'MAFS' is a disaster: 'Experts' face crisis over disastrous matches as show becomes laughing stock

In the last 17 seasons of 'MAFS', 69 couples have been matched, yet only 11 remain together today
'MAFS' experts have a success rate of 16% (@lifetime)
'MAFS' experts have a success rate of 16% (@lifetime)

CHICAGO, ILLINOIS: The 'Married At First Sight' experts play a crucial role in guiding couples through the eight-week journey. They offer counseling sessions to help participants overcome challenges and build a lasting marriage that extends beyond the show. However, the experts have struggled to find suitable matches, with 'MAFS' Season 17 resulting in little to no successful pairings.

This brings to light a troubling reality: the experts have repeatedly fallen short in their roles. The contestants who join the show often come from backgrounds where they have struggled to find genuine or lasting connections. They turn to the experts hoping to bypass the dating scene and step into committed relationships. However, after 17 Seasons marked by mismatched couples and a disappointing success rate, doubts emerge about the experts' legitimacy and credibility. Their approach to handling situations and conducting therapy sessions has drawn criticism, especially regarding its effectiveness. It often seems that the experts contribute more to the drama than to fostering meaningful resolutions. Given this, while there are alternative paths to success on 'MAFS', it may be time to consider replacing the experts entirely.

(Instagram/@alessarampolla)
The 'Married At First Sight' experts play a pivotal role in guiding couples through the eight-week process (Instagram/@alessarampolla)

'MAFS’ poor success rate reveals what the experts are doing wrong

'Married At First Sight' couples have experienced a success rate that pales in comparison to the number of couples who have separated. In the last 17 seasons, 69 couples have been matched, but only 11 are still together today, resulting in a success rate of 16%. While couples often say 'yes' on Decision Day, their relationships often struggle soon after the show, leading to breakups in less than a year, or in some cases, just a few months.

All this could stem from poor matchmaking. However, the experts can't bear all the blame. They rely on the information provided by the cast, which can sometimes be misleading—much like a resume. This ultimately impacts the overall matchmaking process, resulting in unsuccessful pairings. Moreover, many contestants take part in the show only to gain fame. Another significant issue is that the 'MAFS' experts often fail to provide the correct guidance to the couples.

They also have been criticized for not being involved enough and only stepping in when problems become too severe to handle on their own. With 'Married At First Sight' Season 18 nearing its release, there is hope that the experts have learned from their terrible track record and made necessary changes.

(@lifetime)
'MAFS' couples' relationships tend to falter shortly after the show (@lifetime)

Are the ‘MAFS’ experts’ licenses genuine?

Given the poor track record of the 'Married At First Sight' experts, questions often arise about the legitimacy of their licenses. The short answer is yes; the 'MAFS' experts' licenses are genuine. They are professionals in their respective fields, committed to guiding the contestants. Dr. Pia Holec is a clinical psychologist, sex therapist, and coach, holding both a master’s and doctorate in clinical psychology from The Chicago School of Professional Psychology, according to iamdrpia.

Dr. Pepper Schwartz is a "sex, love, and romance expert" as well as a sociology professor at the University of Washington in Seattle, with a BA and MA from Washington University in St. Louis, according to her Instagram. Additionally, Pastor Calvin Roberson is a marriage coach and relationship expert, holding a BA in Theology from Oakwood University and a Master of Divinity from Andrews University, as noted by Lifetime.

(Instagram@dr_pepper_schwartz)
Dr. Pepper Schwartz is a sex, love, and romance expert (Instagram/@dr_pepper_schwartz)

Are any couples assigned by the experts still together?

Over 17 seasons and 69 pairs, 37 couples chose to stay together at the end of the experiment. However, only 11 of those couples remain together today. While this figure is relatively low, it is commendable that a panel of experts was able to achieve any level of success. Although most couples have divorced, it is notable that the couples who remain together are leading happy and healthy lives.

One such couple is 'Married At First Sight' Season 16 contestants Nicole and Christopher, who currently live in Nashville and are proud dog parents. Another remarkable couple from the Lifetime show is Briana and Vincent from Season 12, who celebrated their first anniversary this year. Season 10’s Jessica and Austin are also among the successful couples from the show.

Austin Hurd and Jessica Studer are still married (Instagram/@jessica_studer2)
'Married At First Sight' contestants Austin Hurd and Jessica Studer are still married (Instagram/@jessica_studer2)

'MAFS' Season 18 will premiere on Tuesday, October 15 at 8 pm ET on Lifetime

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

A former ‘RHOBH’ star has filmed with the Season 16 cast, but questions remain about her role. Her latest update offers a glimpse of the reunion and the drama ahead.
2026-11-04T20:49:29.000Z
‘Dancing with the Stars’ will host a brand new theme along with a face-off in next week’s episode
2026-11-04T10:25:19.000Z
‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11 finale sees Wilson and Wilnie clash over expectations before splitting
2026-11-04T09:35:45.000Z
Among the engaged couples featured on the show, only one made it to the altar and said ‘I do.’
2026-11-04T08:23:28.000Z
During his recent appearance on Oliver Hudson’s podcast, David Charvet reflected on his feud with Collin
2026-11-04T07:40:50.000Z
Riley Green also struggled to accept the young singer as a ‘human’ after witnessing her latest performance.
2026-11-04T05:48:33.000Z
Aneha and Cam’s ‘Love Is Blind’ wedding preparations take a turn when her sister raises concerns, leaving the bride with more to consider.
2026-11-03T19:46:46.000Z
The Don suspected one contestant of developing a connection with Demi Engemann
2026-11-03T07:31:50.000Z
‘The Next Pro’ winner Adele Zaikman, who made her debut on the series in season 35, was missing Disney Night on Nov 2 after coming down with an illness
2026-11-03T05:28:50.000Z
Julia Stiles and Ezra Sosa, and Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas found themselves in the bottom two
2026-11-03T03:14:28.000Z