Luke Bryan doubted him during auditions — but this ‘American Idol’ hopeful just made the Top 7

"No ne has ever proved me more wrong than you.” Luke Bryan backtracks on audition judgement of this singer.
PUBLISHED MAY 7, 2025
John Foster performing 'I Cross My Heart' during the Top 8 performance (Cover image source: YouTube | American Idol)
John Foster performing 'I Cross My Heart' during the Top 8 performance (Cover image source: YouTube | American Idol)

It's quite rare for a veteran judge of a show to admit their mistake. Luke Bryan has been a part of the judges' panel of 'American Idol' ever since season 16, which premiered in 2018. The country artist has been part of the show for eight seasons, and needless to say, he does understand 'Idol' material when he sees it. Bryan is considered to be one of the most critical judges of the American singing show, with the judge even being trolled for expressing odd facial expressions as singers performed.


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by John Foster (@officialjohnfoster)


 

However, something rare and unexpected happened as Bryan admitted to being wrong over his judgment of a singer. John Foster is an 18-year-old country singer who went full country mode with his performance during the 'Idol' auditions. While the judges did love his performance, Foster was asked to sing another song, which led to a very hesitant yes by Luke Bryan, who still wasn't sure if the 18-year-old was ready for the grand show. Fast forward to the top 10, with Foster proving time and time again that he deserves a place on 'American Idol.'



 

Foster performed his soulful rendition of 'Something To Talk About' by Bonnie Raitt, as reported by Fandom, as he was part of the top 10. The song was beautifully performed and beloved by the judges and the audience. In the end, Foster received enough votes to reach the top 8. The fanfare for the young country singer always donning a cowboy hat has been immense, which had fans believe that Foster would definitely make his way to the top 7. However, something unexpected happened before this. 



 

On the top 7 episode, which was also a Judges’ Song Contest, a round where each judge picks one song for the contestant to pick from without the contestant knowing who has given it. Foster performed 'I Cross My Heart' by George Strait, which was suggested by Carrie Underwood. The young 'Idol' aspirant's performance was so good that Bryan admitted to his audition blunder, stating, “I was doing my TikTok scroll daily, and I saw a clip of me saying I didn’t know if you could sing well enough back in your audition, and man, no one has ever proved me more wrong than you.”



 

This is not the first time Bryan has vouched for Foster. As reported by MassLive, when Foster was competing for his spot in the Top 14, Bryan yet again stated, "You’ve kind of been a wildcard for me the whole time, but what you just did there removed all doubts in my mind that you deserve to be here.”

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Despite the daytime talk show landscape being in steady decline, the popularity of 'The Drew Barrymore Show' keeps rising.
4 hours ago
The Sports Illustrated model joins an already stacked cast including Stephen Amell, Jessica Belkin, and Hassie Harrison for 'Baywatch' reboot.
5 hours ago
The series focuses on a love triangle as Clark Forrest (Jason Bateman) has an affair with Carol Smernitch (Linda Cardellini)
11 hours ago
The Netflix series will see Georgia confront her abusive past with her toxic parents in the upcoming season
12 hours ago
Dempsey plays Angelo Doyle, a hired-for-pay hitman, who races against time to find the Ferryman before his memory fails him
15 hours ago
Kayce, joined by Cruz and Cal, goes on his first official mission to stop a domestic terror attack in the second episode of 'Marshals'
16 hours ago
A CBS representative just gave fans an exciting update about Riley Green's much-awaited debut in the 'Yellowstone' spinoff
19 hours ago
Hassie Harrison plays Nat, a former foster kid turned Olympic athlete in the upcoming Fox lifeguard drama
2 days ago
'The Night Agent' Season 2 ended with Luciane Buchanan's Rose Larkin moving to California
2 days ago
Lana Condor joins ‘XO, Kitty’ Season 3, reprising Lara Jean alongside Anna Cathcart’s Kitty before the April Netflix premiere.
2 days ago