Murder in a Small Town's 'creepy' character lauded for his 'Emmy-worthy performance'

'Succession' star's guest appearance in FOX's 'Murder in a Small Town' Episode 1 leaves viewers impressed
'Murder in a Small Town' has quickly become a favorite among viewers, and there are more than one reason (@fox/@kaileyschwerman)
'Murder in a Small Town' has quickly become a favorite among viewers, and there are more than one reason (@fox/@kaileyschwerman)

Contains spoilers for 'Murder in a Small Town' Episode 1

BRITISH COLUMBIA, CANADA: 'Murder in a Small Town' has been an instant hit among fans, and there is more than one reason. The debut episode, aired on Fox on Tuesday, September 24, not only hooked viewers with its gripping murder mystery but also with the budding romance between Karl Alberg (Rossif Sutherland) and Cassandra Mitchell (Kristin Kreuk). However, what stood out was the performance by the show's guest star, James Cromwell.

Cromwell appears as George Wilcox, a neighbor of Carlyle Burke, who is found dead under mysterious circumstances in the opening moments of the show. The 84-year-old veteran, who appeared in Apple TV+'s 'Sugar' earlier this year hits it out of the park with his performance in 'Murder in a Small Town'.

Fans assemble to praise the 'legend' in 'Murder in a Small Town'

James Cromwell, Kristin Kreuk, and Rossif Sutherland in 'Murder in a Small Town' (Fox/@kaileyschwerman)
James Cromwell, Kristin Kreuk, and Rossif Sutherland in 'Murder in a Small Town' (@fox/@kaileyschwerman)

Cromwell plays a complex character in the FOX series, deeply shaken by his neighbor's death, yet it's clear from the start that he's hiding something. Soon, the evidence starts to point at him and Karl discovers a motive behind the crime too. However, it becomes clear that George isn't entirely a villain. He has a traumatic past where he saw his mother in an abusive marriage followed by his sister Audrey suffering through similar ordeals.

George also shares a very unlikely bond with Cassandra, primarily because she looks similar to his dead sister, Audrey. James Cromwell does an excellent job portraying the complex layers of the character. On X, one fan wrote, "James Cromwell with an Emmy Winning Performance as George Wilcox and it’s only the first episode."



 

Cromwell, for his role in 'Succession', has won three Primetime Emmy Award nominations for Outstanding Guest Actor. Praising the actor, another fan wrote, "It's the Legend James Cromwell everybody." Another fan added, "James Cromwell is always playing creepy characters. He was a creep on Organized Crime."



 



 

A fan praised 'Murder in a Small Town' in a post, saying, "I liked it a lot. Extra points for having James Cromwell on episode 1." Another fan wrote, "I liked it too. I’ll be back. James Cromwell is great in everything he does."



 



 

Will James Cromwell return in upcoming episodes of 'Murder in a Small Town'?

James Cromwell in 'Murder in a Small Town' (Fox/@kaileyschwerman)
James Cromwell in a still from 'Murder in a Small Town' (@fox/@kaileyschwerman)

It's most likely that Cromwell won't return in the subsequent episodes of 'Murder in a Small Town'. He was introduced as a guest star on the show and his role was fully explored in the debut episode itself.

As the murder mystery gets solved by the end of the episode and George's fate is revealed, expectations for his return remain low. However, it would truly be a treat for the fans if he does make brief appearances. Each episode will bring a new case, while the weekly releases will be tied by the common thread of Karl and Cassandra's evolving romance.

'Murder in a Small Town' Episode 1 premiered on FOX on September 24 and will be available to stream on Hulu on September 25

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'The Gilded Age' is enjoying its strongest season yet, with viewership nearly 20% higher than the previous instalment
2026-11-19T20:50:24.000Z
This ‘Off Campus’ star reveals why his planned Season 2 return fell through, leaving questions about Allie and Dean’s story and his future.
2026-11-19T20:32:39.000Z
NBC reshuffles its Thursday lineup after 'Law & Order: SVU' celebrates its 600th episode, leaving fans waiting for the next instalment
2026-11-19T19:54:30.000Z
‘The Beast in Me’ expands its Season 2 cast as filming begins, with a ‘Daisy Jones & The Six’ reunion among the new additions.
2026-11-19T17:35:35.000Z
Eddie Redmayne’s assassin has unfinished business as ‘The Day of the Jackal’ Season 2 gets its first teaser and a fresh release update.
2026-11-19T15:55:05.000Z
Mary Jo’s present-day appearance gives Gibbs a new lead in his search for Lala, while fans wonder who will play her older self.
2026-11-19T14:26:35.000Z
Probie, who went out disgraced from Firehouse 51 earlier this season, will return to 'Chicago Fire'
2026-11-19T10:00:23.000Z
The teachers will accompany the school's Step Team on a trip to Disneyland Resort when the show returns
2026-11-19T09:18:50.000Z
Violet's fate hangs in the balance as her mother's heartbreaking request threatens her future
2026-11-19T08:02:33.000Z
The latest promo of 'Chicago Med' reveals why Dr Connor Rhodes is back at Gaffney after seven seasons
2026-11-19T06:00:35.000Z