'Masked Singer' fans call her the 'worst' winner — and even she didn’t believe she’d win the show

"I personally believe it should have been MSM 4th, Pearl 3rd, Coral 2nd, and Boogie Woogie 1st," a fan complained.
PUBLISHED MAY 24, 2025
General view during the 5th show of the 5th season of "The Masked Singer" at MMC Studios on November 13, 2021 in Cologne, Germany. (Cover image source: Photo by Andreas Rentz | Getty Images)
General view during the 5th show of the 5th season of "The Masked Singer" at MMC Studios on November 13, 2021 in Cologne, Germany. (Cover image source: Photo by Andreas Rentz | Getty Images)

Grammy winner Gretchen Wilson resurrected her fading music career by winning the Golden Mask trophy on 'The Masked Singer' season 13. She defeated record producer Andy Grammer - 'Boogie Woogie', actress Meg Donnelly - 'Coral', and country musician Brian Kelley - 'Mad Scientist Monster'. However, the 'Redneck Woman' hitmaker was ready lose. “I was absolutely positive that Boogie won,” Wilson confessed to People in an exclusive. "I was so stunned because I had myself ready to hear that I was in second place. I was so ready for it, I had already decided that that's what it should be in my head.” And that is exactly how fans have been reacting to her unexpected win, a Reddit thread labeled her "one of the worst winners of the series." "This is not me hating on Gretchen winning, I just have mixed opinions on it. I personally believe it should have been MSM 4th, Pearl 3rd, Coral 2nd, and Boogie Woogie 1st. I don’t know about y'all though," a Reddit user opined



 

"Boogie should have won. Period," an X user expressed frustration over the results. "She should never have made the final to begin with. One of the worst winners of the series," a viewer slammed. "Terrible. Boogie should’ve won, this show loves boring singers way too much!" an online user chimed. "I think Pearl was the weakest winner since that one season that the girl threw a temper tantrum and should have been eliminated. People rewarded her for advancing her, and she won. Me and my daughter thought Boogie Woogie had this one locked up once it got to the finals," a netizen pointed out

Andy Grammer performs at CMA Theater at the Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum on June 13, 2022 in Nashville. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Terry Wyatt)
Andy Grammer performs at CMA Theater at the Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum on June 13, 2022 in Nashville. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Terry Wyatt)


 



 



 

"No way she was better than Andy. The audience must've heard something else because Andy's vocals are absolutely marvelous," another X user complained. "Sorry, but I feel this is wrong. Boggie didn’t have a slow night at all and consistently knocked it out of the park. Pearl didn't deserve the win. #riggedMaskSinger," a viewer protested that the Fox show results were manipulated. In an exclusive with Gold Derby, Grammer voiced dissatisfaction about finishing second. "I'm very competitive, so I can't say I didn't care," he said. However, he confessed to enjoying the experience. "But there is something about being in a huge mascot monster costume that just brings the vibe to a chill place. This is so fun and ridiculous. Whatever it is, it's so fun to be here," the 'Honey, I'm Good' hitmaker added. 



 

Grammer revealed that he wasn't aware of being up against Wilson throughout the show, "No. I couldn't even really hear. The side stage is not a great place to watch, and you're back behind the stage. So through muffled tones you hear the crowd screaming or you can tell what song they're singing, but you can't hear much more than that," he replied. And while fans continue to air their dispondecy, 'The Masked Singer' happens to go on a mini break before returning for the next season. The Fox reality show has promised to come back in a refreshed avatar for season 14 next year. 

RELATED TOPICS THE MASKED SINGER

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Ben Kingsley opens up on his acting journey and reflects on gratitude while promoting ‘Wonder Man’ on GMA.
6 hours ago
'Industry' Season 4, Episode 2, starring Kit Harrington and Marisa Abela, featured some wild and ruthless moments as it veers entirely off the rails
8 hours ago
Several binge-worthy shows are releasing this January—our list of unmissable shows, including the 'GoT' prequel and a delectable crime caper.
12 hours ago
From Ashford’s tourney grounds to whispered legends, 'A Knight of Seven Kingdoms' Episode 1 showed us plenty of 'Game of Thrones' Easter eggs.
12 hours ago
Everything you need to know about ‘nursing home OG’ Judy Ann Prachyl as ‘Landman’ Season 2 comes to an end
14 hours ago
Created by Stan Lee, Jack Kirby, and Don Heck, the eight-episode series is scheduled to premiere on Tuesday, January 27
15 hours ago
'A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms,' adapted from 'Tales of Dunk and Egg,' takes place between the events of 'House of the Dragon' and 'Game of Thrones.'
16 hours ago
Taylor Sheridan is leaving Paramount and joining NBCUniversal, starting an eight-year movie deal in March 2026
18 hours ago
After the season 2 finale, season 3 looms as 'Landman' locks in its return and familiar faces line up for another round of power shifts
19 hours ago
Finn Wolfhard's latest hosting gig on 'SNL' also featured his 'Stranger Things' co-stars Caleb McLaughlin and Gaten Matarazzo
19 hours ago