Australian singer reveals true self in an emotional ‘American Idol’ audition and honestly it struck a chord

Sheldon Riley performed Matt Corby's 'Brother' on 'American Idol,' and revealed his true identity after hiding behind a mask for years.
PUBLISHED FEB 3, 2026
(L) Screesnhots of Carrie Uncerwood and (R) Sheldon Riley from'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | @americanidol)
(L) Screesnhots of Carrie Uncerwood and (R) Sheldon Riley from'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | @americanidol)

Fans were not prepared for the surprise when a successful Australian masked singer contestant revealed his true identity during 'American Idol' Season 24 auditions. The 26-year-old singer shared that being rejected from an Australian competition sent him into a period of self-doubt. However, he impressed judges Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood, and Luke Bryan with a powerful performance of Matt Corby's 'Brother,' and earned himself a golden ticket.

(L-R) Photo of Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood, Luke Bryan, and host Ryan Seacrest from 'American Idol' (Cover image source: Instagram | @AmericanIdol)
(L-R) Photo of Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood, Luke Bryan, and host Ryan Seacrest from 'American Idol' (Image source: Instagram | @americanidol)

The contestant in discussion is Sheldon Riley, who explained how he created an over-the-top masked persona. "It was the thing that made people see (me)," which led to global success and countless competition appearances. But, it came at an emotional cost: "I'd come home, take the mask off… and I would hate the person I saw in the mirror," he said as per American Songwriter. Realising the toll of his masked persona, Riley took two years off music to reconnect with his passion, later auditioning for 'American Idol' to "remind myself that my voice is enough."

Bryan was full of praise for Riley after his performance, "You're crazy talented, crazy unbelievable… I don't know why you ever had to wear the mask, because you're an amazing-looking person… It's OK to just peel a layer off. But that was impressive." Richie added, "You're an artist, man. You're authentic… You have stage presence. It's all there. Accept you. Embrace you." Underwood concluded, "I'm really glad you're here. I love your voice." All three judges then awarded Riley a Golden Ticket.

Talking about his moment on 'American Idol', Riley said, "I've been judged by a lot of people, very important people, but I feel like it was the first time it really meant something, because I went out there not playing a character. It was me. They liked me." Season 24 of the show is introducing major changes. First, the iconic Hollywood Week will move to Nashville for 'Hollywood Week: Music City Takeover,' featuring a single, high-stakes round with the biggest cut in Idol history. 

Second, Executive Producer Megan Michaels Wolflick told Deadline she's adding social media voting, explaining, “We have to meet the audience where they are… We want to make it as easy as possible for people to vote for their favorites, weigh in from their couch with their second screen, in real time… If we can get Gen Alpha and Gen Z to weigh in a little bit more in the easiest way possible, that's very exciting. It could tip the scale. Trends are always different," as per Parade. Additionally, 'American Idol' is also adding a new Ohana Round, filmed at Aulani, a Disney Resort & Spa in Ko Olina. Notably, it is a special stage where contestants receive peer feedback, emotional support, and professional guidance before moving on to America's Vote.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The previous seasons had the judges determining the ultimate fate of the contestants, but 'American Idol' Season 24 seeks to change that.
13 hours ago
'The Masked Singer' season 14 began with eighteen contestants, out of which only seven remain in the competition now.
15 hours ago
Windey was seen in Season 26 of 'The Bachelor' and returned to lead Season 19 of 'The Bachelorette' with Rachel Recchia
17 hours ago
Two former contestants return to ‘American Idol’, lighting up the stage again as they showcase how far they’ve come
21 hours ago
The Battle Rounds kicked off with Team Kelly’s youngest contestants, and their performance added a twist to the show
1 day ago
The Top 20 performances are being stretched across two nights, with the first batch of 10 taking the stage during the March 16 episode
1 day ago
The clues for High Voltage's true identity left the panelists guessing till the last moment, with some betting he was either Travis Kelce or Jason Sudeikis.
1 day ago
‘Love Island USA’ scores massive streaming numbers, and now Season 8 is on the way, along with a new docuseries about life after the villa.
3 days ago
As 'America’s Got Talent' celebrates its 20-year run, NBC has revealed the Season 21 premiere date, returning judges, and more
4 days ago
'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives' stars Jessi and Jordan have been through numerous lows in their relationship, to the point of seeking couples therapy.
5 days ago