'Mrs America' Episode 6: Is Alice losing faith in Phyllis? Fans can't wait to see her change sides

Alice's waning faith in Phyllis's intent jumps out in moments where she offers subtle eye rolls and sarcastically speaks to the evangelists
Phyllis Schlafly and Alice McCray (Hulu)
Phyllis Schlafly and Alice McCray (Hulu)

Spoilers for 'Mrs America' Episode 6 'Jill'

As 'Mrs America' continues on their somewhat glorifying parade of Phyllis Schlafly (Cate Blanchett) and her staunch anti-feminist crusade, fans are thrilled and beyond ecstatic that on the show, we see Phyllis' strongest ally and ardent supporter Alice McCray (Sarah Paulson) finally begin to show character development as an individual who doesn't always feel compelled to cater and pander to Phyllis's idiosyncracies.

Episode 6 sees the rise of Jill Ruckelshouse (Elizabeth Banks) as Phyllis Schlafly's iconic match within the ERA. Clever enough to try and bribe Phyllis with what her heart really desires, Elizabeth Banks aces as Jill in the titular episode. But it is Sarah Paulson's Alice that is earning all the nods for finally showing sly little signs of how done with Phyllis's selfish battle and motives she is.

Throughout the episode we see a rating panic disguised with p[noise circulate through Phyllis; from her realizing that the ERA is winning over the way she had dreaded, to the inner conflict surrounding her son's sexuality - Phyllis tries her best to be a calculating, conniving eagle she has been even though coming undone during Church confessionals after partnering with Evangelicals.

But in one poignant scene in Episode 6, amid a confrontation between the two, Jill accuses Phyllis of using the anti ERA crusade as a crutch to form allies and supporters who are going to aid her as she glides into Ronald Reagan's defense administration. Jill accuses Phyllis of fighting against feminists purely for clout she needs for other ulterior motives and looks like after days of pandering to her whims, Alice has caught on to the same.

It begins with Phyllis's absolute lack of sympathy towards their fellow member of the STOP ERA, Pamela - a new mother in an abusive marriage. Her husband mistreats her enough to send her into crying fits and Phyllis couldn't care less or be more apathetic. Later, even with an unconsolable Pamela begging Phyllis to not attend an administration meeting as they need to focus on the agenda at hand, she uses the pretext of suggesting they bring the fight to the floor, to defend her attending the meeting. 

Alice's waning faith in Phyllis's intent jumps out in moments where she offers subtle eye rolls and sarcastically speaks to the Evangelists; little eye rolls, smirks, and looks of shocked disdain upon her face has fans convinced she is soon going to change sides, and they couldn't be more thrilled. Taking it to Twitter, a fan enthused how "Alice McCray is a whole a** mood this entire episode!" Another chimed in, exclaiming: "YUP SHE'S GETTING THERE can't wait to see her change sides!!"

A third fan remarked "This is the character development we deserve," while a fourth couldn't stop gushing about how "Alice comforting pamela was so pure and so soft!" 

So far it's only speculation from Alice's instincts; here's hoping the turnover comes soon!

'Mrs. America drops new episodes weekly, every Wednesday midnight, only on Hulu.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘American Horror Story’ Season 13 brings back Twisty the Clown and other fan-favorite characters for its 13-episode return.
17 hours ago
By the end of ‘Silo’ Season 3, Daniel had been cryogenically frozen and awakened multiple times
17 hours ago
‘Sheriff Country’ and ‘Fire Country’ will both debut on October 9 on CBS
1 day ago
Glen Powell’s ‘Chad Powers’ dropped all episodes of its Season 2 on September 3
1 day ago
Nancy Meyers’ long-time collaborator Suzanne Farwell is set to take the director’s chair for ‘Otherwise Engaged’
1 day ago
2026 Daytime Emmy Awards will be streamed live on October 30, only on the National Academy of Television Arts and Sciences and The Emmys app
1 day ago
Nicolas Cage’s noir detective era hits a crossroads as Prime Video weighs in on what is next
1 day ago
Juliette and the people of Silo 18 prepare to challenge the powerful force controlling their underground world.
1 day ago
The HBO series is preparing its ‘Chamber of Secrets’ adaptation months before its Christmas Day debut.
1 day ago
The group finds a possible way to steer through the multiverse, but three competing teams send its journey off course.
1 day ago