Did Richard Goodall ruin his shot at 'AGT' finale? Watch singer fail to hit mark with new spin on 80s song

Richard Goodall's song selection for 'AGT' Season 19 semi-final could hurt his chances at finale
UPDATED SEP 12, 2024
Richard Goodall changed his tune for 'AGT' Season 19 semi finale (@nbc)
Richard Goodall changed his tune for 'AGT' Season 19 semi finale (@nbc)

PASADENA, CALIFORNIA: Richard Goodall, the 'America's Got Talent' Season 19 semi-finalist, anxiously moved off-stage and wrung his hands while Terry Crews encouraged him. His hometown greeted him as a hero when he returned after his audition so the September 11 episode pressured him to prove himself. Simon Cowell advised that he choose a song that no one would expect. Richard, a high school janitor, got one of Heidi Klum's Golden Buzzers earlier in the season before moving on to the September 11 episode to perform ‘Eye of the Tiger’.

He began acappella, which is usually a crowd favorite! However, the song "Eye of the Tiger" is rarely surprising. So far, he's stuck with popular 80s power ballads. He has the pipes. In another universe, he may have made a career with that powerful and rangy voice. Maybe if he makes the finals. However, this song choice, as well as the method in which he performed, might have pushed him to the back burner.   



 

'AGT' Season 19 Judges Torn on Richard Goodall's Song Choice 

Heidi said he exceeded his prior efforts and called it an "epic performance." The music selection surprised Simon, but he said it "doesn't matter because people love you."

Sofía Vergara agreed that the crowd adores him and expressed her admiration for the music selection. Richard's large heart was mentioned by Howie Mandel, who also said that they could sense his affection.

Richard Goodall, Terre Haute's 'singing janitor', will be on Season 19 of 'America's Got Talent' (Instagram/richard.goodall)
Richard Goodall got little criticism over his song choice on Season 19 of 'America's Got Talent'  semi final (Instagram/@richard.goodall)

Howie Mandel always wanted Richard Goodall on 'AGT' Season 19

Richard works as a custodian for Vigo County Schools. He became popular on TikTok when former Journey vocalist Steve Perry and 'AGT' judge Howie saw his performance of Journey's "Don't Stop Believin'" at a school talent event.

"Howie, he posted me on his TikTok, and it said, 'Needs to be on AGT,'" Richard said. "Next thing I know, one of the senior producers messages and says, 'Are you interested in being on the show?'"

After receiving a Golden Buzzer from show judge Heidi during his audition, he gained further popularity.

'AGT' Season 19 judge Howie Mandel first spotted Richard Goodall on TikTok (X/howiemandel/NBC)
'AGT' Season 19 judge Howie Mandel first spotted Richard Goodall on TikTok (X/@howiemandel/@nbc)

Can Richard Goodall pull fans' votes for the 'AGT' title?

Richard is an Indiana school janitor who has won hearts with his interpretations of Journey and Michael Bolton songs around the nation. Richard is already having a great time interacting with the fans, but everything depends on them while he is attempting to secure his place in the finale.

He said in a recent interview with TV Insider, "It is just as much fun for me as it is for, I can’t believe I’m saying this, my fans. People from everywhere coming to meet me? Yeah, me."

He further added, "I’ve had people drive from Michigan to meet me. One of the students made a drawing of me that looked great. All of this is so surreal to me."

Even though Simon had his reservations about Richard's recent song choice, as he mentioned, if his fans can pull through for him, maybe he will find himself in this year's finale.

'AGT' Season 19 singer Richard Goodall still works as a janitor (Instagram/richard.goodall)
'AGT' Season 19 singer Richard Goodall still works as a janitor (Instagram/@richard.goodall)

'America's Got Talent' Season 19 airs on Tuesdays and Wednesdays on NBC at 8 PM ET 

RELATED TOPICS AMERICA'S GOT TALENT (2006)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'The Voice' Season 29 returns with Kelly Clarkson, Adam Levine, and John Legend battling it out as past champions.
1 day ago
As 'Traitors' Season 4 unfolds, Dylan Efron reveals which reality star he believes has a real shot at winning it all.
1 day ago
The last remaining Traitor in the game is now required by the rules to recruit a Faithful to join him
1 day ago
'The Masked Singer' Season 14, judged by Ken Jeong, Robin Thicke, Rita Ora, and Jenny McCarthy-Wahlberg, is now set to feature a 'Twilight' week.
2 days ago
A bold rock performance and one very specific pop-history clue may have quietly exposed Eggplant's true identity
3 days ago
A fierce new wildcard stormed the stage with a bold song choice, cryptic hometown clues, and a costume that sparked instant theories
3 days ago
A familiar face stepped out from behind the petals as another wildcard shook up the competition on a clue-heavy night full of guesses and surprises
3 days ago
‘Summer House’ turns up the tension as Kyle Cooke and Amanda Batula’s crumbling marriage becomes the emotional core of the season
4 days ago
After a life-altering injury ended his sports dreams, Braden Rumfelt finds a new path and a powerful voice on ‘American Idol’ Season 24.
5 days ago
'The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City' alum Britani Bateman joined her niece, Carmen Lorell Martin, to sing 'Let Me Be Your Star' by SMASH Cast
5 days ago