'Snowpiercer' Season 2 Finale: Is Melanie a villain? Shocking theories debate why they don't sympathise with her

Fans know everything about Melanie's heroics, but there have been instances where people felt that she was more of a reluctant villain
Jennifer Connelly as Melanie in 'Snowpiercer' (TNT)
Jennifer Connelly as Melanie in 'Snowpiercer' (TNT)

Thrilling action, gutsy performances, and engaging storyline… Season 2 of ‘Snowpiercer’ had all the ingredients of turning out to be one of the best shows out there. The characters are battling it out against each other to take the control of the train. Meanwhile, one of the characters who have been missing from all the action is Melanie. She went off the train and did a trek to the research station.
 
She has undoubtedly been one of the characters who has many layers and doesn’t shy away from showing any mercy to her critics. A lot of fans believe that she is menacing and has all the things to lead the train. Meanwhile, there are many who don’t like her and say that she deserves to be out of the show.

RELATED ARTICLES

'Snowpiercer' Season 2 Episode 6 Spoilers: Jennifer Connelly returns in Melanie Cavill-centric lonely adventure

'Snowpiercer' Season 2: Release date, plot, cast, trailer and all you need to know about new installment of TNT's dystopian drama


One of the things that made her unpopular among the fans was the way she ran the train when Wilford was not on the train during Season 1. From inheriting class prisons to the scenes where she tortures Josie, there have been times when Melanie felt like she is not what she seems to be.

Snowpiercer (TNT)


After seeing her actions, fans believe that she might be the real villain of the show and as a result, she should be out of the show. One of the Redditors said that she should have abolished the class system when she took charge of the train, but she did not.
 
“Yup right now she’s the villain. The tail really is illegal passengers but it doesn’t change the fact that life on the train is still severely unfair. Since the old system of the class division had undeniably contributed to the freezing, they could and should abandon it while on the train, in order to up the chances of surviving the catastrophe,” one Reddit user said.

Josie in 'Snowpiercer' (TNT)

Another user wrote, Yes. After the recent episode, undoubtedly. I really just can't feel sympathy for her anymore. She's still my favorite character but only because she's so interesting, not because I support her."

Another Redditor wrote, “I will call her the reluctant villain. She designed SnowPiercer and knows what it takes to maintain it. She realizes it's not a fair scenario and will do whatever it takes to maintain order. ‘We're Engineers. We keep the world alive’.

“The first few episodes, I didn't consider her villainous. But these last recent episodes have changed my opinion about that. She seems to be going crazy to maintain the train, but all the dark secrets have to spill at some point,” one post read.
 
Another user stated, “I definitely consider her a villain. She is perpetuating a horrible unjust society.”

Jennifer Connelly in 'Snowpiercer' (TNT)

 
The finale will finally tell the viewers if Melanie will survive or die in process of finding the appropriate locations for colonizing Earth. Will the makers take a chance in killing Melanie? Or they will take a safer route? We have to see the finale for getting all the answers to our questions.
 
‘Snowpiercer’ returns to TNT for Season 2 finale on Monday, March 29, at 9 pm ET.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Dutton family’s legendary ranch is now available for fans to rent, but it is sure to make a dent in their pockets.
7 hours ago
Ewan Mitchell is keeping fans guessing about Aemond’s future, teasing uncertainty over when the feared Targaryen prince will meet his fate in Season 3.
7 hours ago
With the 'Dutton Ranch' finale around the corner, Beulah ended up handing over the reins to her 10-Petal ranch to Rob Will instead of Joaquin.
12 hours ago
Rip Wheeler may still be around, but a surprising shift at the ‘Dutton Ranch’ suggests his once-untouchable role is no longer his alone.
12 hours ago
Fresh comments about Taylor Sheridan’s long-discussed ‘1944’ project have reignited speculation about the future of the ‘Yellowstone’ universe.
14 hours ago
Adam Remsen faces off against Deidre Purcell and Jacob Ross-Ewart on Friday’s episode of ‘Jeopardy!’.
14 hours ago
As ‘Sugar’ returns with a new case and bigger stakes, here's the latest update on whether Apple TV+ plans to bring the sci-fi detective drama back.
14 hours ago
The premiere episode of 'Sugar' Season 2 was titled 'Home Away From Home' and hinted that Sugar might be lonelier than ever.
1 day ago
The detective drama series premiered its first season in 2024 on Apple TV+, and after a fantastic debut season, it's back with Season 2.
1 day ago
The much-loved One Chicago shows are set to return on NBC this fall, and the network's latest announcement may help figure out the premiere date
1 day ago