Jerry Springer sued by family of a man who killed himself two weeks after his fiancée dumped him on the show

On the show, the man's fiancée confessed she had been unfaithful with his good friend, no longer wanted to marry him, and had even sold the engagement ring he had given her.
UPDATED APR 1, 2020
Television Personality Jerry Springer (Source : Getty Images)
Television Personality Jerry Springer (Source : Getty Images)

The Jerry Springer Show makers found themselves in a bit of a soup as news emerged that they are being sued by the family of a man who committed suicide shortly after appearing on an episode of the controversial show. Blake Alvey's family said he was ambushed on the NBC series when he was confronted by his fiancée Cassie Rutter. 

On the show, Rutter admitted to Alvey that she had been unfaithful with his good friend, no longer wanted to marry him and had even sold the engagement ring he had given her.  The show was filmed on May 8, 2018 and aired on May 24, 2018. And a few days later, on June 3, 2018, Alvey took his own life. 

Alvey's family have filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Jerry Springer and NBC, claiming the show knew it would "elicit an extreme reaction" from Alvey. (Photo by Jay LaPrete/Getty Images)

The particularly humiliating episode, which is titled 'Gay Phase...Over', reveals in its short description that "Cassie has moved on - to her boyfriend's good friend." The trailer of the episode, moreover, starts with Rutter saying, "I don't want to get married. And there's someone else."

Alvey's family have filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Jerry Springer and NBC, claiming the show knew it would "elicit an extreme reaction" from Alvey. The lawsuit, obtained by WDRB, claims that  Alvey, who is now survived by his newborn son, killed himself "as a result of severe emotional and mental suffering and anguish". It further accuses the controversial TV show of "reckless disregard for the lives and safety of others". 

"The Jerry Springer Show was designed to humiliate and exploit people like Blake, [disregarding] the devastating consequences that their conduct can have on people's lives," Brenton Stanley, Alvey's family attorney, said in a statement. "We will fight to hold them accountable," he added.

The lawsuit, which was filed in Jefferson Circuit Court last week, is requesting unspecified monetary damages and a jury trial. As per reports, Rutter has also been named as a defendant in the lawsuit. 

Alvey of Louisville, Kentucky, had been posting a lot of content on social media less than three months before he died, and in a couple of images, the Kentucky native had alluded to problems with friends. One was a meme that read: "PSA to All Guys: DO NOT choose your boys over your gf because when you break up its your 'boys' who be in her DM like 'he dumb, you don't deserve that.'"

He had even posted a tribute to his then-fiancée Rutter on his social media page, with the caption: "Cassie Rutter, I love you with all my heart I swear to god I do...your my baby girl despite all your flaws your still #1 to me you (sic)", alongside an image that read, "The couples that are meant to be are the ones who go through everything that is meant to tear them apart, and come out even stronger than they were before."

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

John Oliver was bleeped out twice during his brief, 15-second Emmys acceptance speech on live television after he roasted host Nate Bargatze
Sep 15, 2025
Kevin Hart doesn't appreciate paparazzi’s question after viral video of him hosting Diddy’s party resurfaces
Apr 6, 2025
Diddy’s childhood friend Tim Patterson claims Janice Combs’s wild parties often involved pimps, homosexuals, and other adult activities
Apr 6, 2025
Lisa Marie Presley and Michael Jackson tied the knot in 1994, but she initially thought the King of Pop was a creep—and we totally get why
Apr 6, 2025
Riley Keough opens up about the Presley family curse in a candid interview while on tour for her book, 'From Here to the Great Unknown'
Apr 5, 2025
Natalie Morales hits back after her interview with Seth Meyers is removed from all platforms due to a revealing outfit
Apr 5, 2025
"Babyface, can you believe she wants me to dress like a girl?" Michael Jackson told a producer.
Apr 2, 2025
Sofia Vergara also dished out on why she doesn't ever want to play Modern Family's Gloria again
Apr 2, 2025
"It took more and more to get high, and I honestly don't know when your body decides it can't deal with it anymore," Lisa Marie Presley wrote.
Apr 1, 2025
A family member's last-minute intervention saved Michael Jackson from the 9/11 tragedy—here’s what happened
Apr 1, 2025