6 bizarre 'Emily in Paris' plot holes: From Madeline Wheeler’s infinite pregnancy to Camille's affair

Netflix's romantic comedy show 'Emily in Paris' offers a glimpse into the rich and vibrant outlook on French culture
PUBLISHED AUG 13, 2024
From Madeline Wheeler’s infinite pregnancy to Camille's convenient affair, let's discuss  6 weird plot holes in 'Emily in Paris' (@netflix)
From Madeline Wheeler’s infinite pregnancy to Camille's convenient affair, let's discuss 6 weird plot holes in 'Emily in Paris' (@netflix)

Contains spoilers and speculations for 'Emily in Paris' readers discretion advised

PARIS, FRANCE: While Emily Cooper's (Lily Collins) life in Paris seems fascinating, given her ability to mingle with locals and her impressive professional development in Netflix's 'Emily in Paris,' the question arises, is it really that laid-back in real life?

The show's portrayal of Emily's easygoing lifestyle is not entirely accurate, and there are several plot holes that makes zero to no sense from the very first episode. So, before the big debut of the first half of Season 4 of 'Emily in Paris', let's talk about six major flaws in the show that are too obvious to overlook.

1. Why Madeline Wheeler’s pregnancy felt infinite? 

Kate Walsh in a still from 'Emily in Paris' (Netflix/@stephaniebranchu)
Kate Walsh in a still from 'Emily in Paris' (@netflix/@stephaniebranchu)

One of the most noticeable plot holes in the show has to be Madeline Wheeler's (Kate Walsh) lengthy pregnancy, which have perplexed viewers.

In the pilot, Emily's boss, Madeline, realizes she is pregnant and chooses not to relocate to Paris, so Emily takes her place. Despite this choice, Madeline stays pregnant throughout Seasons 1 and 2 until giving birth in Season 3.

This temporal mismatch has sparked concern, since a large number of events, including romances, career changes, and even an engagement, all take place while she is still pregnant.

The show's chronology is curiously compacted, with a lot of action taking place in what appears to be a short timeframe.

2. Is Camille's affair too convenient?

Lily Collins and Camille Razat in 'Emily in Paris' (@netflix)
Lily Collins and Camille Razat in 'Emily in Paris' (@netflix)

Camille's (Camille Razat) convincing affair with Sofia Sideris (Melia Kreiling) is another often criticized subplot in the show.

While in a relationship with Gabriel, Camille begins an affair with artist Sofia, who is showing at the gallery where Camille works. Camille even accompanies Sofia to Greece for a vacation, while Gabriel thinks they are simply friends.

When Camille returns to Paris, she agrees to marry Gabriel (Lucas Bravo) but cancels the wedding because of his obvious desire to Emily. Surprisingly, Camille never discusses her involvement with Sofia at this time.

The show does not go into detail about Camille's intentions or the nuances of her relationship with Gabriel. Her affair is simply utilized as a story device to generate conflict and sexual tension, rather than providing a deeper narrative purpose.

3. How could Emily Cooper afford a perfect Parisian apartment?

Lily Collins in a still from 'Emily in Paris' (Netflix/@stéphaniebranchu)
Lily Collins in a still from 'Emily in Paris' (@netflix/@stéphaniebranchu)

Emily's ability to pay for a gorgeous Parisian apartment is one of the show's most perplexing aspects. Paris is famed for its high-end real estate, particularly in the lovely, central areas where Emily resides.

Emily's income as a young marketing professional is unlikely to be sufficient to afford the cost of such a huge and well-located flat, particularly given Paris's strong housing demand.

4. Where is Doug?

Roe Hartrampf as Doug in a still from 'Emily in Paris' (@netflix)
Roe Hartrampf as Doug in a still from 'Emily in Paris' (@netflix)

While fans enjoy Emily's love exploits in the Prais, the fate of her ex-boyfriend Doug (Roe Hartrampf) remains unknown.

Doug was introduced in Season 1 as Emily's Chicago-based lover who was initially supportive of Emily's decision to go to Paris, but their relationship swiftly unravels as Doug exhibits reluctance to make the long-distance relationship work.

He feels uneasy with the prospect of going to Paris and finally chooses to end his relationship with Emily over the phone. 

Doug's disappearance from the show comes off as too convenient, considering it was predicted that he would cause problems between Emily and Gabriel in the show's premiere season.

5. Is the love triangle overly convenient?

Lily Collins and Lucas Bravo in a still fom 'Emily in Paris' (@netflix)
Lily Collins and Lucas Bravo in a still fom 'Emily in Paris' (@netflix)

Without a doubt, one of the show's most annoying plotline is the never-ending love triangle.

Yes, we can give the show the benefit of the doubt since it is a romantic comedy, but it's been three seasons where it seems like the triangle saga is not going to end soon, and it's now more of a quadruplet.

Originally, the love triangle was between Emily, Gabriel, and Camille, but now the focus is on Emily, Gabriel, and Alfie (Lucien Laviscount), and this trope appears unduly convenient, particularly given how it continues to propel the story ahead.

The love triangle is now dragging, and its persistence, as well as the characters' decisions, sometimes appear more like expedient narrative devices than spontaneous advances, raising questions about its legitimacy.

6. How Emily Cooper is funding her fashionable wardrobe? 

Jean-Christophe Bouvet, Kate Walsh, and Lily Collins in a still from 'Emily in Paris' (Netflix/@stephaniebranchu)
Jean-Christophe Bouvet, Kate Walsh, and Lily Collins in a still from 'Emily in Paris' (@netflix/@stephaniebranchu)

Another major plot hole is how Emily, a young marketing professional, can afford her extravagant outfits.

Throughout the series, Emily is shown wearing high-end designer dresses that would generally be beyond the reach of someone in her position, particularly considering the expense of living in Paris.

The show fails to explain how Emily finances her stunning apparel collection. Her salary as a marketing specialist is unlikely to allow her to afford such extravagant preferences.

How to stream 'Emily in Paris' Season 4 Part 1? 

Lily Collins and Ashley Park in a still from 'Emily in Paris' (Netflix/@carolebethuel)
Lily Collins and Ashley Park in a still from 'Emily in Paris' (@netflix/@carolebethuel)

Netflix offers a variety of subscriptions based on your budget, so in order to view the show, you will need to have an exclusive membership.

The Standard Plan with advertising requires a monthly membership cost of $6.99 and allows for full HD (1080p) streaming.

You may use one account on two screens simultaneously while streaming in 1080p or full HD quality with the Standard Plan, which does not include adverts, for $15.49 per month.

The $22.99/month Premium Plan lets you enjoy 4K Ultra HD video with Dolby Atmos and HDR on up to four monitors simultaneously

'Emily in Paris' Season 4 Part 1 trailer



 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘Tell Me Lies’ Season 3 Episode 4 spirals as secrets spread, loyalties crack, and Stephen’s control slips while buried truths edge closer to exposure.
1 hour ago
'From' star Catalina Sandino Moreno hinted that season 4 could arrive soon this year, teasing new dangers and long-awaited answers ahead
3 hours ago
'Mayor of Kingstown's' future takes a turn as Sheridan’s Paramount exit leads to a trimmed final season and tense questions, which is far from ideal.
3 hours ago
The fifth season 3 episode of the drama series will feature a pool party where gossip starts swirling around Lucy
4 hours ago
Together with Genie Francis's Laura, Geary maintained his throne as one of the most popular daytime actors of all time
4 hours ago
Drew Cain's life hangs in the balance after Willow's shocking move, sparking exit rumors around Cameron Mathison and dividing 'General Hospital' fans
6 hours ago
Following Willow's dramatic acquittal, fans were left hanging when the episode failed to air on Tuesday
7 hours ago
The teaser features the 'Venom' actor as the star, the writer, and showrunner of the six-episode series
17 hours ago
The images, revealed by CBS, show new characters part of the show slated to release March 1
20 hours ago
The weeks ahead trailer of 'A Knight of Seven Kingdoms' promises high-octane action and drama
20 hours ago