Netflix 'Atypical' Season 4: How does Casey's dad react to the news that she is dating Izzie?

Casey is played by actor Brigette Lundy Paine who came out as non binary in 2019
Michael Rapaport stars as Douglas Gardner (Netflix)
Michael Rapaport stars as Douglas Gardner (Netflix)

Season 4 of 'Atypical' starts with Casey Gardner (Brigette Lundy Paine) still grappling with her sexuality. While many of those closest to her, including her mother Elsa (Jennifer Jason Leigh), Sam (Keir Gilchrist) her brother and the protagonist of the show and her former boyfriend Evan (Graham Rogers) know that she is now involved with her former rival Izzie, it is her father Doug (Michael Rapaport) that Casey seems to be avoiding coming out to. 

When her mother tries to oh so casually ask her when Casey is planning to tell her dad that she's dating Izzie, Casey pretends like she is mulling it over and then tells her mother to butt out. Casey however then in a more vulnerable moment tells her mother that she is worried that her father simply won't know what to say when she tells him and that will make things awkward and weird. Her mother then suggests that Casey attends a gender and sexuality Alliance Meeting which is taking place. Izzie comes along for moral support and it seems like she enjoys the meeting far more than Casey who feels out of place. Casey and Izzie's relationship has taken centre stage in the show which centres around 19-year-old Sam who is on the autism spectrum, due to fans interest in the relationship. If shows like 'Atypical' appeal to you, you may also enjoy shows such as 'Love on the Spectrum' and 'Hannah Gadsby: Douglas'. 

READ MORE

'Atypical' Full Cast List: Meet Keir Gilchrist, Jennifer Jason Leigh and other stars of Netflix show

'Love on the Spectrum': Amazing parents of young adults with autism are the show's real unsung heroes

Brigette Lundy Paine and Fivel Stewart star as Casey Gardner and Izzie on 'Atypical' (Netflix)

It's finally after a day united as a family helping Sam to move into his new apartment, that Casey's mother tells Doug and his daughter to talk. It turns out that Casey had nothing to worry about. While her father is initially surprised to hear that she's dating Izzie, he's more concerned about why she never told him earlier. She says that she was scared that it would change the way he saw her. He says that it hasn't and he still thinks she's a giant pain in the ass. It's an incredibly sweet scene and for parents who want to navigate potentially tricky territory about sexuality, this scene is a good example of how it can be handled with humour, compassion and sensitivity. Now that Casey's dad has accepted her sexuality, the question can Casey be comfortable in her own skin as well, and accept that she's not just 'hanging out' with Izzie but that they are an actual couple. To find out you can catch the episodes of Season 4 of 'Atypical' which began streaming on Netflix on July 9. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

An assassination warning raises questions about Chani’s role as Paul faces the consequences of his reign in ‘Dune: Part Three’
2026-10-27T17:57:16.000Z
Chris Pratt returns in 'Way of the Warrior Kid', an Apple TV military drama about building confidence with help from a Navy SEAL uncle.
2026-10-27T15:15:06.000Z
'Godzilla Minus One' director Takashi Yamazaki recruits Sam Nivola and Nico Parker for Grandgear, an upcoming studio film produced by J.J. Abrams.
2026-10-27T14:03:29.000Z
'Ali G: Who Iz I?' set to arrive on Prime Video days after its release
2026-10-27T08:34:14.000Z
Director Francis Lawrence (‘The Hunger Games’) and screenwriter Michael Green are working on the project
2026-10-27T04:55:30.000Z
Jaume Collet-Serra’s next Netflix thriller pits a federal marshal against attackers and a hurricane.
2026-10-26T18:48:10.000Z
The WWII drama follows 4 football players whose lives take them far beyond the field, prompting many to ask whether the story is based on true events.
2026-10-26T17:48:26.000Z
'Almost You' explores grief and artificial intelligence as a robotics engineer creates a digital replica of her late sister, starring Joey King.
2026-10-26T15:55:48.000Z
Michael Mann’s 'Heat 2' expands the original crime saga with Stephen Graham, Leonardo DiCaprio, Christian Bale, and Adam Driver.
2026-10-26T14:43:21.000Z
‘Clayface’ takes DCU to Gotham, raising questions about Batman, its timeline and surprise cameos.
2026-10-26T14:14:43.000Z