'The Strangers: Chapter 1' Review: Madelaine Petsch impresses but film fails the ultimate horror test

'The Strangers: Chapter 1' revolves around a couple who embark on an ordinary road trip, only to have their lives turned upside down
UPDATED MAY 18, 2024
In 'The Strangers: Chapter 1', Madelaine Petsch stars as Maya, who is deeply in love with her husband (@lionsgate)
In 'The Strangers: Chapter 1', Madelaine Petsch stars as Maya, who is deeply in love with her husband (@lionsgate)

Contains spoilers for 'The Strangers: Chapter 1'

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: 'The Strangers: Chapter 1', the third installment in 'The Strangers' film series, officially hit theaters on Friday, May 17, plunging viewers into a world of terror as a group of deranged strangers, their faces hidden behind eerie masks, unleash chaos and fear.

Starring Madelaine Petsch, Froy Gutierrez, Rachel Shenton, Gabriel Basso, and Ema Horvath in pivotal roles, the film revolves around a couple who embark on a seemingly ordinary road trip.

However, their journey takes a dark turn when they seek refuge in an isolated Airbnb home. It's a classic setup that often sets the stage for intense and suspenseful storytelling.

If you were expecting spine-chilling horror, you may need to think again. While the premise of the film sets up a potentially terrifying scenario, the execution may not deliver the intense scares you're anticipating. The film heavily relies on jump scares to create a sense of fear and suspense. 

Despite Madelaine Petsch's standout acting, the storyline of 'The Strangers: Chapter 1' falters

(John Armour/@lionsgate)
Madelaine Petsch as Maya in a still from 'The Strangers: Chapter 1' (Lionsgate/@johnarmour)

Madelaine Petsch stars as Maya, who is deeply in love with her husband, Ryan, portrayed by Froy Gutierrez. As the couple embarks on a road trip, their journey takes a terrifying turn when they encounter three masked men who unleash a series of horrors upon them.

Petsch delivers a natural and convincing performance as Maya, a woman thrust into a nightmare scenario. Her portrayal of fear, screams, and shock when confronted by the masked assailants is raw and believable, drawing viewers into the intensity of the situation.

In the first half of the film, Petsch portrays Maya as a sweet, loving wife, and a happy-go-lucky individual. Maya is shown as carefree and optimistic, cherishing the moments they share and looking forward to their future together.

However, in the second half of the film, Maya's character undergoes a dramatic transformation. Petsch skillfully transforms Maya into a woman driven by survival instincts.

Madelaine Petsch and Froy Gutierrez (@lionsgate)
Madelaine Petsch and Froy Gutierrez in a still from 'The Strangers: Chapter 1' (Lionsgate/@johnarmour)

While 'The Strangers: Chapter 1' succeeds in delivering thrills and scares through Petsch's acting, its storyline ultimately falls short, relying heavily on familiar horror techniques to elicit fear among viewers.

The plotline of a couple facing off against masked assailants in a secluded setting is a trope that has been used in various horror films, making it feel overly used in the genre.

As the plot unfolds, viewers may find themselves anticipating the next scare or twist, diminishing the element of surprise that is crucial for horror films. 

'The Strangers: Chapter 1' relies on jumpscares and loud noises, but fails to deliver genuine horror

'The Strangers: Chapter 1' is the third installment in 'The Strangers' film series (Lionsgate/@johnarmour)
'The Strangers: Chapter 1' is the third installment in 'The Strangers' film series (Lionsgate/@johnarmour)

The jumpscares, while initially effective in eliciting shock and fear in the first half, are overly used throughout the film, becoming predictable and losing their effectiveness.

Petsch does her best in the role of Maya, but her performance is hampered by the limitations of the script. As an executive producer, she may have had creative input into the film, but her efforts to elevate the material ultimately fell short.

While there are some genuinely tense moments in this horror flick, they are overshadowed by the film's formulaic approach to horror. Additionally, the script lacks depth, offering little in terms of character development.

In certain scenes, the scares feel forced and manufactured, lacking the organic build-up and payoff that characterize truly effective horror films.

'The Strangers: Chapter 1' may be a decent choice for a one-time watch, especially for viewers who are not big fans of horror films. However, for those who are well-versed in the genre, the film may fall short of expectations.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The 2026 Oscars featured several memorable moments, from the heartfelt In Memoriam tributes to the electrifying performance by Miles Canton.
4 hours ago
Sean Penn was also missing from the recently held BAFTA Awards and the SAG Actors' Awards, and was spotted at the Golden Globes 2026.
5 hours ago
Rob and Michele Reiner were murdered at their LA home in December, and their son Nick Reiner has been charged with two counts of first-degree murder.
6 hours ago
The 'Bridesmaids' reunion was one of several sweet reunions at the 98th Academy Awards; others included 'Moulin Rouge,' and 'Avengers.'
8 hours ago
‘All the Empty Rooms’ centers on the lives of the families who lost their young children in school shootings.
8 hours ago
Ahead of the much-awaited event, we predict the winner in the major categories, and our gut says it's a 'Sinners' sweep
2 days ago
The MCU faithful have speculated that the much-awaited footage of Tom Holland's fourth film as the web-slinger might finally hit soon
2 days ago
A classic-style Jason movie could finally happen as ‘Friday the 13th’ creator shares updates on rights progress and a completed story treatment.
2 days ago
Following its massive success on Netflix, ‘KPop Demon Hunters’ will return with a sequel directed by the original filmmakers
3 days ago
Pierre will reprise his 'Lanterns' role in 'Man of Tomorrow,' which is a sequel to the 2025 movie, 'Superman'
3 days ago