‘The Great American Baking Show’ Season 5 Episode 2: Fans feel Brother Andrew might be next on the block to get eliminated

As the holiday edition of the popular baking show opened for a new season, contestant Brother Andrew tops the list of all 10 participants. But the second week turns out to be tough for the talented baker.
Brother Andrew Corriente from Washington DC contests in ABC's 'The Great American Baking Show' Season 5. (ABC)
Brother Andrew Corriente from Washington DC contests in ABC's 'The Great American Baking Show' Season 5. (ABC)

‘The Great American Baking Show’ Season 5 is all about recreating timeless and classic holiday baked recipes. Week 2 saw contestants competing on dessert recipes made with traditional spices. Each of the 10 bakers brought to the table their best versions of confections like cinnamon rolls, puddings, gingerbread house, madeleines and more.

Brother Andrew, from Washington DC, has been one of the top contestants since the first week. He was the star of the show in the bread challenge when he made beautiful, artisan bread. After that, we were hopeful that his winning streak will continue through the next week. But unfortunately, his luck didn’t favor him in the second week.

The challenge of the week was to make Christmas special confections with spices. Although he had enough practice with his friar, he couldn’t manage to please the judges. His lime and Vietnamese cinnamon rolls might have been very creative but they turned out hard. Even the ones that followed were not that impressive either. But the showstopper round was the one that made it really difficult for Brother Andrew, when he had a disaster with his cheesecake.

According to @NotYerAvgChick, “Brother Andrew Accidentally Knocked Over His Cheesecake! #AmericanBakingShow, @GABakingShow.” She also tries to cheer him up with her tweet, saying, “Stay calm Brother Andrew!#AmericanBakingShow @GABakingShow.”

Another fan, @schoolover13, who realized in the second round itself, where Andrew was slipping up, commented, “Oops brother Andrew should do toasted nuts  #AmericanBakingShow”

And after the cheesecake fail, he commented, “I guess that Brother Andrew will go home.  #AmericanBakingShow”

As of now, we don’t think Brother Andrew is at any risk. But looking at the way the competition is going, we can only expect the baking challenges to get tougher with every passing week. As we get deeper into the show, the competition will get tighter. So, whether Andrew will be able to present his best talent and live up to his week one’s standards is something next week will prove.

Watch the holiday special edition of ‘The Great American Baking Show’ Season 5, every Thursday at 9 pm/8c, only on ABC.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The 'Gabby's Dollhouse' Season 14 trailer introduces a new character first teased in the 2025 film adaptation
2 hours ago
‘Tulsa King’ Season 4 gets a major creative update as the writer behind its acclaimed first season returns ahead of the show’s next chapter.
3 hours ago
Sheepstealer’s fate in Episode 7 of ‘House of the Dragon’ Season 3 leaves fans with big questions. Here’s what ‘Fire and Blood’ suggests.
4 hours ago
Previous episodes revealed that both Aegon and Sunfyre were burnt during the Battle at Rook's Rest
5 hours ago
After a dangerous Ukraine mission, Joe was attacked by two men at her home, which resulted in an unexpected situation.
8 hours ago
Alicent comes to Harrenhal with the intention of fulfilling Rhaenyra's wishes and reunites with her son Aemond as well as Alys
8 hours ago
DC's 'Booster Gold' series has made headlines again after years of development. Here's what the latest update means for the project.
1 day ago
'Tulsa King' spin-off has reached a major production milestone, bringing Samuel L. Jackson's new crime drama closer to release.
1 day ago
Netflix and BBC bring out a miniseries based on the real Lockerbie tragedy that took away the lives of 189 Americans
1 day ago
'Cape Fear' ends with shocking revelations, emotional choices, and a final decision that changes Max and the Bowden family forever.
1 day ago