Is 'The Voice' all smoke and mirrors? Ex-contestants reveal what happens when the cameras are off

A former contestant revealed that "the producers were really persistent in having her meet up for an audition."
PUBLISHED APR 20, 2025
"The Voice" coaches Michael Bublé, Gwen Stefani, Reba McEntire and Snoop Dogg on the set of "The Voice" during the Playoff round. (Cover image source: YouTube | The Voice)
"The Voice" coaches Michael Bublé, Gwen Stefani, Reba McEntire and Snoop Dogg on the set of "The Voice" during the Playoff round. (Cover image source: YouTube | The Voice)

'The Voice' has some interesting elements that set it apart from its counterparts, such as 'American Idol.' However, are these interesting elements actually the truth? Are the blind auditions actually 'blind'? Well, not quite, as there are certain caveats to it. As reported by Pinkvilla, 'The Voice' actually orchestrates some major elements of the show, elements that actually are the founding pillars of the competition. The blind auditions gimmick is something that has always drawn people to the show. However, sources suggest that the coaches are already aware of the contestants before the performance even begins.



 

Pinkvilla revealed, "The judges usually get some details about the singer’s background, which helps them fabricate a better conversation." The blind auditions are, in fact, supposed to be the fourth step of auditioning, with the contestants even getting a chance to rehearse their song before performing it in front of the camera. While it does take away from the thrill of the show, Pinkvilla reported the show does this to help the performers "get used to the space."



 

That said, the iconic chair-turning sound that viewers are used to isn't real either, as the sound is added in post-production. While watching the auditions of reality shows, one would think that the contestants go to the show themselves as they want to make a name for themselves. However, that might not be the case with 'The Voice.' Season 1 contestant Vicci Martinez revealed in a conversation with Cosmopolitan that "the producers were really persistent in having her meet up for an audition." Usually this show reaches out to the managers of established singers to get them to audition for 'The Voice.'


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Frenchie Davis (@frenchiedavis)


 

The least one can expect from a show called 'The Voice' is for the contestants to have their own say in what song they pick. However, that doesn't seem to be the case. As reported by Cosmopolitan, Frenchie Davis, a contestant of season 1, revealed, “It’s always hysterical when the judges say, ‘I don’t think that was a good song choice for you,’ and I’m thinking, ‘You picked that song.” Even more baffling is the fact that the viewers don't even get to listen to the actual voice of the contestants during the auditions, as their voice is auto-tuned.


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by NBC's The Voice (@nbcthevoice)


 

'The Voice' contestants are even made to sign an agreement with a clause that states that "they could be embarrassed during the show." It is true that reality shows survive based on TV ratings. Drama and spectacle are essential to making good reality TV shows. However, there is a fine line the producers need to tread between what needs to stay real and what needs to be orchestrated in order to truly stay true to the roots of music.

RELATED TOPICS THE VOICE (2011)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The tribute card at the end of Episode 6 stirred curiosity among the fans
6 hours ago
In addition to the major twists, a key scene hintd at the grim future of Dunk and Egg
8 hours ago
Fans can now watch Catherine O'Hara and the all seasons of the hit sitcom on HBO Max
9 hours ago
While a second season is greenlit, it appears to be a minute before fans get to watch it
10 hours ago
Steve Carell returns to HBO as a famous author whose attempt to save his daughter pulls him deep into campus chaos.
12 hours ago
HBO broke its Sunday routine with an early drop, leaving fans staring down a longer wait as a brutal turning point approaches.
16 hours ago
A deadly case pulls Turner from Yosemite to another park, where fire, secrets, and danger collide once again.
18 hours ago
A stunning Trial of Seven reveal leaves viewers emotional, proving 'A Knight of Seven Kingdoms' has real GOT magic.
1 day ago
The medical drama series is put on hold indefinitely mid-season, allowing 'The Voice' to take over with its revamped 29th season.
1 day ago
'Grey's Anatomy' Season 22, Episode 11, will air on February 26, introducing two new guest stars
1 day ago