'The Secrets We Keep' Review: Noomi Rapace's psychological thriller will leave you guessing till the end

Maja informs her husband that she has recognized one of the Nazis who caught her and her sister towards the end of the war, but is he really the one who committed the crime?
Noomi Rapace (IMDB)
Noomi Rapace (IMDB)

After taking her rightful revenge in the film 'The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo', Noomi Rapace is back with another tale of vengeance. The Swedish actress starring in Yuval Adler's psychological thriller drama 'The Secrets We Keep' will surely give you chills with her blunt and sharp expressions, even though the storyline might come as a disappointment.

The story narrates the tale of a Romanian immigrant woman, Maja, who is married to Lewis (Chris Messina). The couple met while Lewis was stationed in an army hospital in Greece after World War II. The couple lived in a small unnamed town with their son, Patrick, where Lewis' medical practice is at full bloom.

But soon, Maja's world gets shaken when she spots a stranger whom she believes participated in the assault and murder of a group of women that included her and her sister near the end of World War II, named Thomas (Joel Kinnaman).

(The Secrets We Keep)

While Maja is seen enjoying a picnic with her young son, she soon goes into high alert when she spots a tall blond man there, and in short order, she follows him home to get a better look. Peeping into the tidy house he shares with his wife and two children, she sees his face clearly and her reaction is visceral. Maja then kidnaps him and stuffs him up in her car in broad daylight.

She drives him to a remote location where she's already dug a grave, but, unable to bring herself to do the deed, she takes him home, where she imprisons him in the basement and demands his confession of crimes. Thomas replies saying that he is a Swiss and Maja is confused about his identity. This scene resonates a lot with the 1959 thriller film, 'North by Northwest', in which Cary Grant is mistaken for someone he is not.

A still from 'The Secrets We Keep'

Maja also informs her husband about it incident and tells him that she recognized him as one of the Nazis who caught her and her sister towards the end of the war and harassed both of them before killing Maja's sister. This news comes as a shock for Lewis as this was all new to him, as he previously believed, that she never saw so much as a frown during WWII. But he promptly helps his wife to tie Thomas in the basement while he still questions her memory and her method of getting him to confess.

Rapace did an incredible job with her on-point expressions and her portrayal of a strong woman, who wants to avenge the death of her sister. The title of the film, 'The Secrets We Keep' has not done quite a justice, as even though Maja comes out as someone beholding secrets from the past, from her husband for so many years, the film failed to answer the major question in the film which is, Was Thomas actually involved in the crime? 

Watch the 97-minute film 'The Secrets We Keep' on Video on demand (VOD) on October 16.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

DC’s Clayface brings body horror to Gotham as Matt Hagen’s transformation spirals into a story of obsession, lost identity, and revenge in the upcoming 'Clayface' movie.
2026-10-21T20:03:15.000Z
Jack O'Connell discusses the close-knit feel of the 'A Quiet Place' franchise as anticipation builds for the next installment.
2026-10-21T14:52:09.000Z
‘The Prestige’ returns for an anniversary run with new viewing options for Christopher Nolan fans.
2026-10-20T18:05:56.000Z
Star Wars Funday Football’ will stream on Disney+ and the ESPN App, with the animated game also airing on Disney Channel and Disney XD.
2026-10-20T07:15:06.000Z
The Prime Video romantic comedy’s next chapter brings a new director and a move to Italy.
2026-10-19T19:26:54.000Z
'C.L.A.Y.' marks Simon Afram’s feature directing debut, with filming set for November in London.
2026-10-19T18:18:23.000Z
The sequel to the 2011 motion capture adventure now has a finished script and a director
2026-10-19T07:16:32.000Z
The movie was first announced months after ‘The Rise of Skywalker’ closed the Skywalker saga
2026-10-19T04:56:20.000Z
‘You Can See Everything’ takes an unexpected turn after Elizabeth Holmes begins her prison sentence.
2026-10-17T16:42:01.000Z
Diablo Cody’s latest comments give ‘Jennifer’s Body’ fans a new reason to keep an eye on the sequel.
2026-10-17T14:59:25.000Z