Who was Dorothea Puente? Chilling true story behind a serial killer grandma coming to theaters this Halloween

She looked like everyone’s grandmother but behind Dorothea Puente’s smile lay a backyard full of bodies.
UPDATED OCT 9, 2025
Screenshot of Susan Priver as Dorothea Puente from 'Dorothea' trailer (Cover Image Source: YouTube | Dread)
Screenshot of Susan Priver as Dorothea Puente from 'Dorothea' trailer (Cover Image Source: YouTube | Dread)

This Halloween, horror gets disturbingly real as Dread Films unleashes ‘Dorothea.’ It’s a chilling true-crime thriller about a grandmother whose deadly secret was buried right in her backyard. Epic Pictures’ horror division, Dread, has announced that ‘Dorothea’ will hit theaters on October 31, perfectly timed for the spookiest night of the year. The film will then arrive on VOD starting November 4, continuing Dread’s growing slate of horror projects inspired by true crimes that shocked the world. Written and directed by Chad Ferrin, ‘Dorothea’ stars Susan Priver (‘Night Caller’) in the unsettling lead role of Dorothea Puente, as per The Hollywood Reporter.

She plays a seemingly kind-hearted boarding house owner who hid a monstrous double life. The film also features Lew Temple (‘The Walking Dead’), Brinke Stevens (‘House on Haunted Hill’), Ginger Lynn (‘The Devil’s Rejects’), Brenda James (‘Slither’), Cassandra Gava (‘Conan the Barbarian’), Cyril O’Reilly (‘Porky’s’), Ezra Buzzington (‘The Artist’), and Robert Miano (‘Fast & Furious’). But behind its eerie trailer and haunting visuals lies a shocking true story. In the 1980s, Dorothea Puente appeared to be a caring grandmother who ran a quiet Sacramento boarding house for the elderly and disabled. In reality, she was a cold-blooded serial k*ller.

Puente preyed on her vulnerable tenants by drugging them, stealing their Social Security checks, and burying their bodies in her garden, as reported by LA Times. Her crimes went unnoticed for years, until authorities uncovered the gruesome remains of multiple victims hidden beneath her property, earning her the nickname ‘The Death House Landlady.’ Director Chad Ferrin, known for his gritty and psychological approach to horror, brings Puente’s shocking story to life with unnerving realism. The film marks the second installment in Dread’s growing true crime horror collection, following the studio’s earlier success with ‘Ed Kemper.’

Up next in the lineup: a film centered on Richard Ramirez, the notorious ‘Night Stalker,’ also helmed by Ferrin. Dread CEO and executive producer Patrick Ewald described ‘Dorothea’ as an unflinching look at the darkness behind ordinary faces. “‘Dorothea’ is the second in our series of unflinching true crime films that explore the darkest corners of human nature,” Ewald said. “Director Chad Ferrin masterfully transports audiences to the era in which these horrifying events took place, capturing both the atmosphere and psychology of the time with a truly singular vision.”

Ewald also teased what’s next for the series, “Our next film with Chad, centered on Richard Ramirez, the ‘Night Stalker,’ will push this series even further, diving deeper into the terror and truth behind one of history’s most infamous killers.” By blending biographical detail with bone-chilling tension, ‘Dorothea’ is going to offer something far more disturbing than supernatural scares, a reminder that real monsters often live among us.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The movie is now called 'Guarding Stars' to avoid confusion with Kevin Costner's 1992 romantic thriller
8 hours ago
'Ares' rough BO run will also likely quash all hopes of another 'Tron' film on the big screen
10 hours ago
Maya Hawke gushes over Jennifer Lawrence’s influence while hinting at her return as Katniss Everdeen in the upcoming ‘Hunger Games’ prequel
10 hours ago
‘Godzilla Minus Zero’ charges into theaters in 2026 as the Oscar-winning creative team reunites for a powerful new chapter.
19 hours ago
Kristen Stewart, who starred as Bella Swan in the 'Twilight' movie series, said she's open to re-adapting the 2008 film
1 day ago
Directed by Michael Gracey and written by Jennifer Kaytin Robinson, the studio confirmed Teagan Croft and Milo Manheim’s casting on January 7
1 day ago
Mark your calendars as Neon is set to release Cannes-winning Spanish film 'Sirat' on Feb. 6, featuring a story of a father-son duo in an endless rave
1 day ago
Jay and Silent Bob are two prominent characters from the fictional "View Askewniverse" created by Kevin Smith
1 day ago
Wait for 'The Batman Part II' has been gruelling, but it may prove to be worth it as one of DC's most iconic villains will appear in the film
2 days ago