How old is Sarah Hyland? Actress almost lost Haley Dunphy's role in 'Modern Family' as she was 'too old'

Sarah Hyland revealed in an interview that her agent's assistant fought for her to get her a chance to read for the part
UPDATED JUL 20, 2023
Sarah Hyland revealed 'Modern Family's casting directors didn't even put her on video for the first reading (Tommaso Boddi/Getty Images for Los Angeles LGBT Center)
Sarah Hyland revealed 'Modern Family's casting directors didn't even put her on video for the first reading (Tommaso Boddi/Getty Images for Los Angeles LGBT Center)

LOS ANGELES , CALIFORNIA: Just over three years after the highly successful 11-season run of the iconic ABC sitcom 'Modern Family' ended, Sarah Hyland is discussing how she nearly didn't earn the role of Haley Dunphy.

The actress, now 32, revealed in an interview with Buzzfeed that she was first informed that she was too old to play the role. "Originally, they didn’t want to see me for 'Modern Family' because I was 18 and Haley’s character was 15. They were like, "She’s too old,"' she recalled. 

'She looks very, very young'

Sarah Hyland attends the 2019 Pre-Emmy Party hosted by Entertainment Weekly and L’Oreal Paris at Sunset Tower Hotel in Los Angeles on Friday, September 20, 2019.
Sarah Hyland attends the 2019 Pre-Emmy Party hosted by Entertainment Weekly and L’Oreal Paris at Sunset Tower Hotel in Los Angeles (Emma McIntyre/Getty Images for Entertainment Weekly)

But in the end, someone fought for Hyland and secured an audition for her to show off her skills. She said, "At the time, my agent's assistant fought for me to enter the room, saying, "She doesn't look 18 years old, I promise you! She looks very, very young!"'

'They didn't put my audition on the tape'

Hyland continued by saying that the casting directors didn't even put her on video for the first reading because they already believed she was too old. She said, "I went in and they pre-read me for the cast — like, they didn't put my audition on the tape — and then he brought in the casting director." She added, "The casting director, Jeff [Greenberg], had me read and then he was like, "Okay, now do it again, and now I'll put it on tape." They just were very much like, "She's too old. She's 18."

Hyland was flawless as Haley

(IMdb)
Hyland eventually gained access to visit the director and creators (IMDb)

Hyland eventually gained access to visit the director and creators. The New York City native proved herself and got the part by refusing to let the doubters crush her confidence and desire. From the series' debut in September 2009 all the way up to the show's conclusion in April 2020, Hyland was flawless in her depiction of Haley.

Ed O'Neill, Sofa Vergara, Julie Bowen, Ty Burrell, Jesse Tyler Ferguson, Eric Stonestreet, Ariel Winter, Nolan Gould, Rico Rodriguez, Aubrey Anderson-Emmons, Jeremy Maguire, and Reid Ewing were all included in the cast in addition to Hyland. Each of the show's first five seasons received an Emmy Award for Outstanding Comedy Series, while Eric Stonestreet and Ty Burrell each received two for Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series.

RELATED TOPICS MODERN FAMILY (2009) SARAH HYLAND

MORE STORIES

John Oliver was bleeped out twice during his brief, 15-second Emmys acceptance speech on live television after he roasted host Nate Bargatze
Sep 15, 2025
Kevin Hart doesn't appreciate paparazzi’s question after viral video of him hosting Diddy’s party resurfaces
Apr 6, 2025
Diddy’s childhood friend Tim Patterson claims Janice Combs’s wild parties often involved pimps, homosexuals, and other adult activities
Apr 6, 2025
Lisa Marie Presley and Michael Jackson tied the knot in 1994, but she initially thought the King of Pop was a creep—and we totally get why
Apr 6, 2025
Riley Keough opens up about the Presley family curse in a candid interview while on tour for her book, 'From Here to the Great Unknown'
Apr 5, 2025
Natalie Morales hits back after her interview with Seth Meyers is removed from all platforms due to a revealing outfit
Apr 5, 2025
"Babyface, can you believe she wants me to dress like a girl?" Michael Jackson told a producer.
Apr 2, 2025
Sofia Vergara also dished out on why she doesn't ever want to play Modern Family's Gloria again
Apr 2, 2025
"It took more and more to get high, and I honestly don't know when your body decides it can't deal with it anymore," Lisa Marie Presley wrote.
Apr 1, 2025
A family member's last-minute intervention saved Michael Jackson from the 9/11 tragedy—here’s what happened
Apr 1, 2025