'American Idol' changed its voting system and fans have some serious questions: 'I wonder if...'

Did 'American Idol' just ruin its voting system? Fans are questioning the big change
(L-R) Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood and Luke Bryan in screenshot from 'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)
(L-R) Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood and Luke Bryan in screenshot from 'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)

ABC's 'American Idol' Season 23 will not only be best remembered for being Carrie Underwood's debut season as a judge, but also for a huge voting change for selecting the top 12. With Josh King being the latest to exit the show, the race to reach the top is heating up. To add more drama to the competition, the new voting system is also grabbing major headlines, with fans even questioning the fairness of this new method.

Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood, and Ryan Seacrest pose for a photo during
(L-R) Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood, and Ryan Seacrest pose for a photo during 'American Idol' in NYC (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Mike Coppola)

On Sunday, April 27, 'American Idol' Season 23 aired a live show featuring a major announcement and a significant voting change. The episode, themed around Rock & Roll Hall of Fame inductees and mentored by James Taylor, included host Ryan Seacrest revealing the 2025 class of Hall of Fame inductees, which is a tradition he began the previous year with help from Lionel Richie, as per The Things. The biggest twist, however, was a change in voting, as for the first time, live voting occurred during the episode itself, giving viewers less than two hours (from 5:00 to 6:50 PM PST) to vote.



 

The contestants also took it upon themselves to ask for votes. Thunderstorm Artis emphasized this in his social media post, alerting his followers as he posted a photo with the caption, "This Sunday AND Monday they are eliminating 2 people per day. So a total of 4 people." His post highlighted both the urgency and the high-pressure nature of this new format. Gabby Samone also joined in to rally her fans, writing, "We’re going LIVE coast-to-coast  for the first time ever, so remember those votes early as soon as the show starts if you want to see me in the #TOP12!"


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by THUNDERSTORM ARTIS (@thunderstormartis)


 

Notably, this is also the first time this season the judges have had the power to save one contestant from elimination. Fans can also vote in three ways: the first being through the ABC website or the 'American Idol' app (both of which require a sign-in via a MyDisney account) or by texting a contestant’s unique number to 21523, as per Entertainment Now. Each method allows up to 10 votes per contestant, totaling 30 votes across platforms. Votes can be changed during the episode if saved before the deadline, and viewers are encouraged to vote early, which is even before performances begin.



 

However, it looks like fans are not thrilled with this new voting system, as many shared their opinions under a Reddit post. A fan said, "Yes you’re 100% right. I remember a few years ago before anyone had performed, Ryan said something like “And kudos to you! We already have had 14 million votes have come in!” And I’m thinking… that’s really not a good thing lol," while another added, "My friend’s daughter Mattie is on there. It’s totally unfair to the last person singing that the voting closes right after they sing. I really hope Mattie makes it through!!! I grew up with my grandparents living next door to Ellie's parents (Ellie is Mattie's stepmom)".



 

A viewer remarked, "It's a popularity contest more than anything." Another said, "I've lost interest the past few seasons as soon as they go live for this reason. I can never watch until the next day on streaming so it doesn't matter anyway," while another added, "Yes, this show sure isn't what it used to be." A viewer also questioned the credibility of the show, saying, "I honestly wonder if voting actually does anything at all?"

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The Season 2 finale is out, and the cast is already gearing up for another round of the Harrigan family saga
2026-11-20T12:42:07.000Z
Harry outsmarts Kat and saves the Harrigans, but Eddie’s botched bombing leaves Jan’s fate uncertain in the dramatic ‘MobLand’ Season 2 finale
2026-11-20T12:17:52.000Z
Netflix series ‘Altruists’ revisits the FTX scandal, but the real-life stories of its two central figures, Sam Bankman-Fried and Caroline Ellison, have taken very different turns
2026-11-20T09:14:03.000Z
The medical drama revolves around Lucia, a first-year resident at a prestigious Phoenix hospital
2026-11-20T07:02:02.000Z
After Tim and Lucy’s abduction, the crew gears up for a dangerous rescue mission
2026-11-20T06:18:08.000Z
Trevor Jackson's return to Grey Sloan takes an unexpected turn in the ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Season 23 fall finale, leaving his health in question
2026-11-20T05:51:21.000Z
Mark Grayson takes on greater responsibilities as he struggles to protect Earth while navigating the personal toll of being a superhero in Season 5
2026-11-20T05:27:48.000Z
Hooks was stabbed to death during private yard time, prompting the FBI to investigate anyone who may have had a motive
2026-11-20T04:31:44.000Z
'The Gilded Age' is enjoying its strongest season yet, with viewership nearly 20% higher than the previous instalment
2026-11-19T20:50:24.000Z
This ‘Off Campus’ star reveals why his planned Season 2 return fell through, leaving questions about Allie and Dean’s story and his future.
2026-11-19T20:32:39.000Z