'Cruel Intentions' reboot finally arrives, but where's all the steamy seduction we were promised?

'Cruel Intentions' on Prime Video is the official reboot of Sarah Michelle Gellar and Ryan Phillippe starrer 1999 film of the same name
PUBLISHED NOV 21, 2024
'Cruel Intentions' premiered on Prime Video on November 21 (Amazon MGM Studios)
'Cruel Intentions' premiered on Prime Video on November 21 (Amazon MGM Studios)

What comes to your mind when I say 'Cruel Intentions'? The title alone evokes memories of the 1999 film's edgy exploration of sex and power. As every glance, smirk, and violin-laden moment brimmed with unspoken tension, this film turned out to be a guilty pleasure that you keep to yourself, no matter how old you are!

25 years later, Prime Video has come out with a television adaptation of the film with a fresh, modern take. Now you must have the same question as everyone else- does it bring the same heat as the OG? We are here to answer it!

Prime Video's 'Cruel Intentions' is baked in same mold but feels different

Sarah Catherine Hook and Zac Burgess in 'Cruel Intentions' (Amazon MGM Studios)
Sarah Catherine Hook and Zac Burgess in 'Cruel Intentions' (Amazon MGM Studios)

The 1999 film was uncomfortably bold. Watching Sebastian and Kathryn manipulate everyone around them felt like eavesdropping on something taboo. Every scene smoldered, dripping with tension and scandal. The dynamics between the stepsiblings were unholy yet captivatingly provocative. Yes, it left us cringing and gasping and secretly rooting for the chaos.

Now let's talk about the new series. The Prime Video series shifts its backdrop from the cutthroat world of New York prep schools to the backstabbing arena of Washington, DC’s Greek life. We are introduced to Caroline Merteuil (Sarah Catherine Hook) and Lucien Belmont (Zac Burgess), two power-hungry step-siblings scheming to dominance. While the modern twist is a welcoming change, the reboot feels like someone turned down the thermostat. The risks are calculated, the sensuality dulled, and the once-shocking storyline now feels oddly tame.

'Cruel Intentions' rectifies some issues at a cost

Savannah Lee Smith and Zac Burgess in 'Cruel Intentions' (Amazon MGM Studios)
Savannah Lee Smith and Zac Burgess in 'Cruel Intentions' (Amazon MGM Studios)

Let's all agree that 1999 was quite problematic. I mean, Sebastian was an outright patriarchal psycho. Thankfully, the series replaces this with fewer undertones of misogyny. Yet, in an attempt to address problematic elements, the show trades its signature rawness for a safe, palatable drama.

The steamy tension, which defined the OG 'Cruel Intentions', is glaringly absent. Surprisingly, Disney+'s 'Rivals' embraced scandal and passion unapologetically (cough, Penelope and Colin in 'Bridgerton'). Sadly, the Prime Video reboot plays coy. The electric tension between the step-siblings is barely reduced to flirtation. Where are the scenes that make you feel like you shouldn’t be watching, yet you can’t look away?

We aren't saying that the Prime Video series is all bad. It isn't! The cast is stunning, and the premise holds your intrigue. But without the deliciously sinful energy that made the original iconic, this reboot feels like a watered-down cocktail at a party you were excited about until you realized the playlist was just elevator music.

All the episodes of 'Cruel Intentions' are now streaming on Prime Video

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘Bridgerton’ Season 4 Part one ends on a risky ask, but the second-half brings a walk-away threat, and a surprise baby cameo.
18 hours ago
Benedict and Sophie’s ‘Bridgerton’ romance heats up in the show's part one, but here’s how Netflix reshapes the classic story from the books.
19 hours ago
Catherine O’Hara’s starrer ‘Schitt’s Creek’ follows a once-wealthy family forced to rebuild their lives in a tiny town they never planned to call home
19 hours ago
Marvel’s big cosmic reboot just hit the brakes, with ‘Imperial Guardians’ quietly shifting from bold new era to a short run before it even begins.
22 hours ago
Ahead of host Trevor Noah kicking off the Grammys 2026, celebrities from Teddy Swims to PinkPantheress are celebrating early.
1 day ago
By the end of the first half of 'Bridgerton' Season 4, Danbury has set things in motion that may ultimately lead to her departure
1 day ago
A ‘Daredevil’ (2003) actor turns up in ‘Wonder Man’, but Marvel flips expectations with a sharp, self-aware cameo.
1 day ago
Showrunner Jess Brownell had teased the leads for 'Bridgerton' Seasons 5 and 6 in a creative reveal using her pocket square
1 day ago
Before joining the staff at Penwood House, Sophie had a very different life as the ward of Lord Penwood, her biological father
1 day ago
Trevor Noah will host the upcoming 68th edition of the Grammy Awards in what will be his last appearance as the event's MC
1 day ago