‘American Idol’ might’ve just found its new heartthrob — how this fan girl reacted is proof enough

This ‘American Idol’ contestant is making girls swoon with his voice and, let’s be real, his looks (we aren't complaining)
Screenshot of an 'American Idol' fan girl and John Foster from a May 2025 episode (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)
Screenshot of an 'American Idol' fan girl and John Foster from a May 2025 episode (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)

It seems like 'American Idol' fans can't contain their excitement after seeing their favorite singers! During the most recent episode of the ABC singing show, which was released on May 5, the Top 8 contestants performed the songs that were secretly picked by the esteemed judges Carrie Underwood, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan in the “Judge’s Song Contest.” In the episode, contestant John Foster performed a beautiful rendition of 'I Cross My Heart' by George Strait, and he won over the judges and the crowd with his flawless vocals. At the end of Foster's performance, an 'American Idol' fan girl who was seated in the studio audience bounced with excitement and was seen swooning over him as he performed on the stage.



 

As per Parade magazine, when Underwood was asked to share her feedback on Foster's performance, the 'If I Didn't Love You' hitmaker went on to say, "The reason I picked the songs for everybody is I've been in your shoes, and I feel like I know what will showcase your voice the best and what people out there want to hear and vote for. I was so right. That was absolutely perfect. Hearing you sing that song, it felt comfortable, it felt genuine. I feel like that was one of your best performances, John. And it made me so happy." Shortly afterward, Judge Bryan chimed in, "It was the perfect song for you… You’re singing better and better every week.”



 

Foster shares a special bond with Underwood. Before this, Foster dedicated his performance of 'I Told You So' to Underwood. For the unversed, Underwood performed the same song with Randy Travis many years ago on the show. In an interview with People magazine, Underwood shed light on Foster's journey and said, "He’s so sweet and fresh-faced and he’s one of those people that I feel like… don’t even really know how good you are kind of thing. Week to week, we have watched him progress so much. We were talking after his performance, me, Luke, and [Lionel], and we were just saying he’s probably the one that has grown the most since he’s been here.”



 

When 'American Idol' uploaded a video of Foster's performance on YouTube, the fans flooded the comments section with many messages. One social media user gushed over Foster's looks and wrote, "Incredibly handsome and one of the best young country singers to ever hit the stage." Followed by a second user who penned, "I just love John! He’s an amazing performer! All through American Idol, he has done true to the perfection of his performances. He has great stage presence, and he’s just a talented young man!"



 

Another viewer chimed in, "I love John's performance touched my heart so gracefully and beautiful. He is a country star. My prediction is that he will win American Idol season 23. Carrie picked the perfect song for John."  A user mirrored the same sentiments by commenting, "Very pretty song. Nice job. I really think this young man should win...that said, he kinda, already has.. Maybe it's better if he doesn't, so he can make his own choices without Idols constraints..." One fan quipped, "Wow, now I know why his voice sounds familiar, it’s like listening to George back in his younger days ! I think John carries himself much like George, both class acts, both “gentlemen” a word not even used much anymore."

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Ganesh's exit at the end of Season 2 drew a ton of backlash from fans, who suspected on-set drama was to blame for her unexpected departure.
1 hour ago
The third installment of the series is based on the second half of the video game 'The Last of Us Part II' and will focus on Abby's story
3 hours ago
‘Schmigadoon!’ is an Apple TV series about a modern couple who are transported back to a rustic town in the 1940s.
4 hours ago
'FROM' is created by John Griffin and focuses on a small town that traps everyone inside
4 hours ago
Pauley Perrette played forensic scientist Dr. Abby Sciuto and often shared the screen with Brian Dietzen's Dr. Jimmy Palmer
5 hours ago
Lestat takes over the world as a rockstar as new relationships and more twists surface in the 'Immortal Universe.'
10 hours ago
Considering there are three iterations of 'Cape Fear', the end for Max Cady is different in each version.
2 days ago
Paramount+ drops all episodes of the ‘Among Us’ adaptation just after an announcement at the Summer Game Fest.
2 days ago
Peter McFerrin faces off against Seth McElroy and Jackie Goncalves in Saturday's episode of ‘Jeopardy!’.
2 days ago
After a lengthy break following Season 2, Paramount+ has shared a major ‘Lioness’ Season 3 update as Joe faces dangers that hit closer to home.
2 days ago