This teen ‘American Idol’ runner-up might be eyeing ‘DWTS’ next — and we’re here for it

'DWTS' teases a major casting reveal — and fans think an 'American Idol' heartthrob could be next to hit the dance floor.
PUBLISHED MAY 21, 2025
(L-R) Daniella Karagach, Gleb Savchenko, Steven Nedoroscik, Kailyn Rogers, Ezra Sosa, and Britt Stewart perform during 'DWTS' Live 2025 in Phoenix, Arizona (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by John Medina)
(L-R) Daniella Karagach, Gleb Savchenko, Steven Nedoroscik, Kailyn Rogers, Ezra Sosa, and Britt Stewart perform during 'DWTS' Live 2025 in Phoenix, Arizona (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by John Medina)

Popular teen country artist John Foster wants to set the hearts racing once more after being declared runner-up on the 'American Idol' season 23. The Louisiana native is open to competing for the Mirror Ball trophy by entering the new season of 'Dancing With the Stars'. "I never really thought about that. I’ll tell you this – it’s certainly not a no," he revealed during an exclusive with TVInsider on being asked if he would try his luck on the ballroom stage. It might just happen that Foster may profit from his rising stardom and compete against well-known faces on the celebrity dance show. 


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by John Foster (@officialjohnfoster)


 

The 18-year-old celebrated his win with optimism: "Please be confident in who you are as an artist,” Foster advised the 'Idol' future contestants. “Never accept failure as a final defeat. Never accept defeat. Do not be discouraged. This is the beginning,” he wisely worded his message. Meanwhile, 'DWTS' has already been buzzing on social media after wildlife conservationist Robert Irwin was announced as one of its first participants. For the unversed, his elder sister Bindi competed and won the Mirror Ball trophy during season 21 in 2015. Meanwhile, Parade reports that on May 22, 'Good Morning America' will reveal the second cast member for season 34 of DWTS. Kristyn Burtt, DWTS reporter, shared this exciting news first on her TikTok


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Kristyn Burtt (@thekristynburtt)


 

"This is so smart, because remember we just had the Dancing with the Stars tour end in April? A few days later, they announced Robert Irwin as the very first cast member, and now, in May, we're getting a second cast member. I think this is a brilliant PR strategy. It is keeping Dancing with the Stars in the headlines, leading all the way up to the premiere. I would expect maybe a couple of other surprises in the coming months," Burtt shared excitedly. "I love that it's keeping us on our toes, but the smart thing is that they are making sure that Dancing with the Stars is a priority as a trending headline and on social media, so who do you think they'll announce?" she added. 



 

There have been fan theories about a 'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives' starcast joining in as the second contestant on the ABC dance reality show. A Reddit discussion thread has guessed that Taylor Frankie Paul might just be the ideal choice. "I'm predicting Taylor! She's easily the most popular of the Mormon Wives, and with over 5 million TikTok followers, she's extremely marketable!" the opening comment suggested. "I think it'll be someone that has something to tie into the ABC/Disney universe. I was trying to think if there was something coming up that the show might be able to capitalize on. Another idea I had that's unrelated to the network was maybe the Lautners," a fan countered. 


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Taylor Paul (@taylorfrankiepaul)


 

"Would love Taylor on the show, but not sure how that would work with custody," an online user chimed. "I’m not sure she would do it because of her kids. She probably wouldn’t be able to have them in LA due to her custody agreements, so I could see her not doing it because of that," a netizen voiced, keeping in mind Paul's custody battle with ex-husband Tate Paul. However, it will be exciting to see which one of the reality stars gets the coveted second place on the 'DWTS'. 

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL DANCING WITH THE STARS

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘Chicago Med’ is back after its midseason hiatus, and the latest Season 11 episode wastes no time diving into the hospital-wide blackout
5 hours ago
‘Chicago Fire’ returns from its winter break with a look at the apartment fire that was set
5 hours ago
Jamie Campbell Bower’s 'Tonight Show' appearance has fans convinced 'Stranger Things' isn’t over, despite claims there’s no Episode 9.
5 hours ago
Oliver Platt's Dr. Charles went through an emotional rollercoaster in the latest episode, leaving fans concerned about his future in the show
6 hours ago
In a heartbreaking twist, ‘9-1-1’ Season 8 bids farewell to Captain Bobby Nash, whose death in a lab explosion stunned fans and cast alike
6 hours ago
The wait is almost over as Netflix's ambitious sci-fi saga has finally locked in its return window, setting the stage for a much bigger chapter
7 hours ago
After closing the door on 'Stranger Things', Finn Wolfhard is gearing up for a major live TV moment that hints at his post-Hawkins future
8 hours ago
Netflix recently unveiled its lineup of anticipated shows and movies for 2026, and 'Wednesday' Season 3 is notably missing from the list
8 hours ago
Millie Bobby Brown also weighed in on Finn Wolfhard's character Mike Wheeler's theory about Eleven still being alive
20 hours ago
As Lucy and The Ghoul finally reach the New Vegas Strip, it appears to be a shadow of its former self
1 day ago