Teen ‘American Idol’ singer makes it to top 8 — and Carrie Underwood’s advice definitely played a part

"You're on your way to something, you just have to get more confidence, more stage presence," Richie advised.
PUBLISHED MAY 5, 2025
Contestant Mattie Pruitt and Carrie Underwood 'American Idol' 2025. (Cover Image Source: YouTube| American Idol)
Contestant Mattie Pruitt and Carrie Underwood 'American Idol' 2025. (Cover Image Source: YouTube| American Idol)

Sixteen-year-old Mattie Pruitt has made it to the top 8 of 'American Idol Season 23'; with her signature raspy voice, the Tennessee native has come a long way from her soulful rendition of Jessie Murph's 'How Could You' during the auditions. Despite her meteoric rise in the competition, judge Carrie Underwood advised the younger singer, "If there's anything I can say to you, it's that you have to find your sass. You have to find that sass ... You need some sass, girl; come on."



 

Fellow judges Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie also agreed that Pruitt needs to step out of her comfort zone and overcome her shy persona to match her stunning voice, as per The Things. "You're on your way to something; you just have to get more confidence and more stage presence. Your delivery was wonderful," Richie advised. "You have a maturity in your voice that is a bit beyond your years, but it's really cool. You have a really nice range," Underwood had gushed at the teenager's voice during auditions. Meanwhile, James Taylor, a six-time Grammy Award winner and' Rock & Roll Hall of Fame' inductee, mentored Pruitt while she chose to sing Janis Joplin's 'Piece of My Heart.'

Carrie Underwood at the People's Choice Awards at Barker Hangar on December 06, 2022, in Santa Monica, California. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Axelle)
Carrie Underwood at the People's Choice Awards at Barker Hangar on December 06, 2022, in Santa Monica, California. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Axelle)

Although Taylor was impressed by the teen's Top 12 song selection, he made her study the lyrics to understand the mature song. "To me, it was a bit of a surprise because Mattie's our youngest artist, and this is a song that you would think of as being sung by a woman, not a girl." Pruitt took note of the judges' advice and gave a stunning rendition of Kelly Clarkson's ballad 'Because of You' during the 'Iconic Idol Moments' night after being mentored by season 3 winner Fantasia Barrino. The Tennessee native turned the tide with her strong stage presence that night. She owned every minute of her presence with matching facial expressions and natural acting. 



 

Bryan fawned over her performance: "I mean, at 16 out here going toe-to-toe with everybody, you need to make sure you understand how amazing it is... You're doing so good; you just keep growing. Great job." Richie chimed in, "You just stood there with confidence, and you did it well." Pruitt jumped to the top 10 spot, and Underwood couldn't keep calm. "Mattie, your voice is just so stinking good; it is so cool and unique. Every single time we see you, I feel like you get more and more connected with the words that you're singing, the songs that you're singing. Just keep doing that, keep leaning into it," the country music queen gushed over the teen. 



 

Pruitt broke out of her shell and gave an electrifying rendition of Miranda Lambert's 'The House That Built Me' during the 'Ladies Night' round and secured herself a spot among the top 8 idols for season 23. According to Entertainment Now, Pruitt celebrated a milestone moment on the sets of the iconic talent show; she was greeted by a surprise sweet sixteen birthday arrangement on April 15th. 


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Mattie Pruitt (@mattiepruittofficial)


 

The excited teen shared the special moment on her Instagram with a lengthy caption: “I walked into the dressing room thinking no one was going to do anything for my birthday,” she wrote, “and then some of the contestants and my stepmom surprised me with the sweetest birthday setup ever.” "Still can’t believe I’m 16 and living this dream — thank you for all the love, support, and votes after last night’s performance. My heart is so full," she concluded. 

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL (2002)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'Stranger Things' Season 5 Volume 2 will premiere on Netflix on Thursday, December 25
7 hours ago
Set to premiere in 2027, the show is officially a full reboot of J.K. Rowling's beloved novels
7 hours ago
The zombie apocalypse series centers on a group of students who find themselves trapped inside their school, fighting to survive the deadly outbreak
9 hours ago
While 'Bridgerton' Season 4 is set to premiere on Thursday, January 29, 2026, fans can watch the first episode on Wednesday, January 14
9 hours ago
‘Stranger Things’ Season 5 drops it's penultimate set of episodes on Netflix on Christmas Day
16 hours ago
Rhea Seehorn explains what Carol’s choice means and how it changes the story moving forward to Season 2
22 hours ago
Netflix has secured a new MGM deal to stream all 10 seasons of 'Stargate SG-1', bringing the iconic sci-fi series back into orbit
1 day ago
In the pilot episode of 'Pluribus', astronomers detect a mysterious radio signal originating roughly 600 light-years away
1 day ago
Morgan's instincts push her closer to the truth as the Rembrandt theft and Roman's disappearance collide when 'High Potential' returns
1 day ago
Apple TV+’s ‘Pluribus’ could follow ‘Severance’ with a long, painful gap between seasons
1 day ago