'Love Island': Jeremy and Bailey come third, upset fans say 'they changed our votes'

'Love Island' fans were convinced that Jeremy was either a producer or his father worked for CBS as an explanation for his continued stay on the show
'Love Island' Season 3 stars Bailey Marshall and Jeremy Hershberg (CBS)
'Love Island' Season 3 stars Bailey Marshall and Jeremy Hershberg (CBS)

After watching the number of times Jeremy Hershberg managed to bounce back from being voted out/ eliminated from the show, 'Love Island' fans were convinced that he was either a producer or his father worked for CBS as an explanation to his continued stay on the show despite fans trying to get him off the island at every given opportunity. So fans were convinced that Jeremy and his partner Bailey Marshall might win Season 3 of 'Love Island'. 

With the many red flags in Will Moncada and Kyra Lizama's relationship and the general dislike towards Olivia Kaiser, Korey and Charlie Lynch, 'Love Island' fans were convinced that Jeremy and Bailey could easily take home the $100,000 prize money. However, fans were in for a rude shock when Korey Gandy and Olivia were announced as winners while Jeremy and Bailey came in third place.

RELATED ARTICLES

Will Jeremy and Bailey win 'Love Island' Season 3? Fans say 'everyone good is gone'

'Love Island' fans enjoy Korey and Jeremy's 'bromance', dub them 'best couple by far'

'Love Island' stars Jeremy Hershberg and Bailey Marshall (CBS)

Although Jeremy wasn't a fan-favorite islander on the show, over the past few episodes he began growing on fans. His quirky personality coupled with his attempts to building a connection with Bailey earned him a decent fan following. So, when it was time for America to vote for the winning couple, many fans declared on Twitter that they would be voting for Jeremy and Bailey, just so Will- Kyra & Olivia- Korey wouldn't get their hands on the money. But it looks like the grand plan failed.

Many fans took to Twitter to question the authenticity of the votes after Jeremy and Bailey came third. A fan tweeted, "Jeremy and Bailey coming in 3rd is suspicious. Did they even count the votes? Ugh. Whatever. I'm glad it's over and done with. #LoveIslandUSA." Another fan wrote, "No way Bailey and Jeremy got 3rd. We know they changed our votes. #LoveIslandUSA." "I would like a recount of the votes since we all voted for Jeremy. The math ain’t mathing. #LoveIslandUSA," echoed a fan. 



 



 



 

'Love Island' Season 3 winners Olivia Kaiser and Korey Gandy (CBS)

Another fan shared, "#loveislandusa THIS SH*TE IS RIGGED BC IK EVERYONE VOTED FOR JEREMY AND BAILEY …..BUT NOW ANTI BLM TRUMPIE OLIVIA HAS $50K." "WE’VE BEEN ROBBED no way with 80% of Twitter rooting for Bailey and Jeremy they got 3rd… #loveislandusa," pointed out a fan. "Those Facebook mom’s robbed us of our petty revenge victory for Jeremy #LoveIslandUSA," declared a fan.



 



 



 

'Love Island' Season 3 is available for streaming on Paramount +. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Despite divided online fan reactions, the show hit record-breaking ratings ahead of its highly anticipated series finale, 'Blood and Bone.'
6 hours ago
The production team turned real hangout spots, hotels, and an Olympic sports arena into the beautiful world of Garrett and Hannah.
6 hours ago
The topical nature of 'South Park' is sustained by creators Terry Parker and Matt Stone penning each episode week by week, thus keeping them fresh.
7 hours ago
Greenlighting the show has been the network's major 2026-27 move after it released its fall schedule last week.
8 hours ago
Ahead of highly-awaited 'The Boys' Season 5 finale, buzz has all been about whether Homelander dies, with one particular leak catching fan attention.
8 hours ago
Set photos from 'Dexter: Resurrection' Season 2 reveal a surprising character return, threatening to expose the vigilante's dark past once more
8 hours ago
The focus has already been on 'Marshals' Season 2, and one of the show's central stars shared a major update on the second season.
9 hours ago
Ella Bright plays Hannah Wells, an aspiring singer-songwriter who falls in love with the all-star hockey player, Garrett Graham.
10 hours ago
With the countdown well and truly on for an epic 'The Boys' Season 5 finale, here are 7 episodes to catch up on to stay up-to-date
10 hours ago
Sony hypes the upcoming live-action 'Spider-Noir' series starring Nicolas Cage with a striking new dual-style poster ahead of its final trailer.
10 hours ago