'Our Little Secret’ Review: Lindsay Lohan's movie is a secret Netflix should have kept to itself

Lindsay Lohan starrer 'Our Little Secret' is a Christmas rom-com movie premiered on November 27
'Our Little Secret' features Lindsay Lohan, Jon Rudnitsky, and Ian Harding in lead roles (Netflix)
'Our Little Secret' features Lindsay Lohan, Jon Rudnitsky, and Ian Harding in lead roles (Netflix)

Lindsay Lohan is back again with another Netflix holiday movie, and honestly, at this point, it's starting to feel like a Christmas tradition. 'Our Little Secret' is part of her multi-movie deal with Netflix, which began with 'Falling for Christmas' in 2022, followed by 'Irish Wish' in March of this year. These three movies have one thing in common- they all are rom-coms. Unfortunately, with each film, the warmth and charm seem to fade, leaving fewer genuine smiles behind.

In 'Our Little Secret', Lohan plays Avery, who visits her boyfriend, Cameron's (Jon Rudnitsky) family for Christmas. But when she finds out that her ex-boyfriend, Logan (Ian Harding) is dating Cameron's sister, Cassie (Katie Baker), she decides to hide their romantic history. The initial awkwardness between the two, followed by them pairing up to keep their secret intact stretches out to absurd levels.

Good luck finding romance or comedy in 'Our Little Secret'

Lindsay Lohan, Ian Harding, and Katie Baker in 'Our Little Secret' (Netflix)
Lindsay Lohan, Ian Harding, and Katie Baker in 'Our Little Secret' (Netflix)

I love Christmas movies for their light-hearted moments infused with love, hope and fun. I had my popcorns ready as soon as 'Our Little Secret' premiered on Netflix. But oh boy, the disappointment I felt by the end is something I struggle to put into words.

How bad could it be, you may ask! Well, it's a rom-com movie, with, no awe-worthy romance and literally not a single scene that could make you chuckle, let alone ignite a laughter. Every potential comic scene falls flat and even Lindsay Lohan's could save it.

There's absolutely no chemistry between any of the couples. The cast radiates no energy, and it feels like they’re just there to read their lines, rushing to wrap up and go home. Never thought I would say this, but 'Hot Frosty' should be a lesson on how to ignite some strong emotions even if the plot is extremely silly.

'Our Little Secret' is a total cringe fest

Dan Bucatinsky and Kristin Chenoweth in 'Our Little Secret' (Netflix)
Dan Bucatinsky and Kristin Chenoweth in 'Our Little Secret' (Netflix)

Even if I try too hard to find some positive aspects of the film, I would fail. Kristin Chenoweth is the only bright energy in the film as she plays Cameron’s overly critical mother, Erica. But it doesn't make up for the bad writing and dull performances. Be it Avery getting stoned or Logan catching the two elders making out, 'Our Little Secret' continues to deliver one cringe scene after the other and I regret why I didn't give up on it sooner.

Lohan fails to bring out her charm amid movie’s confusing tone and lackluster script. All the characters are quite bland and don't add warmth to the narrative. So, if you were planning to watch it this holiday season, be ready for major disappointment. Or else, skip this and go back to watching some classic Christmas flicks.

'Our Little Secret' is now available to stream on Netflix

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The latest 'Hunger Games' prequel revisits Haymitch's brutal Second Quarter Quell and reunites Jennifer Lawrence, Josh Hutcherson and Woody Harrelson.
2026-11-19T19:35:05.000Z
Jeff Bezos reveals why he personally backed Robert Pattinson for James Bond after the actor impressed during screen tests.
2026-11-19T13:01:29.000Z
Originally Jack’s bodyguard, Hannah ends up pretending to be his girlfriend as he visits his hometown during Christmas.
2026-11-19T10:40:35.000Z
‘The Traveler’ follows a 47-year-old computer programmer whose commute to work takes an unexpected turn
2026-11-19T07:04:37.000Z
Vin Diesel reunites with action as a cemetery groundskeeper in his upcoming action thriller
2026-11-19T04:00:25.000Z
Originally released in March 2026, the film earned over $600 million worldwide and received positive reviews from audiences and critics
2026-11-19T03:29:04.000Z
Nearly two decades later, Jason is ready to return. Here's what we know about his next movie
2026-11-18T20:00:17.000Z
Denis Villeneuve opens up about the qualities he wanted in his new 007.
2026-11-18T19:56:17.000Z
‘The Comeback King’ trailer sends Glen Powell’s country singer back to college after a breakup scandal involving Madelyn Cline’s pop star.
2026-11-18T17:39:32.000Z
Brad Pitt wants to play Robert Pattinson's villain in Denis Villeneuve's 'James Bond' movie
2026-11-18T03:38:08.000Z