About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use Accuracy & Fairness Corrections & Clarifications Ethics Code Your Ad Choices
© MEAWW All rights reserved

'It Was Always You' Full Cast List: Meet Erin Krakow, Tyler Hynes and the rest of the actors of Hallmark's romantic comedy

Elizabeth starts to question her life decision after her future brother-in-law comes back to town. Find out who plays these characters in the romantic comedy
Erin Krakow as Elizabeth and Tyler Hynes as David in 'It Was Always You' (Hallmark)
Erin Krakow as Elizabeth and Tyler Hynes as David in 'It Was Always You' (Hallmark)

'It Was Always You' centers around finding love when you least expect to or least want to. 'It Was Always You' centers around Elizabeth, who is right in the middle of planning her engagement when her fiancée's free-spirited brother David returns home.

David's presence causes Elizabeth to question her life decisions. Fans of Hallmark's romantic fare have been particularly looking forward to the release of 'It Was Always You' due to the easy chemistry its lead pair seems to share.

Let's now introduce you to the stars of 'It Was Always You.'


'It Was Always You': Release date, plot, trailer, cast and all you need to know about Hallmark's romantic film

'Mix Up in the Mediterranean' Full Cast List: Meet Jeremy Jordan, Jessica Lowndes and rest of the stars from Hallmark movie

Erin Krakow as Elizabeth

Erin Krakow is something of a Hallmark regular. Not only is she known for her starring role on the Hallmark Channel's 'When Calls the Heart', but she has also played many other popular characters on the Hallmark channel, including Samantha Hart in 'Chance at Romance', Samantha Walker in 'A Summer Romance' and Christie in 'A Cookie Cutter Christmas'. On Hallmark Movies & Mysteries, Krakow played Miranda in 'Finding Father Christmas', 'Engaging Father Christmas' and 'Marrying Father Christmas' and Ella in 'Sense, Sensibility & Snowmen'.

Erin is also known for her recurring role on Lifetime Television's 'Army Wives'. She has also guest-starred on a number of popular television series such as 'Castle' and  'NCIS'.

Erin Krakow stars in 'It Was Always You' (Getty Images)

Tyler Hynes as David

Tyler Hynes got his professional start at eight years old and has been performing in one way or the other ever since. At the age of 18, Tyler landed a role in the Andie MacDowell, Tim Roth starrer 'The Last Sign'.

Shortly after, Hynes played the role of Patrick Walker in NBC's 'The Firm', based on John Grisham’s novel. Most recently, Hynes can be seen in a recurring role this season of 'UnREAL' as well as a lead in the upcoming feature, 'Peace', starring opposite Alexander Ludwig. He also plays Luke Reid on 'Saving Hope' which has introduced him to a new set of fans. His other notable recurring guest-starring roles include 'Transporter: The Series' and the critically acclaimed Canadian series, '19-2'.

Tyler Hynes stars in 'It Was Always You' (Getty Images)

Giles Panton as George

Giles Panton plays George, Elizabeth's straight-laced fiance and the free-spirited David's brother. Giles Panton has worked in television, film, stage and is particularly well known for his voice work. He has had the opportunity to voice iconic characters such as Tarzan on Netflix's 'Tarzan' and supervillains such as Norman Osborn and Carnage for Marvel.

Giles Panton with Erin Karkow in 'It Was Always You' (Hallmark)

Elysia Rotaru as Louise 

Elysia Rotaru plays George and David's sister Louise an award-winning artist in 'It Was Always You'. Rotaru is an actress and producer known for 'Arrow', 'Dead Again in Tombstone' and 'Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Rodrick Rules'.

Elysia Rotaru stars in 'It Was Always You' (elysiarotaru/Instagram )

Who are the other stars?

The other stars of 'It Was Always You' include Craig Haas, Nelson Wong and Morgana Wyllie.


'It Was Always You' is directed by Michael Robison. The producers include Kathy Kloves, Joey Plager, Charles Cooper and Risa Shapiro.


You can catch 'It Was Always You' on Saturday, February 27, 9 pm/ 8c on the Hallmark Channel.