‘The Voice’ contestant felt Adam Levine ‘sold him out’ after controversial on-air moment: ‘We did our...’

"So, I have to fight for my girl," said Adam Levine before throwing his teammate under the bus on 'The Voice'
PUBLISHED JUN 14, 2025
(L) Adam Levine and (R) DeAndre Nico in screenshots from 'The Voice' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | The Voice Reupload)
(L) Adam Levine and (R) DeAndre Nico in screenshots from 'The Voice' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | The Voice Reupload)

Adam Levine is grabbing major headlines for his stellar comeback on 'The Voice' after his unexpected exit in 2019. While Levine failed to clinch the victory in the new season, his heartwarming mentorship won hearts. However, there is one instance that raised eyebrows and placed Levine's mentorship under the scanner. It all originated when Levine reportedly threw a teammate under the bus, who had to say goodbye to the show and was left mighty upset.

Adam Levine in a screenshot from 'The Voice' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | The Voice)
Adam Levine in a screenshot from 'The Voice' (Image Source: YouTube | The Voice)

During 'The Voice' Season 15, Levine stirred controversy in an incident fans dubbed 'Bathrobegate,' as per Life & Style. The drama unfolded when contestant Reagan Strange, just 14 at the time, was too sick to perform during the live elimination round and appeared in the audience wearing a bathrobe and full makeup. Meanwhile, DeAndre Nico, from the same team, sang John Legend’s 'All of Me,' and Dave Fenley of Team Blake performed Lonestar's 'Amazed.'



 

Despite Strange not singing, Levine chose to advocate for her during the voting segment, leading to Nico's elimination. This decision drew heavy criticism from viewers, who felt it was unfair to let a non-performing contestant advance while sending a performing artist home. As Strange sat safely in the crowd while Nico stood onstage, Levine said, "I have a very special relationship with Reagan, and I have two little girls at home, and the thought of breaking their heart by not urging everyone to give this girl a shot to go redeem herself next week would be far beneath me."



 

Levine continued, "So, I have to fight for my girl, and I have to make sure that I represent her properly in this moment because she didn't have a chance to use her voice tonight." Ultimately, Nico received the fewest votes and was eliminated. After his elimination, Nico expressed deep disappointment with Levine’s decision to favor Strange, as he said in a post-show interview, "It was just weird. I'm not being rude. I just felt like he sold me out and I just don’t respect it. I'm just being honest."



 

He went on to clarify that he understood what it meant to perform under pressure, stating, "We did our job, sick or not. I just got over laryngitis. When I came back, I still sang. It wasn’t any of that anxiety or any of that stuff." Voicing his frustration with Levine's lack of public support, he added, "I know that [Reagan's] a little kid, but it's like, 'Man, [Adam,] you could have put some words in for me at all, like something!'" 



 

Levine addressed the controversy surrounding his decision to save Strange over Nico during the following week's rehearsal on 'The Voice.' Levine said to Strange, "It was a strange week, but it's over now." Trying to smooth over the backlash, he shared that there was no bad blood, adding, "DeAndre’s my boy. I love him. We talked." Reportedly, Levine, Strange, and Nico eventually reconciled and even FaceTimed during the episode.



 

Talking about Levine's future on 'The Voice,' according to an insider who spoke with The US Sun, Levine felt a noticeable "void" while filming 'The Voice' without longtime co-star Blake Shelton. The source revealed, "Adam didn’t realize how much his experience was made by having Blake on set with him until this season when he had to film without him. They added, "He didn’t enjoy this season as much as he anticipated, but he definitely feels Blake’s void and misses him. That's not to say he doesn’t like the other coaches this season, he does. But he didn’t have as much fun as he did in the past with his buddy Blake."

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The finale features Liv Ciara, Mikenley Brown, Lucas West, and Alexia Jayy competing to win the show
50 minutes ago
The Top 9 finalists of 'American Idol' Season 24 are set for a fierce battle ahead as they fight for a spot in the semi-finale round.
12 hours ago
Liv Ciara, Lucas West, Alexia Jayy, and Mikenley Brown will square off in 'The Voice' finale after their impeccable semifinal runs.
14 hours ago
'The Voice' Season 29 introduces a major voting twist, leaving viewers at home unable to participate in deciding the winner.
16 hours ago
‘American Idol’ Season 23 winner Jamal Roberts made an appearance on the show's official podcast and revealed a recent purchase.
17 hours ago
Bravo star Mike Durrant got himself in trouble after he accidentally spilled a secret about the charter guest’s plans
19 hours ago
The latest episode of ‘The Voice’ Season 29 spanned two hours and ended with five favorites being eliminated
20 hours ago
Five singers exit ‘The Voice’ after a high-stakes semi-final, as a new voting twist leaves four finalists battling for the Season 29 crown
1 day ago
Two singers exit ‘American Idol’ Season 24 after a tense night as fan votes shake up the competition
1 day ago
Dolly documented her struggles with food addiction and revealed her deteriorating mental health in a 2022 episode of 'My 600-Lb Life.'
1 day ago