horan shared that "Nini is the most ready, she knows exactly what she is, and she can win the whole thing. Are you listening, America?"



 

Tension on the stage rose as the other four contestants stood in anticipation, holding each other's hands. Carson Daly pressed, "Niall, who is the last artist to move on?" Horan, clearly having a hard time, said, "This is crazy, that I have to like make this decision, I just don't know how I do it." Legend exclaimed, "I'm on the edge of my seat." And Gwen Stefani said, "I actually feel sick for you right now. I do." Without further ado, Horan then revealed, "The third artist, moving on, is...Mara." Horan later explained his choice: "Mara is a  perfect choice for Live shows because of the energy she brings, the control, the quality of her voice, she is so excited for this."



 

However, fans were taken aback; one YouTube viewer wrote, "I am so devastated. I cannot believe he did not pick her. I thought she was the solid one for sure, going through insane Alex saying you are so amazing. It has been a gift watching you and hearing you sing." Another added, "He made a huge mistake letting her go, and the comments prove that. I’m shocked she was eliminated! I wanted her to make it to the finals. She’s special." The third added, "Really sad that she didn’t make it! I thought she was phenomenal and so different than the other belters. She was able to interpret a song and bring out the emotion! Niall blew it on this one." 



 

"REALLY, Niall! This GIRL was the G.O.A.T for this season of the voice," wrote the fourth. GoldenDerby also asked fans to vote for the singer whom they felt was most robbed during the season 23 Playoffs, and the results were shocking. Wildish topped with a whopping 72% leaving Roome with 17% and Claudia B. at just 11%. It is given that even if Wildish didn't win over coach Horan, she won the hearts of the fans.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

From Peter personal life to addressing the fate of 'The Father', we look at some key storylines that needs explaining in 'The Night Agent' Season 4
18 hours ago
Four episodes in, 'Love Story' continues to generate the buzz, with the anticipation for episode 5 growing by the day
18 hours ago
A renewal for he fourth season purely depends on the ratings for the recently released season 3
22 hours ago
‘Tell Me Lies’ may have ended, but Disney’s quiet spinoff talks hint the drama could return with new faces.
1 day ago
'A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms' has received positive reviews since its premiere in January and looks poised for a long future ahead.
1 day ago
The third season of the Disney+ series will feature the Greek goddesses Hera and Demeter, along with the Greek god Apollo
2 days ago
Peter Sutherland uncovers a White House conspiracy led by the President himself in 'The Night Agent' Season 3
2 days ago
'A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms' features a familiar 'Marvel' villain actor tied to Thanos, and many viewers may not have noticed.
2 days ago
'Monarch: Legacy of Monsters' Season 2 clip takes viewers back into the dangers of Skull Island
2 days ago
Benoît Magimel plays a hunter who mysteriously becomes the hunted in the upcoming TV series
2 days ago