‘The Great American Baking Show’ Season 5 Episode 4: Fans rejoice as Brother Andrew wins the finale

With their artistic baking skills, creative recipes, and personal touch to classic confections, all the amateur bakers saw their share of ups and downs
Brother Andrew (ABC)
Brother Andrew (ABC)

The greatest and grandest baking show of the season finally comes to an end with three amateur bakers making it to the finals. After four weeks of grueling challenges and several fine goodies later, contestants Brother Andrew from Washington DC, Dana Commandatore from LA, and Marissa Troeschel from Portland, survived through the final rounds.

With their artistic baking skills, creative recipes, and personal touch to classic confections, each of these amateur bakers saw their share of ups and downs. If Brother Andrew became the star baker in the second week, he was replaced by Dana in the third. He had even reached a point where the fans feared that he might be cut off from the show in the third week, despite all his attempts to keep himself in the competition. The competition among the three was close and they were neck to neck with their performances.

However, in the final round, the judging parameters had gone up and there was more to their dishes than just ingenuity. Judges and master chefs Sherri Yard and Paul Hollywood went beyond the recipes per se and focused on the technicality, understanding baking secrets and implementing them, and most importantly, assess bakers on how far they could think outside the box, even with traditional recipes.

Weighing all past performances and the final round of each contestant’s original recipe, the judges found Brother Andrew to be the best of the final three. He had evolved over the weeks, learning from his mistakes and pushing his limits every time. 

As @miggycash Tweets, “Brother Andrew! So happy he took it home, so well deserved 🙏🏽@GABakingShow  #americanbakingshow #capuchinfriars”

So does @IInspired, “Replying to @GABakingShow, “Yes, Congrats Brother Andrew, well deserved!! #AmericanBakingShow 👏” @melgotserved agrees saying, “I’m very pleased with the winner of the #AmericanBakingShow!!”

But fans also loved the other contestants and how they fared throughout the season. As @NotYerAvgChick comments, “Congrats to all the bakers this season! You all blew the audience away with your creations! #AmericanBakingShow @GABakingShow”

@MultiversalDork admires each of the finalists, the winner, as well as the show. He says, “Congratulations to Brother Andrew on that hard-earned victory! And congratulations to Dana, Marissa and everybody in that tent, bakers, judges, hosts and crew, for a wonderful competition. What a great season and a marvelous way to start this new year. #AmericanBakingShow.”

And we couldn’t agree more. For one month, we cherished the gastronomic joyride with 10 amateur but brilliant bakers and some of the most delectable baked recipes that were visually delightful, making this holiday season a truly special one.

‘The Great American Baking Show’ will be back next year, around the same time, with a brand new season full of food, fun, and competition.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Charles’ British rival makes a poor first impression as the ‘Only Murders in the Building’ Season 6 trailer previews the trio’s London case.
2026-11-17T17:50:47.000Z
An alien offer of peace clashes with Thomas Wade’s warning in the first ‘3 Body Problem’ Season 2 teaser ahead of its Netflix return.
2026-11-17T16:27:21.000Z
‘Line of Fire’ Episode 8 takes Nia’s investigation in a new direction as another killing pushes her to seek Jane’s help.
2026-11-17T14:03:00.000Z
Sonny has a breakthrough in the latest episode when he discovers Tracey, Ellen's long-lost sister
2026-11-17T09:01:57.000Z
Jubal helps Nikki hunt for a former asset who vanished with his family from a quiet suburban street
2026-11-17T08:05:38.000Z
Amaury Nolasco takes over the role previously played by Juan Francisco Villa, with his character set to bring major complications to Baez's family
2026-11-17T07:09:32.000Z
Scola and Nina face a major relationship crossroads on 'FBI' as John Boyd addresses his future on the show
2026-11-17T06:36:49.000Z
Steve Carell, John Krasinski and 14 other ‘The Office’ stars will reunite for NBC’s three-hour anniversary broadcast, alongside Tina Fey and other familiar faces.
2026-11-17T05:33:47.000Z
Several actors, including Benedict Wong, will reprise their roles in ‘3 Body Problem’ Season 2
2026-11-17T05:01:11.000Z
A shortened 13-episode order puts the Max Thieriot drama on a very different calendar than last season
2026-11-17T04:14:04.000Z