Is Cashay falling for Cinco again? 'Love Island' fans say they'll hate her if she dumps Charlie

'If cash leaves Charlie for cinco this will officially become a Cashay hate page #LoveIslandUSA,' wrote a fan

                            Is Cashay falling for Cinco again? 'Love Island' fans say they'll hate her if she dumps Charlie
'Love Island' stars Charlie Lynch, Cashay Proudfoot and Melvin Cinco Holland Jr (CBS)

Fan-favorite 'Love Island' contestant Cashay Proudfoot might soon earn a spot in the fans' black book if she continues to pursue Melvin Cinco Holland Jr. Frustrated fans watched for weeks as Cash found herself tangled in a messy love triangle with Trina Njoroge owing to Cinco's indecisiveness, and crying her heart out while Cinco and Trina were busy being affectionate with each other right under her nose. 

Although Cash was well aware that Cinco had long moved on with Trina, she still continued to have feelings for him. So right before Casa Amor, she expressed her interest in Cinco and made it clear that they had better chemistry together compared to the one between Trina and him. But Cinco continued to be indecisive and strung both Trina and Cash along during Casa Amor. While Trina continued to worry about her relationship with Cinco and its future, Cash thankfully opened her heart and made a great connection with Charlie Lynch during Casa Amor.


Does Melvin Cinco have a girl back home? 'Love Island' fans warn Trina Njoroge to stay away

Will Shannon and Josh win 'Love Island'? Fans say they are the most 'solid couple'

Melvin Cinco Holland Jr. is once again wooing Cashay Proudfoot after Casa Amor on 'Love Island' (CBS)

During Casa Amor recoupling, Cinco picked Trina while Cash brought back Charlie to the villa. This had fans heaving a sigh of relief thinking the messy love triangle was put to rest. Unfortunately, that wasn't the case. Cinco was reportedly shaken on seeing Cash with Charlie and realized that he had stronger feelings for her compared to Trina. So, he told Trina that he wanted to pursue Cash.

Although Cash was initially disappointed about Cinco not fighting for her while she was with Charlie, she was later pleased to see that he made his decision and was ready to pursue her. She once again began warming up to Cinco, and during a conversation, she expressed that she needed to get clarity on who to pick between Cinco and Charlie. She felt that although Charlie was a nice guy and treated her well, his energy didn't match hers. On the other hand, Cinco is everything she ever wanted.

When fans realized that Cash might be toying with the idea of going back to Cinco and falling for him all over again, they were far from pleased. A fan tweeted, "Although I feel like there’s something off about Charlie, I still might start a hate train if Cash pick Cinco #LoveIslandUSA." Another fan added, "If cash leaves Charlie for cinco this will officially become a Cashay hate page #LoveIslandUSA." "I love u cash but it’s getting to a point that I’m starting to really disliking her cause how can you still want cinco when charlie is giving you everything you was looking for. I’m just tired of seeing cash and cinco together at this point. #LoveIslandUSA," wrote a fan.




Cashay Proudfoot brought back Charlie Lynch to 'Love Island' villa after Casa Amor (CBS)

Many fans were also convinced that Cinco was just wooing Cash to win the $100,000 prize money. A fan shared, "Cash stans still tryna convince us that cash has pull with cinco. HE DOESN'T WANT HER EITHER. Its the money lmaooooooo #LoveIslandUSA." "Cinco lost interest in Trina when he learned they weren’t America’s favorite couple…Cinco is playing a game for money while Cash & Trina falling for his lies #loveislandusa," pointed another fan. "Omg cinco leave cash alone. He just want the money and Leave #LoveIslandUSA," echoed a fan.




'Love Island' Season 3 airs on Tuesday through Friday at 9 pm ET/PT on CBS. In addition, 'Love Island' will air on Sunday nights from 9 to 11 pm ET/PT for the remainder of the season. You can also stream the episodes on Paramount+.