'American Idol' Season 18 Finale: Fans want Arthur Gunn to be champion, say Just Sam had a better 'sob story'

The young Nepali with the raspy soulful voice has consistently been one of the reasons to tune into the show, but he eventually emerged as the runner-up to Just Sam
Arthur Gunn (ABC)
Arthur Gunn (ABC)

The long 'American Idol' journey is now over, and the talented Dibesh Pokharel aka Arthur Gunn can rest easy knowing that he has now completed a roller coaster ride all the way to the grand finale. It's been an amazing experience watching the young man from Nepal consistently knocking it out of the park each and every night with millions of Americans agreeing that he was going to be crowned the eventual winner. His raspy, soulful, sandpapery voice has consistently been one of the reasons to tune into the show, but he eventually emerged as the runner-up to Just Sam, the subway singer from New York, who has also impressed us with her stunning voice and rags-to-riches story. 

The 18th season of the celebrated singing competition finished off in grand style, with the Top 7 being cut down to the Top 5 at beginning of the show. We sadly said goodbye to two talented singers in Louis Knight and Julia Gargano, while the Top 5 of Arthur Gunn, Just Sam, Francisco Martin, Jonny West, and Dillon James then performed two songs each. 

The judges talk to Arthur Gunn (ABC)

The first song was billed as the song that the contestants wanted to celebrate their journey to the top while the second song would be a nostalgic track, looking back at each singer's best performance from the entire season of the singing contest. This second song was also touted as a winner's single and will be made available to the American public after the eventual champion was crowned.

Dillon James sang 'Change The World' by Eric Clapton and then 'The Times They Are A-Changin' by Bob Dylan. Francisco Martin sang 'Adore You' by Harry Styles and then 'Alaska' by Maggie Rogers. Jonny West did 'Can't Keep A Good Man Down' by James & Bobby Purify, and then followed that up with his own original song called 'Makin' Love'. 



 

The new champion Just Sam performed 'Stronger (What Doesnt Kill You)' by former 'American Idol' winner Kelly Clarkson and then performed a quintessential version of 'Rise Up' by Andra Day. Meanwhile, Arthur rocked the house with soulful renditions of 'I Don't Wanna Be' by Gavin DeGraw and followed that up with his authentic take on 'Have You Ever Seen The Rain' by Creedence Clearwater Revival, making it his third original spin on a song that first launched him into the public eye. His glorious voice is certainly something to marvel at, gravelly and powerful, raw and open-throated, it's a genuine surprise that he ended up as the runner-up, because the modest young Arthur looked and sounded like a champion from day one. 

Fans on social media were also shocked that he didn't win the competition. One fan said, "Arthur Gunn should have won. His talent far outperformed Sam. She just had a better sob story", while another declared, "Currently trying to figure out how Arthur Gunn didn’t win." There was definitely plenty of love for Arthur, as miffed fans exclaimed "Arthur Gunn got robbed, he should've won! He had the best voice from this season without question!"   



 

More people praised the young Nepali, saying "What Arthur Gunn lacks in sob story he makes up for in talent. He’s the clear winner here," and other admirers stated, "Congrats to Sam but ARTHUR GUNN SHOULD HAVE WON AMERICAN IDOL. I’ve never been so disappointed in my life." Another fan pointed to the stats, saying - "Arthur Gunn had twice as many Google searches than Just Sam in the USA during the finale." 

So was it a conspiracy? A low-blow on the down-low? We'll never know for certain, but what we do know is that Arthur Gunn will become a household name in the United States thanks to his unquestionable talent and incredible voice. He will gain a cult following just like Alejandro Aranda (aka Scarypoolparty) did after last season, so at least we can look forward to hearing his magical supercharged vocals for the next few decades.  

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Sean Reagan’s past shapes a rescue in ‘Boston Blue’ Season 2 Episode 6 as Mika Amonsen discusses continuing the character’s ‘Blue Bloods’ story.
2026-11-14T19:02:59.000Z
Left Bank Pictures has responded to a tragic incident at the Edinburgh studio used for ‘Dept. Q’ as police inquiries into the circumstances continue.
2026-11-14T15:25:47.000Z
A fan-favorite ‘Matlock’ star shares a behind-the-scenes update as the CBS drama prepares for its Season 3 return.
2026-11-14T14:08:57.000Z
‘Gilmore Girls’ documentary ‘Drink Coffee, Talk Fast’ brings back familiar cast members, including Jared Padalecki and Scott Pattersonts
2026-11-14T10:08:21.000Z
'CSI' veteran Marg Helgenberger was once one of the highest-paid small-screen actresses
2026-11-14T09:17:43.000Z
Dexter sets his sights on the Jaw Splitter in Season 2, Episode 3, while a fan theory links the mysterious killer to actor Jack Dylan Grazer.
2026-11-14T07:37:35.000Z
‘Law & Order: SVU’ showrunner Michele Fazekas addresses Benson and Stabler’s future after their emotional reunion in the milestone 600th episode
2026-11-14T07:25:13.000Z
‘Station 19’ alum Jay Hayden joins ‘Fire Country’ Season 5 as Mason Ellis, whose return to Edgewater sparks a new conflict between Bode and Jake
2026-11-14T06:34:18.000Z
CBS brings ‘Marshals’ and ‘Tracker’ back to its Sunday lineup on November 15 with new episodes following a one-week break for ‘Cupertino.’
2026-11-14T05:54:18.000Z
Boone and Mickey's relationship gets complicated with Emmy's arrival in 'Sheriff Country'
2026-11-14T04:43:33.000Z