Who did Corey Sobczyk hook up with? 'Temptation Island' star Erin Smith wants to 'walk away' from relationship

Erin and Corey left the island feeling sure that things would work out between them, but unfortunately, things seem to have taken a turn for the worse during the reunion


                            Who did Corey Sobczyk hook up with? 'Temptation Island' star Erin Smith wants to 'walk away' from relationship
Corey Sobczyk and Erin Smith's relationship was tested during 'Temptation Island' reunion (USA Network)

Corey Sobczyk and Erin Smith got their fairytale ending towards the end of their long stint on 'Temptation Island'. The young couple came on the island as Corey felt like he was being 'undervalued' in their relationship, and wanted to prove to his girlfriend that he was the man for her. 

During their journey on the island, Corey built a strong connection with a single named Amanda Spain-Butts. Amanda was completely different compared to Erin. While he felt like he had to compete for Erin's attention, with Amanda he could just be himself and realized that he could open up to her and be vulnerable with her. Although Amanda and Corey had a very strong connection and all the fans were rooting for them to leave the island together, he made the shocking decision to leave with his girlfriend instead. The couple left the island feeling sure that things would work out between them. But unfortunately, things seem to have taken a turn for the worse during the show's reunion when Shaq Urie revealed that Amanda had confided in him about hooking up with Corey.

RELATED ARTICLES

'Corey Sobczyk who?' Amanda Spain-Butts posts sizzling bikini pics after he rejects her on 'Temptation Island'

Erin Smith and Corey Sobczyk's Relationship Timeline: 'Temptation Island' Season 3 couple sparks breakup rumors

Amanda Spain-Butts clarified that she never hooked up with Corey Sobczyk during their overnight date (Temptation Island/ USA Network)

Did Corey Sobezcyk hook up with Amanda Spain-Butts?

When Shaq made the huge revelation about Corey and Amanda during the reunion, the duo's reaction to it was very interesting. While Amanda immediately got defensive and refuted Shaq's claims of confiding in him about anything, Corey instead kept quiet. Corey neither admitted nor denied it, leaving Amanda to fend for herself. Erin was beyond furious on hearing about the hookup, and she was further triggered by Corey's lack of reaction. 

Amanda then clarified that she never hooked up with Corey at any point during the show. She revealed that they did sleep in the same bed during the overnight date, but nothing transpired between them. When Erin asked her what hooking up meant to her, Amanda replied kissing and said they didn't kiss. Erin then confronted Corey for keeping all the details from her and slammed him for only admitting that he was texting and talking to Amanda four days prior to the reunion. 

Are Erin and Corey still together?

Finally, when Corey and Erin were asked if they still wanted to be with each other after learning about the hookup, Corey said yes. He explained that he wanted to be with Erin and grow old with her. But Erin declared that she didn't want to do this, and said she was going to 'walk away'.

Although Erin's response may seem like the couple split up, Corey threw a curveball by posting a picture of them together on his Instagram with a caption hinting at the couple still being together while the reunion was airing. In his post, he also subtly acknowledged that he had lied and hid things from his girlfriend but was hoping for her to forgive him.



 

He wrote, "The show might’ve ended but our journey continues. I know the person you are, you are kind, funny, and can light up any room you are in. You are a great person inside and out. And please never forget it. Tonights actions, whether it be understood or not, were justified. You were right. And I did hide and lie. But I’m sorry, and here’s to us continuing our growth and our love through thick n’ thin. I love you @esm0oth." Following the reunion, neither Corey nor Erin made any posts or comments about the current status of their relationship. So, we will just have to wait for them to finally clear up the air and reveal whether they are still seeing each other or not.

'Temptation Island' Season 3 is available for streaming on USA Network.

If you have an entertainment scoop or a story for us, please reach out to us on (323) 421-7515