'AGT' Season 19: Watch Howie Mandel take a bold shot at Latino boy band Menudo

'AGT' Season 19 judge Howie Mandel was not on board with Menudo, comparing their performance to something from Saturday morning television
'AGT' Season 19 judge Howie Mandel criticized Menudo's live performance (@nbc)
'AGT' Season 19 judge Howie Mandel criticized Menudo's live performance (@nbc)

PASADENA, CALIFORNIA: The Latino boy band Menudo was the first group to play on 'America's Got Talent' Season 19, Episode 13. After their initial audition, Simon Cowell encouraged them to "be yourselves" rather than letting the industry shape their image.

They performed their new song, "Party in California," with complete Spanish lyrics. However, Howie Mandel criticized their performance, comparing it to something from Saturday morning TV.



 

Howie Mandel was underwhelmed by the revamped Menudo during their tryout, describing their performance as lackluster. The group, which was popular among Latino audiences in the 1980s and 1990s, frequently changed its lineup as its members aged. While their voices and tunes may lack vibrancy, their outfits are eye-catching. Despite the years, this group likely still has a dedicated audience. The young performers may sing off-key, but they have a certain charm.

Howie remained unimpressed, stating, "Good news, I don’t get to vote. I felt like I was on a Saturday morning kids show on Telemundo." Is Howie dismissing the band unfairly? We'll find out if they become fan favorites when the poll results are revealed on Wednesday, 28 August.

'AGT' Season 19 judge Howie Mandel criticizes Menudo's Live performance (NBC)
'AGT' Season 19 judge Howie Mandel criticizes Menudo's Live performance (@nbc)

'AGT's Sofia Vergara criticizes the weak vocals in Menudo's Live Show

Despite their vocals not being "the best in the world," Howie and Sofia Vergara appreciated the energy they brought to the stage. According to Heidi Klum, they "brought the party to AGT," while Sofia described them as the perfect way to kick off the episode, though she also acknowledged their weak vocals.

'AGT' Season 19 judge Sofia Vergara pointed out the weak vocals in Menudo's Live performance (NBC)
'AGT' Season 19 judge Sofia Vergara pointed out the weak vocals in Menudo's Live performance (@nbc)

Menudo assures Simon Cowell about taking the 'AGT' judge's advice

Simon Cowell inquired about their thoughts on the performance. They maintained that they "did everything that you asked" in selecting the music. With that, he ended the conversation. Simon allowed the men to speak before sharing his view. He confirmed that they had chosen the song themselves and had followed his advice to stay true to their path.

'AGT' Season 19 judge Simon Cowell glad Menudo took his advice for Live performance (NBC)
'AGT' Season 19 judge Simon Cowell expressed his satisfaction that Menudo took his advice for their live performance (@nbc)

When was the new Menudo formed?

Menudo has been revived several times since the group's peak. Auditions were announced in 2004, and a reality show was planned for 2007. This is the first time this particular lineup has been introduced.

In Season 19, Episode 5, 'AGT' was introduced to the "new" Menudo, a project that, according to the members, started when their "boss bought the name Menudo" and initiated a global talent search. One of the project's architects is Mario Lopez, an actor and Access Hollywood anchor.

This time, the members are from the United States and are based in Miami, but they sing in Spanish (the original Menudo recorded songs in several languages). "Deciding on the final five was harder than we ever imagined because there was so much great talent to choose from," Mario stated when the new group was announced in March 2023.

"The five boys we selected gelled together instantly, and the music they’ve created have exceeded all of our expectations. I think we have several massive hits," he added. The current members of the band are Andés Emilio, Nicolas Calero, Alejandro Querales, Ezra Gilmore, and Gabriel Rossell.

Menudo 2.0 is a next gen carrying forward the legacy of the OG band (@menudo.com)
'AGT' band Menudo 2.0 is a next-gen carrying forward the legacy of the OG band (@menudo.com)

Watch 'AGT' Season 19 on Tuesdays and Wednesdays on NBC at 8 PM ET

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Explore ‘The Circle’ filming locations, the apartments behind the catfish and what has changed as Season 8 brings the U.S. reality competition to Hulu.
2026-11-11T19:25:16.000Z
Anthony Mackie’s recent comments about filming sparked curiosity among fans about Vision’s possible appearance.
2026-11-11T07:46:48.000Z
Despite breaking her nose, Jenna Johnson delivered a salsa performance with Harry Shum Jr. that earned them 29 out of 30 points
2026-11-11T05:49:43.000Z
'Dancing With the Stars' Season 35 enters its quarterfinals with seven couples still standing
2026-11-11T02:58:50.000Z
Cam’s dad appeared on the show when he met Aneha and later returned for the reunion
2026-11-10T10:27:23.000Z
Thanks to America’s votes, an artist from Team Kelly made it back to the competition
2026-11-10T07:45:37.000Z
After Harry Jowsey took over as the new Don, he had the power to eliminate two players
2026-11-10T06:21:24.000Z
After her engagement ended, Michaella reconnected with Matt away from the cameras
2026-11-10T05:03:40.000Z
After the Boston reunion, casting calls and restaurant sightings offer fresh clues about where Netflix’s ‘Love Is Blind’ could head for Season 12.
2026-11-09T18:29:01.000Z
The Boston cast reunited long after their weddings, with Sarah and John’s split and Benita’s new engagement among the revelations
2026-11-09T16:23:06.000Z