Who is Cat Witch? ‘The Masked Singer’ 14 panel finally learns identity of ‘America’s Insider’

Viewers knew Cat Witch’s identity from the premiere, making the final reveal one of the season’s most unusual twists
UPDATED APR 2, 2026
A still of Cat Witch from 'The Masked Singer' Season 14 (Cover Image Source: Instagram | @maskedsingerfox)
A still of Cat Witch from 'The Masked Singer' Season 14 (Cover Image Source: Instagram | @maskedsingerfox)

There was something a little different about Cat Witch from the very beginning of ‘The Masked Singer’ Season 14. That’s because the audience knew who was under the mask from the premiere episode itself, but the panel didn’t. Behind the Cat Witch mask was Kylie Cantrall, best known to younger audiences for her role in Disney’s 'Descendants' universe. Her participation wasn’t exactly kept a secret. While this could be considered a spoiler, it was all part of the plan. She wasn’t just another contestant trying to dodge guesses from the panel, as she had an extra role to play as ‘America’s Insider’.

Screenshot of Cat Witch character alongside  Jenny McCarthy taken from 'The Masked Singer' Season 14 performance video (Cover Image Source: YouTube | @MaskedSingerFOX)
Screenshot of Cat Witch alongside Jenny McCarthy from 'The Masked Singer' Season 14 (Image Source: YouTube | @MaskedSingerFOX)

This basically meant she had one foot inside the competition and the other outside, sharing glimpses of the process while still competing in a disguise. In a social media clip ahead of the premiere, she teased her role. “For literally the first time ever, I’m gonna be bringing you guys in on the entire process as I bring you behind-the-scenes,” she revealed. “I’ll be working for you and sharing my strategy to throw off Nick [Cannon], Robin [Thicke], Jenny [McCarthy], Ken [Jeong], and my on-screen mom Rita [Ora]. They have no idea this is happening. It’s the biggest secret ever!” 

What made her role even more ironic was her connection to Rita Ora, who sits on the judging panel and also stars in the ‘Descendants’ franchise. In it, Ora plays the Queen of Hearts, the mother of Cantrall’s character Red. So there they were, technically part of the same fictional family in one universe, but on this stage, Ora had no idea she was critiquing someone she already knew. Fast forward to the finale, and Cat Witch had two big moments to make a final impression. She stepped onto the stage first with a performance of ‘Leave (Get Out)’ by JoJo, and then returned later with ‘Greedy’ by Tate McRae.

A screengrab of Kylie Cantrall as Cat Witch and host Nick Cannon (Image Source: YouTube | @MaskedSingerFOX)
A screengrab of Kylie Cantrall as Cat Witch and host Nick Cannon (Image Source: YouTube | @MaskedSingerFOX)

The finale saw her compete alongside Galaxy Girl, Pugcasso, and Crane, as they all chased that Golden Mask trophy. Crane was the first to be eliminated in the final round and revealed as Normani. Then, Cat Witch was finally unmasked to the judges as Cantrall. Pugcasso and Galaxy Girl moved on as the final two. After one last round of performances, Pugcasso was unmasked as Phillip Phillips, leaving Galaxy Girl to take the win. Under that final mask was Ashlee Simpson, who was officially crowned the Season 14 champion.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

A ‘Summer House’ Bravo discussion board on Reddit featured comments from many fans speculating whether Mia and Scott had broken up.
13 minutes ago
While on FaceTime with Ciara Miller, Amanda Batula spoke about the real reason behind her absence.
2 hours ago
The latest episode of the Bravo show featured West and Ciara having several one-on-one conversations
6 hours ago
Paige DeSorbo announced her departure from ‘Summer House’ in June 2025 after the Season 9 reunion aired
7 hours ago
Hulu eyes ‘Mormon Wives’ return after abrupt pause, but Taylor Frankie Paul’s uncertain status keeps Season 5 plans up in the air.
8 hours ago
West had a private conversation with Ciara in the latest episode of 'Summer House' and apologized for his actions
9 hours ago
Eddy and Jenna’s date in the latest ‘Below Deck Down Under’ episode takes a turn as Jenna uncovers a major “non-negotiable.”
23 hours ago
‘Below Deck Down Under’ Season 4 episode 12 saw Daisy inform the Captain about an urgent situation involving 2 crew members.
1 day ago
Carrie Underwood replaced Katy Perry after her exit in Season 22, and now the fans have made their voices heard on social media about her replacement.
1 day ago
The next episode of 'Summer House' will showcase Kyle coming to terms with his marital issues with Amanda and KJ realizing how special Dara is to him.
1 day ago